Monday, December 10, 2018

Theresa May, Putschist + NYT Continues Attack on al-Saud

Well, I suppose I might have been incorrect last week when I opined that British democracy was not more dysfunctional than the American variety.

After repeatedly assuring the public last week that the momentous Brexit vote in parliament would proceed on schedule for Tuesday, December 11, BBC is reporting, based on insider accounts, that May will postpone the vote.

"The report that May could cancel the vote came just hours after the top EU court ruled that Britain could cancel its notice to leave the bloc, which it is due to exit on March, 29."

May's path forward appears to be another trip to Brussels to plead for additional concessions. Why would the EU oblige her? Clearly May's only goal is to extend the life of her split, unpopular government and prevent new elections. The zombie plods on!

Checking with Yves Smith this morning, she lists the probable outcomes if May's vote had failed tomorrow:
  • May could face a vote of no confidence in the Commons. Kier Starmer has said that Labour would table a vote, but with the DUP stating that they would support the Conservatives in such a vote, this is unlikely to succeed. If the Government did fall, there would be 14 days for another Government to win a vote of confidence in the Commons, or the country will have a General Election.
  • Conservative MPs put in 48 letters, and the party has to have a confidence vote in the Prime Minister. If 48 letters go in, this would require a swift vote of confidence, where May must win more than 50 per cemt of the 315 eligible MPs. If she lost, the party then has to elect a new leader. Given the incredibly short timescale before 29th March, the Conservative Party would be signing its own death warrant to do this.
  • Labour tries to table a censure motion about May – this is effectively a personal vote of no confidence in the Prime Minister, which is what happened recently to Chris Grayling. This would potentially allow Tory MPs to vote against the May without bringing down the Government. However the Government is under no obligation to provide time for an Opposition Day before Christmas, so this is unlikely to happen.
  • The Prime Minister goes to negotiate with Brussels and brings back an amended deal. This would then require the Government to win a vote on its renegotiated deal, using the procedure outlined above. If no negotiated deal can pass through the Commons the UK will leave the EU without a deal.
For the last several weeks the scenario of choice floated in the pages of the mainstream press has been for May to lose the initial vote in parliament, but not by a disastrous margin, at which point she would proclaim renewed determination for a better deal and off to Brussels she would go.

That scenario started to disintegrate at the end of last week when it became apparent that May had been lying to the public about what exactly her Brexit deal with the EU entailed. Most MPs could not be seen to publicly support it. It was headed for a huge defeat in parliament.

So, despite numerous promises that the vote would go on, May is skipping the "lose round one" part of the scenario and, apparently, proceeding directly to the return to Brussels kabuki.

The shortcoming of May's about-face is that it deprives her coalition government, already living on borrowed time, of the last shred of credibility. May has zero credibility. The mainstream media can no longer shield her. 

A sort of putsch is underway where the Tories and the DUP are trying to lock in a crash-out. That's the only thing that makes sense at this point, above and beyond blocking snap elections. But the only way that's possible, given the EU ruling that Britain can simply cancel its notice to leave the bloc, is for the Tory coalition government to stay in power until March 29. Given all that has transpired since Chequers, to accomplish this will require a putsch.

Once again, as this latest Brexit episode illustrates, the zombie neoliberal paradigm refuses to be defeated. We are reminded again and again by those in power that there is no alternative. Use this lens to look at the unfolding events in France.

****

Yesterday The New York Times devoted prominent placement in its cultural aircraft carrier, the Sunday edition, to two weighty, significant attacks on the House of Saud: the front-page account, "The Wooing of Jared Kushner: How the Saudis Got a Friend in the White House," of how Trump arrived at his main foreign policy initiative via a November 2016 meeting between son-in-law Jared Kushner and a Saudi delegation of high-raking officials; and Nicholas Kristof's must-read "Your Tax Dollars Help Starve Children," which thoroughly demolishes the U.S. case for assisting the Saudi-UAE coalition's war on Yemen.

