Showing posts with label Southern Strategy. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Southern Strategy. Show all posts

Tuesday, September 26, 2017

Trump's Big NFL Blunder

The Democrats, even with their warmongering and their Wall Street agenda, have polled over 65 million votes in the last three presidential elections. Neither Trump, Romney nor McCain made it to 63 million.

But thanks to gerrymandering and the 200-plus-year-old gift to the slavocracy/plantocracy (Electoral College) Trump won the White House in 2016 by accumulating 304 electoral votes. He accomplished this primarily by flipping the industrial Midwest -- Michigan, Wisconsin, Ohio -- as well as Pennsylvania. 

I didn't think it was possible. I thought the Southern Strategy was dead in presidential politics. I thought Obama had killed it; plus, there is the overall demographic trend, summarized in the August Newsweek story, "WHITE NATIONALISTS ARE RIGHT: AMERICA IS BECOMING LESS WHITE":
Nevertheless, under the current racial demographics widely accepted across the U.S., white people have seen signs that their dominance over the general population might be waning. The Census Bureau announced in 2012 that non-Hispanic whites made up a minority of births in the U.S. for the first time. That year, minorities made up 50.4 percent of the nation's infants, in part because of a booming Hispanic population. 
Some demographers have predicted the U.S. will become a majority-minority nation by 2050, with African-Americans, Asians, Hispanics and other minority groups outnumbering the people we call white. 
The shift in the nation's racial demographics have already been stark. In 1965, whites represented 85 percent of the population, with the other 15 percent made up of African-Americans. These days, white people make up just 60 percent of the nation, while Hispanics account for 18 percent and Asians about 6 percent. 
"The forces behind this transformation are a mix of immigration, births and deaths. The United States is more than four decades into what has been, in absolute numbers, the biggest immigration wave in its history–more than 40 million arrivals. Unlike previous waves that were almost entirely from Europe, the modern influx has been dominated by Hispanic and Asian immigrants," the Pew Research Center concluded in 2012. 
But I also believed in an acute public disdain for the progressive charlatanism of Obama and Clinton; my mistake is I thought that there was enough reality to the mythical minivan piloting soccer mom that a TV huckster like Trump wouldn't stand a chance in Keystone State and America's Dairyland suburbs. Of course those were the voters who gave Trump his 'W.'

Now Trump is going all in with the Southern Strategy, which you will recall was Kevin Phillips' plan after the 1968 presidential election for Nixon to co-opt George Wallace voters (blue-collar, lunch-bucket Democrat bigots) for the GOP. 

Trump is going all in by attacking the last refuge of national identity in the United States, the National Football League. He is sowing division by questioning the "Americanism" of players, overwhelming black, who are protesting institutional racism by kneeling or raising a clenched fist during the pre-game performance of the national anthem.

Trump has done this in the belief that it is good politics, that NFL viewership is "way down" because fans are turned off by player activism. By demanding that these players be fired and calling them "sons of bitches," Trump is looking to fluff up his approval ratings.

