Showing posts with label Nader 2000. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Nader 2000. Show all posts

Monday, September 26, 2016

The Black Swan

With the first presidential debate tonight, it is interesting to note that Nate Silver, polling guru who made a name for himself successfully predicting both of Obama's robust victories, has basically punted when it comes to divining the outcome for 2016. The polls are too close and the trend lines are going in odd directions in swings states versus the nation at large. But what Silver is really saying, at least what I came away with, is that polling in this presidential election year is not reliable.

In other words, the polling guru is calling a black swan. Silver won't name it as such because his FiveThirtyEight web site, owned by ESPN, is part of the corporate media monopoly and is therefore all in for Hillary. But a significant part of this particular black swan is the corporate media monopoly itself. So Silver's elliptical reference to a black swan makes perfect sense. Self-censorship.

The black swan of which I speak is a Trump victory. Impossible based on the factoid that the candidate who is leading in the polls two weeks after the last nominating convention always wins. But who could have imagined in late August, after the daily pummeling Trump receives on the front page of the "newspaper of record" and the tens of millions of dollars Clinton has spent on unchallenged ads, that in late September Trump would be ahead in Ohio and Florida and that we would have a nail-biter on our hands?

Hillary's path to 270 electoral votes is easier to imagine because I don't see Trump winning in Pennsylvania or Michigan, states Trump needs to find a way to the White House. But there is also a small chance that no candidate gets to 270. This could happen if Trump wins Colorado, New Hampshire and one of the two electoral votes Maine apportions based on Congressional District. Assuming all the swings break according to the current FiveThirtyEight map, this would keep Clinton under 270.

Andrew Levine in "The Meaning of the Trump Surge," which was the featured piece on the CounterPunch web site over the weekend, thinks that after the debates Hillary will reattain her substantial post-convention lead. In this scenario, Levine thinks the best that can be hoped for is that the Jill Stein vote will reach five percent; at that threshold the Green Party will qualify for federal funds. This is a big deal. It was the unicorn we were after in 2000 with Nader-LaDuke.

If Nader-LaDuke couldn't do it, neither will Stein-Baraka.

On Saturday I participated in a 5K road race that is part of an annual community event in a working-class neighborhood in the northernmost reaches of the city. I go every year. It is my favorite run. I think it has something to do with its small scale. I like racing on the empty streets early on Saturday morning. What I noticed this year is that people still have their Bernie signs up. This is a phenomena I have noticed in the more inexpensive precincts of my neighborhood, something one would expect to see in apartment windows. But in the northern home-owning neighborhood of working-class Broadview it came as a surprise. No Trump signs. No Hillary signs. Only Bernie signs and Seahawks signs (and less of those than in years past).

What do these signs portend? It is hard to say. Were Kucinich signs still up in yards and apartments at this point in 2004?

I don't think every Bernie sign is a marker for Jill Stein. After all, Bernie has capitulated and is campaigning for Clinton. I think these signs are similar to Tibetan prayer flags and signify nothing more than the bleached aspiration of a weekend Buddhist living in a 'roided-out consumer culture. I think we need to start looking at the electoral map from the 2004 election.

Friday, September 19, 2014

Scots Buckle at the Polls: Fear Triumphs over Courage Once Again

The "No" vote ended up winning by a landslide, 55 percent to 45 percent. It was too grand a thought to think the Scots would stand in a majority to deal a blow to Empire. Despite some favorable polls recently and a sense of momentum, the "Yes" campaign for Scottish independence was always operating under an enormous burden, and that burden was that voters had to display some personal courage. There was a tremendous amount of fear-mongering in the mainstream media. Scottish independence would result in economic collapse, or so we were told by the experts.

The overwhelming majority of people are ruled by fear. In light of this, 45 percent for independence is very encouraging.

Fear will always triumph in the voting booth. We saw this in Pakistan's spring 2013 elections. Despite a lot of excitement, activism and momentum, support for Imran Khan's Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf collapsed at the polls. Nawaz Sharif's Pakistan Muslim League-N walked away with the victory.