Sunday, December 9, 2018

Expect More Violence

The size of the protests are reported to have shrunk for Gilets Jaunes Act IV yesterday, yet the number of arrests more than tripled, from a little over 400 nationwide last week to nearly 1,400. So something doesn't quite add up.

Preventative detention no doubt was employed by the gendarmerie. But that won't stuff the Yellow Vests genie back in its bottle. We're probably looking at more force delivered by the state because the rebellion will continue. (Colonel Cassad thinks so.)

The mainstream media is beginning to shift its coverage of the Yellow Vests from sympathy to fear. More quotes of men and women on the Parisian street expressing consternation at the disruption of daily life.

At least the stories in The New York Times and Reuters both highlighted that the protests have shifted from demands that the fuel tax be repealed, which was accomplished last week, to demands that Macron resign.

Macron's election in 2017 was the singular spectacular achievement of a collapsing zombie neoliberal world order post-Brexit (post-Ghouta?). He will not go easily. Expect more state violence, if not a state of emergency.

Friday, December 7, 2018

Gilets Jaunes Act IV Tomorrow

Tomorrow the Yellow Vest rebellion in France stages "Act IV."

Macron has promised a major address to the nation next week. He has already capitulated on the fuel tax which sparked the uprising. Prominent Yellow Vest demands now include an increased minimum wage, a more robust retirement and Macron's resignation.

Close to 100,000 police will be on duty Saturday. It's conceivable that another violent weekend could prompt a state of emergency. Macron is running out of options. His approval rating is at 18%. He's promoting the idea that tomorrow will be violent.

Another indication of how dire things are for Macron is a story by Adam Nossiter, Paris correspondent for The New York Times. "How France’s ‘Yellow Vests’ Differ From Populist Movements Elsewhere" could have appeared in Jacobin. It's one of those rare instances where the mainstream mirrors the fringe. What makes it even more noteworthy is that Nossiter, though not as rabid in defense of the zombie neoliberal status quo as NYT's Rome bureau chief Jason Horowitz, puffed Macron shamelessly from the outset of the last presidential campaign. Now, as you can see, things have turned:
The uprising is instead mostly organic, spontaneous and self-determined. It is mostly about economic class. It is about the inability to pay the bills.
In that regard, it is more Occupy than Orban — more akin to the protests against Wall Street driven by the working poor in the United States than the race-based, flag-waving of Hungary’s increasingly authoritarian leader, Viktor Orban.
[snip]
“There’s this social distress that exists more or less everywhere,” said Marc Lazar, a specialist in Italian history at Sciences Po. “Of people who are very worried about the future, not only are they suffering, but they have profound distrust of institutions and political parties. This is what we are seeing everywhere in Europe.”
Comparing the four countries — Britain, France, Italy and the United States — Christophe Guilluy, a French geographer who has studied the demographics of the “left-behinds,” said “the sociology of the people in revolt is the same.”
“These are the people who feel endangered by the current economic model,” which doesn’t “integrate the greatest number,” he said.
[snip]
But [Macron's] base, then and now, was exceedingly small, presaging his current wide rejection by the French, not just by the Yellow Vests. He won only 24 percent of the vote in the first round of voting last year — while his opponents on the far right and far left together won over 40 percent of the vote. Those numbers have now come home to haunt Mr. Macron in a political landscape where nearly eight out of 10 French citizens no longer support him, according to a recent poll.
Occupy never went away. It has always been here since 2011. The Brexit vote got defined as primarily a response to the refugee crisis in Europe, which was less an issue of immigration and more about warfare run amok in the Middle East thanks to United States; but the Brexit vote had just as much to do with the Brussels-backed, German-enforced regime of neoliberal austerity as it did immigration. Now Briton Leavers are waking up to the fact that the people in charge of Brexit have no intention of working towards equality in a new Little England.