But Trump has been gulled by "fake news," as Manuela Tobias susses out in a PolitiFact piece published Sunday. The polls which purportedly establish anthem protests as a main reason for people not watching football are a joke:
Trump spokesman Steven Cheung pointed to a Seton Hall Sports Poll that found that 56 percent of 841 respondents cited players not standing for the national anthem as a reason for last year’s ratings drop.
But as CNBC pointed out, the poll asked why other people — rather than respondents — aren't watching football. About half the people polled said they either follow sports "not closely" or "not at all," but coverage of Kaepernick’s kneeling was widely covered by the media.
A similar J.D. Power survey Cheung cited also reported national anthem protests as the main reason NFL fans watched less games last season.
"Among the 12 percent who watch less (sports), 26 percent of them say national anthem protests are to blame, however those respondents reflect only 3 percent of the full, nationwide sample," the researchers wrote.
Various pundits criticized the survey results as negligible, pointing out that for every one person turned off by protests, 10 NFL fans tuned in.
"If a larger share of respondents claimed they watched more NFL, the fact that NFL ratings were actually down last year is good enough reason to discard this survey as meaningless," Patrick Redford wrote in Deadspin.
Like the Seton Hall survey, the reasons for tuning out were offered as a list for respondents to choose from, so people weren’t necessarily offering the anthem protests on their own, and respondents could provide multiple answers.
Paulsen said that NFL rating drops aren’t unprecedented, with similar declines in the ‘80s, ‘90s and the first half of the 2000s.
"It’s only now that people are deciding it’s a political issue, that people are really focusing on it. There’s any number of reasons to believe that what’s happening right now is not necessarily political," Paulsen said, including a loss of interest among younger viewers.
NFL viewership is down, which Tobias' story acknowledges -- eight percent in 2016 (it was double that the first part of the season, but rebounded later) and on pace for an equal drop this year. And Trump is right when he says "Boring games yes," but wrong when he attributes ultra-nationalism as a primary reason for fans tuning out the NFL. Why? The ratings drop has hit other sports as well, and in those sports, like soccer, anthem protests are not an issue.

The foremost reason for the NFL ratings drop is lopsided games. Even when the games are competitive, there is very little consistent action. Why is this?  Money. Owners don't want to see high-priced quarterbacks taking unnecessary risks. The best game I saw on Sunday was Houston-New England because Texans rookie QB Deshaun Watson played with abandon.

As for secondary and tertiary causes of the ratings drop, I think the incessant militarism of NFL telecasts and the deepening knowledge, both popular and scientific, of CTE are bigger reasons than an offended patriotism.

Trump is a shrewd operator. He thinks by fracturing the present-day foundation of American national identity he will make some political hay. Patrick Martin of World Socialist Web Site ("Behind Trump’s attack on the NFL football players") sees Trump producing a "Reichstag fire":
Under conditions of mounting war threats against North Korea; the devastation of Puerto Rico, a US territory, by Hurricane Maria; and the near-collapse of the latest attempt by the Republican-controlled Congress to repeal Obamacare, the US president devoted 12 tweets in 30 hours to the observance of the national anthem at sporting events. No other event warranted such attention.
What took place last weekend arose from a deliberate decision by the president of the United States to weigh in against a long-running campaign of protest against police brutality and violence, especially against African-American youth. Trump sought to provoke as much outrage as possible, particularly among the black athletes, who comprise 75 percent of NFL teams, and in that way arouse his ultra-right and fascistic social base.
Trump does not care that his positions are massively unpopular, or that the players have widespread support. He is not seeking to assemble an electoral or parliamentary majority, but to whip up a lynch-mob atmosphere within a minority of the population, which can be directed towards the violent suppression of any public opposition to the policies of his government, and particularly against opposition to the actions of the police and military.
Trump’s last tweet on Monday morning was perhaps the most brazenly racist, as he hailed the performance of NASCAR race drivers, nearly all white, contrasting the absence of protests at Sunday’s race in New Hampshire to the actions of football players, who protested in large numbers at 15 game sites.
This isn't 1933. Trump isn't the president of the Confederate States of America. Going after the NFL was a big mistake. At this point -- four autumns before the next presidential election -- I think Trump is doomed.

Tuesday, June 7, 2016

Hillary Wins

Any doubt should be put to rest this morning about Stathis Kouvelakis' statement mentioned a couple weeks back, that with the erosion of support for major parties throughout the West the corporate media has filled the void to prevent a more precipitous collapse of the status quo. On the eve of the final day of primary voting, the Associated Press preordained the outcome and announced that the Democratic nominee would be Hillary Clinton (Amy Chozick and Patrick Healy, "Hillary Clinton Has Clinched Democratic Nomination, Survey Reports").