I participated in a similar monumental battle of hope versus fear in the Nader 2000 campaign. In spite of huge Super-Rallies and a legitimate grassroots Green Party volunteer movement, Democrat's fear-mongering carried the day (but not for the Democrats themselves, who continued to blame Nader supporters for costing the listless Al Gore the presidency). Nader couldn't even tally 3 percent of the vote nationally. The goal was to reach 5 percent in order that the Green Party could qualify for public funding the next election.

Fear apparently is much stronger than hope when it comes to a public vote. It is a Hobbesian world.

Monday, February 10, 2014

Democrats Vulnerable on the Left

Eric Lipton has a decent frontpage story this morning on how the infernal machine that is Washington D.C. works. "Fight Over Minimum Wage Illustrates Web of Industry Ties" details the work of pro-corporate Employment Policies Institute in generating research saying that increasing the minimum wage kills jobs and raises prices.

Employment Policies Institute is funded by right-wing foundations as well as the restaurant and retail industry; it is run by a guy named Howard Berman out the office of his public relations firm:
The sign at the entrance is for Berman and Company, as the Employment Policies Institute has no employees of its own. Mr. Berman’s for-profit advertising firm, instead, “bills” the nonprofit institute for the services his employees provide to the institute. This arrangement effectively means that the nonprofit is a moneymaking venture for Mr. Berman, whose advertising firm was paid $1.1 million by the institute in 2012, according to its tax returns, or 44 percent of its total budget, with most of the rest of the money used to buy advertisements.
The Employment Policies Institute's commissioned research has come under fire:
But some questions have been raised about the institute-funded work. Saul D. Hoffman, a professor of economics at University of Delaware, examined the employment data Mr. Sabia used for a 2012 paper funded in part by the institute. Mr. Hoffman concluded that the narrow cut of data Mr. Sabia picked was perhaps unintentionally skewed, and once corrected, it would have showed that the 2004 increase in New York State’s minimum wage had no negative impact on employment — the opposite of the conclusion the institute had proclaimed in its news releases.
Raising the minimum wage is a vital issue for the Democrats. It is basically the only thing they have to offer voters. Obama's approval rating has taken a nosedive, as Mike Whitney points out in an excellent piece, "The American Dream is Dead," that appeared over the weekend on the Counterpunch web site:
Obama has done nothing to help working people. He hasn’t lifted a damn finger, which is why “58 percent of Americans disapprove of his stewardship of the economy” (Wall Street Journal/NBC News and Quinnipiac University) It’s also why 78 percent said of respondents in a recent Wall Street Journal/NBC News poll said they think the country is “on the wrong track.” And it’s also why Obama’s personal performance ratings have slipped below those of George Bush in the fifth year of his presidency. Obama has been a disaster and everyone knows it. The impact of his misrule with be felt for years to come. Just take a look at this comment by University of Michigan economist Richard Curtain who explains the dramatic change he’s seen in consumer behavior due to the policies that were put in place following the Great Financial Crisis (GFC). The quote is from an analytic piece titled “Consumer Behavior Adapts to Fundamental Changes in Expectations” Economic Outlook Conference November 21, 2013:
“I have been reporting on the economic implications of the latest twists and turns in consumer expectations at this conference for nearly four decades. From the heights of expansions to the depths of recessions, consumers had never deserted their bedrock belief that the economy would produce ever increasing levels of affluence. The Great Recession, unlike any other downturn in the past half century, has not only tarnished the American Dream, but has prompted some fundamental changes in consumer expectations and behavior.” (“Consumer Behavior Adapts to Fundamental Changes in Expectations” Economic Outlook Conference November 21, 2013, University of Michigan)
How do you like that? After 40 years of watching this stuff, Curtin says he’s noticed a “fundamental change” in the “bedrock belief that the economy would produce ever increasing levels of affluence.” 
This is quite profound, I think, with far-reaching implications for the economy. The pessimism that Obama (and Congress) have generated through their policies have dampened expectations and changed people’s views about the future. Most people no longer expect their wages to increase or their financial situation to improve. For a growing number of people, the American dream is dead. This is already having an effect on personal consumption, household spending and economic growth. It’s also effecting the way people view the government, and what we think of ourselves as a nation. As Curtin notes:
(The) “deeply rooted uncertainty about future economic conditions…has been sustained by the growing recognition that no federal policy has yet emerged that will restore long term economic prosperity anytime soon for the majority of consumers. Optimism about long term job and income prospects are essential for maintaining high levels of economic motivation. Too few consumers have regained that optimism.”
Exactly. “No federal policy” has been put in place to “restore long term economic prosperity.”
That’s the whole ball o’ wax, right there. The pols have done nothing. 
The pessimism we now see everywhere, can be traced back to government policy. All the blame goes to Obama and Congress. They’re the ones who ended the American Dream. They killed it.
Not only is the loss of faith in Obama, an electoral avatar, potentially ruinous for Dems in the near term, but so too are the rumblings of socialism. Here is how Robert McChesney describes it in "Sharp Turn Left for Media Reform" (a must-read) in the latest issue of Monthly Review:
U.S. capitalism is in the midst of what Paul Krugman refers to as another great depression. Unemployment remains very high, corporations are sitting on some $1.7 trillion they are not investing in new plants and equipment, and downward pressures on wages are extreme, particularly for the young and the working class. This is part of a long-term problem of secular stagnation for monopoly-finance capitalism, as John Bellamy Foster and I write about in The Endless Crisis. Stagnation, combined with political corruption, means that poverty rates have returned to levels not seen for nearly a century in the United States, and inequality is trending towards that found in Malaysia or the Philippines, with Western Europe and Japan in its rearview mirror. Nothing in the range of current debates on economic policy proposes anything that will change this dynamic. For the bulk of the population, the future is grim. 
The political-economic situation in the United States is therefore unstable and ultimately untenable. When one factors in the environmental crisis, this becomes an even more calamitous and desperate period. What is striking is that all the paeans to the genius of the market, which remain commonplace in policy or academic debates on communication from the respectable left to the right, now increasingly smell like month-old fish left out on a table. While the news has yet to hit the corrupt elites in Washington, academia, or the mainstream news media, it is increasingly understood by a beleaguered citizenry. It is also understood by Pope Francis, who delivered a condemnation of capitalism, and capitalist media, in November 2013 that was unsparing and radical. “No one else,” the journalist Robert Scheer wrote, “has put it as powerfully and succinctly.” 
What is taking place is little short of a sea change. As John Nichols notes, “Thirty-nine percent of Americans surveyed for a November 2012 Gallup poll said they had a positive image of socialism. In a 2011 Pew survey, 49 percent of Americans under 30 said they felt positive about socialism, while just 46 percent felt positive about capitalism. Among African-Americans, 55 percent had a positive reaction to socialism, versus 41 percent to capitalism. Among Latinos, it was 44 percent for socialism, 32 percent for capitalism.” This is especially notable since few Americans have ever heard anything positive about socialism; it would be like a survey in the Soviet Union in 1955 asking people to compare the merits of capitalism versus communism. What Americans do know today from firsthand experience is that really existing capitalism, to employ the vernacular, sucks. In 2013 the “socialist alternative” candidate Kshama Sawant won a citywide election for the Seattle City Council, over a liberal Democrat opponent in a two-person race. A decade ago a radical like Sawant—who called for using eminent domain to take over abandoned factories and have workers “take over the factories”—would have been unlikely to nudge 1 or 2 percent of the vote.
I supported Sawant, with my vote and by making campaign contributions. Post-election she is doing the right thing. Sawant is keeping her supporters mobilized. The goal is to realize her campaign goal of a $15/hr. minimum wage in Seattle. She has set up 15now.org. Saturday a big organizing rally is to be held.

If Sawant is successful, watch out.

My read is that Democrats are far more vulnerable than they will acknowledge. With liberal/progressive voters finally experiencing their "morning after" moment with Obama and more bad news likely on the way -- Keystone XL, continuing Congressional gridlock, war in the Middle East and a collapse of Israeli-Palestinian negotiations, a new Cold War with Russia, more embarrassing revelations from Snowden and details about what is on the Trans-Pacific Partnership bargaining table -- the Democratic Party could be looking at something far worse than Nader 2000 in the next couple of years.