I have been telling people that the events in France and England offer a ray of sunshine as we head into winter. Though we seem to be hurtling back to the medieval, with hostage-taking of rival economic royals, the dialectic is churning forward away from zombie neoliberalism.

Thursday, December 6, 2018

May's Government Falls Next Week

The big Brexit story today is that May will not delay next Tuesday's vote in parliament. Ministers in May's government are panicked that the withdrawal agreement will be defeated by a 100-vote margin. They were lobbying for a delay because that significant a defeat would almost certainly lead to the collapse of the government.

Yves Smith is starting to row back the "likely scenario"of May losing next week's vote by a margin small enough to allow the prime minister one more trip to Brussels for more ceremonial haggling. Now Smith is almost at the point of adopting May's talking points: It's crash-out or the Brexit withdrawal agreement on the table. Take your pick.

My sense is that the publication of the government's legal advice -- that Northern Ireland would be, for all intents and purposes, separated from the United Kingdom in perpetuity -- means the DUP can longer support May. The government should fall next week. That's the obvious conclusion. If this does not happen it means that British democracy is even more dysfunctional than democracy in the United States. And that is not the case. So mark your calendar. Finally, May's coalition government, after a year-and-a-half in power, comes down.

Wednesday, December 5, 2018

War Drums in Lebanon & Ukraine + INF Treaty + Zombie May + "Smoking Saw"

There are warnings of an Israeli attack on Lebanon, as well as a Ukrainian attack on Donetsk People’s Republic (DPR) in Donbass.

****

Colonel Cassad assesses the U.S. ultimatum to Russia on the INF treaty. Not good.

****

The first test of strength for May's Brexit plan got off to a shaky start in parliament yesterday. Yves Smith jousts against the conventional and opines that May actually fared pretty well:
May may survive next week. Even though her bill will be shellacked, the margin of loss on the contempt vote is a reminder that the Tories will be loath to oppose her if there isn’t a viable leader in the wings. And the reason May is still standing is that there hasn’t been one since she became PM. The Tories do not want Corbyn in, and the DUP does not want to sacrifice its temporary power player role. So the DUP and Tories will vote against May only if they are pretty certain they can quickly install a new PM and avoid a general election.
The scenario that appears to be coming together is that May loses next week but not by an enormous margin. She survives to trudge off to Brussels one more time to try renegotiate the Irish backstop with the EU. The Orangemen of the DUP don't want a perpetual border-free customs union that will bind Northern Ireland to the south. Nothing will come of May's efforts other than allowing her government to live into the New Year.

****

After what looked like a triumph for crown prince Mohammed bin Salman (MbS) at the G-20 in Argentina (a high five from Putin!) the Khashoggi affair is back top of the fold. Reuters reports:
ANKARA (Reuters) - Istanbul’s chief prosecutor has filed warrants for the arrest of a top aide to Saudi Arabia’s de facto ruler and the deputy head of its foreign intelligence on suspicion of planning the killing of Jamal Khashoggi, two Turkish officials said on Wednesday.
The prosecutor’s office has concluded there is “strong suspicion” that Saud al-Qahtani and General Ahmed al-Asiri, both removed from their positions in October, were among the planners of Khashoggi’s Oct. 2 killing at the Saudi consulate in Istanbul, the officials said.
The move comes a day after senior U.S. senators said they were more certain than ever that Saudi Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman was responsible for the killing, citing a CIA briefing. The United Nations human rights chief on Wednesday called for an international investigation.
Lindsey Graham had a good line yesterday rebutting Pompeo's claim that there was "no smoking gun" linking MbS to Khashoggi's murder. Graham quipped, “There is not a smoking gun, there’s a smoking saw. You have to be willfully blind not to see it."

Tuesday, December 4, 2018

Endgame Brexit + Macron Flinches + AMLO's First Move

The Brexit vote in parliament is scheduled for next Tuesday, December 11. So gloomy are May's prospects of victory, the debate is over the margin of defeat for her withdrawal agreement. Touts think a loss in the 50-vote range will allow May to live to fight another day; a loss by 100 votes will lead to her ouster.