Based on the polling, it did not appear as if Hillary was in any serious danger of losing California to Bernie Sanders, particularly given the fact that last week she received the endorsement of longtime California Governor Jerry Brown. So this AP "rush to judgment," as the Sanders campaign is calling it, seems like paranoid overkill. Possibly the intent is to create a situation in the six states voting today where Hillary will walk away with enough pledged delegates (the AP report had to do with superdelegates) to prevent Bernie from contesting the nomination at the Democratic National Convention in Philadelphia. Sanders has predicted that Hillary will not have enough pledged delegates after today's vote, and that, on this basis, he will march his children's crusade to Philly.

One thing is certain, to me at least. This primary campaign has illuminated the extent to which U.S. society is a closed one. It took a billionaire schooled for decades in the most brutal, omniscient media market on the planet to break through. But, if last week is any indication, Trump will be sliced and diced before August is over.

Hillary, competing in her fourth presidential campaign, did several things well, given how tarnished a candidate she is. Though her Super Tuesday "Southern strategy" did not work exactly as planned, because it was designed to knock Bernie out of the race, it will likely end up providing her the margin of victory she needs in pledged delegates; also, it cemented the narrative that black voters overwhelming favor her. Most importantly, Hillary proved an adroit manager of Democratic Party machinery, including the big international unions, and the corporate media monopoly.

Monday, September 7, 2015

The Future of Work + Hillary's Suicidal Southern Strategy + the Biden Decoy

On this Labor Day, give yourself a sense of the perilous times we are in by scanning the weekly Popular Resistance newsletter put together by Kevin Zeese and Margaret Flowers. What jumped out at me is "The Future of Work" section:
The Future of Work 
There are some major trends that indicate we are in the midst of a radical transformation of what work means and how people will have income. 
The most significant trend involves robotics, artificial intelligence and software that will do most current jobs. The research firm Gartner predicts that “one in three jobs will be converted to software, robots and smart machines by 2025.” Oxford University researchers estimate that 47 percent of U.S. jobs could be automated by 2033.  Already the official unemployment rate hides the fact only 63% of working-age adults are actually working. 
These changes are happening alongside the demise of unions and worker power; as well as globalization resulting in lost jobs and a race to the bottom of low paid workers.  Workers are already in politically and economically weak positions to survive the onslaught of robots. 
It is time for these issues to rise to the top.  The transformation of jobs and what to do about them is not even discussed in the 2016 elections, other than reforms like raising poverty wages. A broader discussion is needed.
The authors go on to advocate for a universal basic income and worker cooperatives.

One thing is for sure, the economy is not working for most people. Official unemployment is down to 5.1 percent, what many mainstream economists believe to be the "natural" rate of unemployment, but wages are still broadly stagnant. This fact is succinctly explained in Doug Smith's "Labor Day? Let's Tell the Truth and Call It 'Assets Day' ": "Take heart. Through your self-denial, executives, owners, and shareholders have grabbed all the productivity gains of the past quarter century for themselves."