That's where Yves Smith has some worthwhile thoughts on the topic. Clearly the path forward after May's Brexit agreement is rejected next week will be for the prime minister to resign and new elections held. But, as Smith points out, the fractious Tory-led coalition government is united in not wanting elections:
Labour has said it would introduce a motion of no confidence if May’s Brexit were voted down and there is every reason to take them at their word. Some Conservatives have already sent in letters calling for a Motion of No Confidence, and the DUP is likely to vote against May. DUP leader Arlene Foster has recently said the UK could get a better deal from the EU if it pushed for it, which contradicts May’s claims. It doesn’t matter whether Foster believe this or not; it legitimates the DUP voting to toss May over the side.
However, the DUP does not want a General Election. It would almost certainly lose its powerful position as the key member in a coalition. Neither do the Tories. So if the Tories can rally around a new PM (Michael Gove?), the DUP would very likely join them. Recall that under the Fixed Term Parliaments Act, the Government can forestall a general election if it can act quickly enough. From Parliament’s website:
"If such a motion is agreed to, and a new government with the support of a majority of MPs cannot be formed within a period of 14 calendar days, Parliament is dissolved and an early General Election is triggered."
The fact that May might be turfed out right before Parliament goes out of session starting Friday December 21 means that minds in the Tory party are very likely focused on this question right now. And since a General Election will not have been called under any scenario by the time of the EU Council meeting on December 13-14, one wonder what they will have to say.
Gove is positioning himself  to replace May. But what I don't understand is why anyone would want to lead a government responsible for a crash-out of the European Union. I don't see it. It might be a UKIP or DUP wish, but it's not the basis of a national government. A Gove government might survive for a moment on subterfuge and misdirection. But there is very little time between now and March 29, and the Tories are hemmed in by the EU on one side and Labour and SNP on the other.

****

Macron flinched today and announced a six-month moratorium on his gas tax. The Yellow Vests promptly rejected the move as insufficient. Protests will proceed. My guess is that now having presented the carrot Macron can graduate to the stick. If the rebellion remains at the level of last Saturday, Macron will announce a state of emergency.


****

AMLO is already cooking in Mexico. According to Maria Verza and Mark Stevenson, "Mexico’s ‘common man’ president pledges end to secrecy," reporting for AP:
On Monday, Lopez Obrador tackled a case that cast a long shadow over the previous government, signing a presidential decree creating a truth commission to investigate the 2014 disappearance of 43 students in an apparent massacre. He then posed with parents of the missing young people, who displayed photos of their loved ones.
Prosecutors have said the students from a teachers college in southern Guerrero state were killed by a drug gang and their bodies incinerated in a massive fire. But conclusive evidence has never been found or presented, leading the students’ parents on a frustrating, painful four-year quest for the truth,

Monday, December 3, 2018

Gilets Jaunes

After reading the latest from The New York Times on the Yellow Vests (Gilets Jaunes) uprising in France, Adam Nossiter's "‘Yellow Vests’ Riot in Paris, but Their Anger Is Rooted Deep in France," one comes away with the impression that the movement will not die down anytime soon.

Alissa Rubin reports the results of Saturday's protest:
More than 260 people were wounded nationwide, at least 133 of them in Paris, according to the prefecture of police. Some were bystanders caught in the fray who needed treatment after exposure to tear gas. About 412 people were arrested nationwide.
The prefect of Paris, Michel Delpuech, said at a news conference late Sunday that the police had been faced with “extreme and unprecedented violence” and that protesters had thrown hammers and steel ball bearings at them.
Firefighters extinguished nearly 250 blazes that destroyed 112 cars and burned other property, including several buildings. The cost of the damage was being assessed on Sunday.
The French are comparing it to the student-worker rebellion of 1968.

Writing for Jacobin, Aurelie Dianara defines the Yellows Vests as a reaction to Macron's redistribution of wealth to the 1% and the widening immiseration of the working class:
In terms of their demands, the gilets jaunes first of all want to get rid of this “carbon tax.” But behind the anger there is something else. As they and their supporters have repeated over the last two weeks, to justify their actions (which have stirred no little upset), the fuel price issue is something of a “straw that broke the camel’s back.”
The voices heard in recent days express a clear feeling of exasperation, the sense of being the objects of the contempt of (and exclusion by) a political class which they generally reject. Many call for the government and President Emmanuel Macron to resign. They continually insist on his low support and weak electoral legitimacy: after all, in last year’s presidential contest he only scored 24 percent in the first round, and turnout in the runoff hit historic low. “Macron, resign!” is a slogan that thunders through the provinces and along the Champs Elysées.
This feeling of exasperation is the result of years of fiscal and social policies that have gradually strangled the low and middle classes, including in terms of the tax take. Immediately upon reaching office, Macron abolished the Solidarity Wealth Tax (ISF), giving €4 billion to the richest; and has strengthened the Tax Credit for Solidarity and Employment (CICE), a tax cut and exemption program transferring €41 billion a year to French companies, including multinationals. Shortly afterwards, with the 2018 budget bill, Macron established a flat tax that allowed a lowering of taxation on capital, handing another €10 billion to the richest.
At the same time, the government has increased the General Social Contribution (CSG) income tax to be paid by pensioners, while pensions themselves have ceased to be indexed to inflation (and thus to retirees’ ability to buy consumer goods). It has got rid of the subsidized contracts (which allowed large numbers to work on contracts partly financed by public bodies) and lowered by five euros a month the amount of housing contributions (APL) for the most disadvantaged.
As if that were not enough, the new “carbon tax” will weigh five times heavier on the budgets of the middle classes than on that of the upper classes. Yet the government has taken no steps to counterbalance this obviously unequal treatment — for example by giving aid to the families on the most modest budgets.
Building on policies already implemented by presidents Nicolas Sarkozy and François Hollande, the effect has been to produce a further massive increase in inequalities. Over the last two decades the largest fortunes in France have increased tenfold, while according to a recent study by OFCE and INSEE, French families’ average “purchasing power” has fallen by €440 a year since the 2008 crisis. In this context, it is unsurprising that a sense of injustice and humiliation has spread, as well as that of an arrogant “president of the rich.”
This has exacerbated a divide between the people and the privileged elite represented by the president, aggravated by a series of recent financial scandals enveloping recent heads of state. If governments have continued to repeat that tax breaks for the richest and big companies would stimulate investment, the figures tell us otherwise: we are still waiting for the million jobs promised by Hollande and his then-adviser Macron when CICE was launched in 2012.
We must see that the Yellow Vests are a continuation of Occupy Wall Street, the difference being that the movement originated from the exurbs rather than the urban core; also, the Yellow Vests don't dither when it comes to making demands, and the movement is not yoked to the occupation of a prominent public space.

The basic facts of life since the dot-com bubble and burst nearly two decades ago are rising housing costs and stagnant wages. Governments have done nothing to address the problem. Why? Because it is not of problem for the people whom those governments serve: The wealthy.

Eventually though the peasants rebel, even under the paradigm of zombie neoliberalism.

Macron shows no sign yet of recognizing the enormity of the challenge with which he is faced. Zombie neoliberalism has managed to last this long because there has not been a legitimate social democratic crack in its market-worshiping armor. That's about to change in Mexico. In the UK May should be gone before the end of the month.

Faced with a rebellion, what can Macron do? Both Le Pen and Melenchon are calling for the dissolution of the national assembly followed by new elections. Macron will declare a state of emergency first before he dissolves the national assembly.

In any event, this Saturday the Yellow Vests will be on the march again.