Krugman's Labor Day column, "Trump Is Right on Economics," addresses the root of Trump's popularity: He is the only Republican addressing this issue of the systemic lack of work in the globalized neoliberal economy:
And here’s what’s interesting: all indications are that Mr. Bush’s attacks on Mr. Trump are falling flat, because the Republican base doesn’t actually share the Republican establishment’s economic delusions.
The thing is, we didn’t really know that until Mr. Trump came along. The influence of big-money donors meant that nobody could make a serious play for the G.O.P. nomination without pledging allegiance to supply-side doctrine, and this allowed the establishment to imagine that ordinary voters shared its antipopulist creed. Indeed, Mr. Bush’s hapless attempt at a takedown suggests that his political team still doesn’t get it, and thinks that pointing out The Donald’s heresies will be enough to doom his campaign. 
But Mr. Trump, who is self-financing, didn’t need to genuflect to the big money, and it turns out that the base doesn’t mind his heresies. This is a real revelation, which may have a lasting impact on our politics. 
Again, I’m not making a case for Mr. Trump. There are lots of other politicians out there who also refuse to buy into right-wing economic nonsense, but who do so without proposing to scour the countryside in search of immigrants to deport, or to rip up our international economic agreements and start a trade war. The point, however, is that none of these reasonable politicians is seeking the Republican presidential nomination.
Like Trump, Bernie Sanders is also bringing the neoliberal temple down, except for the Democratic half of the duopoly. Sanders only gets a fraction of the media attention though; nonetheless, at this point, the Clinton camp has basically acknowledged that it is going to lose Iowa and New Hampshire. That was the point of yesterday's "Hillary Clinton Relying on Southern Primaries to Fend Off Rivals," by Patrick Healy and Amy Chozick:
Hillary Rodham Clinton’s presidential campaign is methodically building a political firewall across the South in hopes of effectively locking up the Democratic nomination in March regardless of any early setbacks in the Iowa caucuses and the New Hampshire primary.
Mrs. Clinton’s advisers, struck by the strength of Senator Bernie Sanders in those two states, have been assuring worried supporters that victories and superdelegate support in Southern states will help make her the inevitable nominee faster than many Democrats expect. They point to her popularity with black and Hispanic voters, as well as her policy stances and the relationships that she and her husband, former President Bill Clinton, have cultivated. Mrs. Clinton was similarly confident at this point eight years ago, before Barack Obama and his superior organizers began piling up delegates, including in many Southern states.
In interviews, advisers said the campaign was increasingly devoting staff members and money to win the South Carolina primary on Feb. 27 while laying the groundwork to sweep Alabama, Arkansas, Georgia, Oklahoma, Tennessee, Texas and Virginia on March 1. Those Super Tuesday states are highlighted in red on maps in the offices of Mrs. Clinton’s senior aides in Brooklyn.
The eight primaries will deliver several hundred delegates for Mrs. Clinton, advisers believe, toward the goal of more than 2,200 needed to clinch the Democratic nomination. The campaign is barraging superdelegates in the South with requests for support — sometimes even jumping the gun by sending pledge forms prematurely — in hopes of adding scores of these party leaders who can bring their votes to the Clinton column at the Democratic National Convention.
The Southern firewall also includes Florida, Louisiana, Mississippi and North Carolina, which vote through mid-March. If Mrs. Clinton wins big in the Michigan and Ohio primaries that month, her advisers and supporters believe, the nomination will essentially be hers (though crossing the total delegate threshold takes time).
In order to sew up the nomination, Hillary is relying on votes in states Democrats have slim chance of winning in 2016, votes based on ignorance of Bernie Sanders' positions vis-a-vis Clinton's. This is her "Southern Strategy." If it is to pay off and she is to win the nomination, it will almost certainly be a Pyrrhic victory. Winning a nomination based on the ignorance of voters who reside in states most of which will not be in play for Dems next year is a prescription for disaster. How can Hillary juice turnout and return the Obama coalition to the polls if she is relying on public ignorance and superdelegates to push her across the finish line?

As for the Biden, after reading the coverage of his jaunt to Florida and Georgia, it is clear to me he is not going to run. Seventy-two is 72 and not an age that allows for a late-entry, come-from-behind win of a presidential nomination. Biden exists as a decoy to keep rank-and-file Democrats from giving Bernie a look and thereby to keep as many Dem voters on the Clinton reservation as possible. Clinton's support is fast disappearing. To slow things down the Democrat power elite have introduced a Biden mirage.

Friday, May 1, 2015

Hippies vs. Punks: The Drive-By Truckers' Southern Rock Opera


In this morning of May Day, a day devoted to the rites of spring and the rights of working people, it is time to approach Hippies vs. Punks from a different angle.

My tendency of late has been to lean heavily on the recordings of one of the most productive and creative bands of the last 15 years. I speak here of the Drive-By Truckers.

For the last month or so, on the train ride home on Friday after another debilitating work week has been crossed off the calendar, I have plugged into Decoration Day (2003).

If you want a stepping-off point for an introduction to the Drive-By Truckers, Decoration Day is a good place to start. It is the band's fourth album. From there I would move backward or hop to the first record, Ganstabilly (1998) and then move forward to Pizza Deliverance (1999):


Before arriving at the third album, the masterful Southern Rock Opera (2001).

Southern Rock Opera is a two-disk tour de force exploration of Lynyrd Skynyrd, George Wallace, classic rock, and the "Southern Thing." It is worthy of lengthy study. The first disk is the more analytic, dense one of the pair. You can kind of get it all in one gulp with the cut "The Three Great Alabama Icons":


Disk two is a straight-up display of pure power. I have probably played disk two as much as any album over the last five years. It speaks to the enduring power of classic rock. Patterson Hood sums it up perfectly in the first track, "Let There Be Rock":


And here we have arrived at a golden truth of Hippies vs. Punks. The clash between Hippies and Punks in the late 1970s is more a mirage of historical perception than an actual moment in the Zeitgeist. Though I think such a moment does exist, and, as I have argued elsewhere, it takes place during the summer of 1976 and then plays out primarily in the years 1977 and 1978, the real clash is earlier in the 1970s. It's less a clash than a retreat from the field of battle.

Southern rock rises, first with the The Allman Brothers Band, and then with Lynyrd Skynyrd and ZZ Top; as does Glitter/Glam and Disco. All enervate the Hippies, or point to an abandonment of the belief in a broad social transformation.

This coincides with the rise of classic rock. "Sex, drugs and rock 'n' roll." Hedonism absent the goal of liberation from capitalism.

Classic rock is perfectly exemplified by two massive radio hits from 1974: Skynyrd's "Sweet Home Alabama" and Eric Clapton's cover of Marley's "I Shot the Sheriff":




I remember driving along in a Chevy El Camino pickup truck with my father and sister listening to both the summer of 1974. I remember one evening pulling into the driveway of our home, and my father turning off the engine but leaving the radio on. The three of us sat in the dark and listened to "Sweet Home Alabama." It was a powerful new narcotic in 1974.

Nixon was on his way out of the White House. But his "Southern Strategy," as promulgated by a young Kevin Phillips, remains in control of the country to this day. Phillips' idea was to co-opt for the GOP George Wallace's third-party American Independent Party electoral base by tapping the rich vein of white working class resentment and paranoia over any modest material gains for the African-American underclass.

Now, nearly half a century later, the cities are still burning and Dixie has a stranglehold on Congress.

But if you listen to the Drive-By Truckers and the band's truth-telling about white Red State America -- the failed marriages, the alcoholism and drug abuse, the dead-end jobs, the girlfriends faking orgasms, Santa Claus raping his reindeer -- you realize that the white underclass is no different than any other underclass, black or brown, red or yellow.

It is the politicians and the Fourth Estate that pit us against each other so that the plutocrats can continue to call the shots. Maybe there is enough room left within the exhausted neoliberal paradigm -- maybe there is enough juice left in classic rock -- that we can undergo a shift in consciousness, and social transformation will once again become an aspiration of the masses.

Monday, April 1, 2013

Born in the Golden State Suburbs

The present day hard-shell Republican Party began its rise in the California suburbs of the 1960's. Goldwater's landslide loss to LBJ in 1964 is usually where people start. And there's some merit to that. Goldwater carried five states from the Deep South, almost the same five that third-party candidate George Wallace carried four years later (Goldwater won South Carolina; Wallace, Arkansas). This prompted Nixon to launch his Southern Strategy, which rapidly accelerated the conversion of the Republican Party.

But the first big win for the new, hard-shell type of Republican was when Ronald Reagan demolished incumbent Pat Brown in the California gubernatorial election of 1966. Then in 1978 there was Howard Jarvis' anti-tax uprising enshrined in California's Proposition 13. Reagan's ascension to the presidency two years later shocked many but it shouldn't have. The handwriting was on the wall for all to see.

Paul Krugman's column today, "Lessons From a Comeback," floats an argument that has merit. Since California is a bellwether of conservative Republicanism shouldn't we be paying attention to what's happening in the Golden State? And what's happening there is that the GOP has dwindled to such a small number that they can no longer block, even with supermajority rules, any and all legislation. As Krugman says,
California isn’t a state in which liberals have run wild; it’s a state where a liberal majority has been effectively hamstrung by a fanatical conservative minority that, thanks to supermajority rules, has been able to block effective policy-making. 
And that’s where things get really interesting — because the era of hamstrung government seems to be coming to an end. Over the years, California’s Republicans moved right as the state moved left, yet retained political relevance thanks to their blocking power. But at this point the state’s G.O.P. has fallen below critical mass, losing even its power to obstruct — and this has left Mr. Brown free to push an agenda of tax hikes and infrastructure spending that sounds remarkably like the kind of thing California used to do before the rise of the radical right. 
And if this agenda is successful, it will have national implications. After all, California’s political story — in which a radicalized G.O.P. fell increasingly out of touch with an increasingly diverse and socially liberal electorate, and eventually found itself marginalized — is arguably playing out with a lag on the national scene too. 
So is California still the place where the future happens first? Stay tuned.
Nationally the radical right's control of the House of Representatives appears to be on more solid footing -- because of the gerrymander and Citizens United. The House gives them all the structure they need to block and stymie for the foreseeable future; that, and they also control the Supreme Court. So anything progressive that squeaks through the legislature will be overturned by the judiciary.

Let's see how the GOP manages immigration reform. After the 2012 presidential election Republicans know they cannot win another national contest polling as low they do with Latinos. If they botch immigration, they'll likely be blocked from controlling the executive for a long time. But, really, why should hard-shell conservatives care? They're getting almost all of what they want with the current set up.

Wednesday, December 5, 2012

GOP Budget Strategy

Ever since William Greider's interview with David Stockman appeared thirty-one years ago the basic goals of the post-Nixon Republican Party have been on full public display.  First, bring down the top tax rates; second, blow up the debt in order to cut back social programs down the line.

This is what we're dealing with in the fiscal cliff, coming to terms with decades of entrenched conservative thinking and governance.  Combine this with the collapse of the Southern Strategy for winning presidential elections and you get a sense of the high stakes at play for Republicans.
We're at one of those unique moments when change is afoot.  The bedrock of national GOP hegemony is breaking.

Today's front page offering from Jonathan Weisman adds a lot of necessary detail to the negotiations.  Apparently -- I didn't know this -- we're going to reach the national debt limit again sometime next month or the month after.  This is the ace in the hole for the GOP.  The threat of a default worked well for them last year.  It caused a meltdown in the Dow and forced Obama to heel.  They will not bargain this away.  Worst case scenario for Republican strategists: sail off the cliff January 1; wait until a vote to raise the borrowing limit; then extort deep cuts in Medicare and Social Security plus a return of the Bush tax cuts.  It's an apocalyptic option, but, as Weisman points out, most Republicans in the House feel secure:
Popular opinion seems to be running against the Republicans. Most Americans support higher taxes on the rich, and a poll by The Washington Post and the Pew Research Center released Tuesday found that 53 percent say Republicans in Congress would and should be blamed if Washington fails to reach a deal before January. Just 27 percent said Mr. Obama would deserve more blame, while 12 percent say both sides would share the blame equally.

Most Republicans do not want tax rates to rise on anyone, and such national polls have little sway over House members in districts drawn to favor one party over the other. In November, 204 Republicans — 88 percent of the House Republican Conference — won at least 55 percent of the vote, according to David Wasserman, a House analyst at The Cook Political Report. Thirty-five of them won at least 70 percent.
The estate tax increase is huge.  Inheritances over $5 million currently taxed at 35 percent will go up to 55 percent for estates over $1 million.  This is a wild card.  It might be enough leverage for Obama to get a deal before December 31.

Can a Republican Party, rife with Birchers and cracker nostalgia, exorcise its Mad Mullah spirit?