In the previous post I praised the quality of C.J. Chivers reporting for the New York Times. I'd like to retract that. After reading this morning's Moon of Alabama blog post it is apparent that Chivers frequently engages in tendentious argumentation on behalf of the West.
In the past I suppose I've been swayed by his detached voice-overs describing the technical details of battles captured on videos that have appeared on the New York Times website.
Moon of Alabama offers a counterpoint to the argument that the Syrian government is responsible for the chemical weapons attack on Ghouta based on azimuth data. This is welcome since the West has been winning the propaganda war so far this week.
Wednesday, September 18, 2013
Chapter VII a Stretch for the West Despite Winning Propaganda War on Ghouta CW Attack
C.J. Chivers, a reporter who does good work, has another story today, "U.N. Data on Gas Attack Points to Assad’s Top Forces," fleshing out the azimuths evidence contained in the recently released United Nations report on the August 21 chemical weapons attack in the Damascus suburb of Ghouta. The angle of impact taken from rocket craters point to the Republican Guard 104th Brigade located atop Mount Qasioun. This revelation, mostly unanswered in the last 36 hours, is being countered this morning by the Syrian government. Agence France Presse reports that "Russian Deputy Foreign Minister Sergei Ryabkov said Wednesday after the first of two days of talks in Damascus that the Syrian regime has handed Russia new materials implicating rebels in the attack that horrified the world." Ake Sellstrom's UN investigators are returning to Syria to continue inspections.
Regardless of the actual truth of who is behind the Ghouta chemical attack, the Syrian government has been losing the rhetorical war with the West since Monday. This has given renewed impetus in the Security Council to include Chapter VII sanctions in the draft resolution governing Syrian compliance with the Chemical Weapons Convention. Here's Rick Gladstone's take in "Security Council Returns to Role in Syria Conflict":
Regardless of the actual truth of who is behind the Ghouta chemical attack, the Syrian government has been losing the rhetorical war with the West since Monday. This has given renewed impetus in the Security Council to include Chapter VII sanctions in the draft resolution governing Syrian compliance with the Chemical Weapons Convention. Here's Rick Gladstone's take in "Security Council Returns to Role in Syria Conflict":
[D]iplomats, who declined to be identified, said Russia, Syria’s most important ally, was resisting components of the draft, composed by the three Western permanent members — Britain, France and the United States — that discuss the threat of force to ensure Syrian compliance, whether to condemn the Syrian government for chemical weapons use and whether suspected users should be referred to the International Criminal Court for war crimes prosecutions.
The discussions are unlikely to produce a quick resolution, the diplomats said, and it is unclear when a draft will be ready for a vote.Even though Syria and their Russian ally are losing the public relations war on the Ghouta attack, they remain in a strong position vis-a-vis the West. Public opinion is overwhelming against military intervention even though a super-majority already believes the Syrian government to be responsible for the attack; that's what polls published earlier showed. The United States Government is facing the very real threat of a shutdown in the near future. In his negotiations with the House GOP there is no way Obama is going to risk losing public support by launching a unilateral strike. Russia will block any threat of force or official condemnation in the Security Council. It is likely that Sellstrom's inspection team will eventually document evidence of rebel chemical weapons use. The West will do everything it can to prevent this because once it happens any military support for the opposition will be exceedingly difficult to justify to a public bludgeoned about the horrors of using gas on the battlefield.
NFL Week 2: The Ecstasy of Grief
Once I get off the train in the morning I make my way across a skywalk and then down
four flights of concrete steps and across International Boulevard to the bus stop. I
climb aboard the bus at a back entry and usually sit near an older man who is always
reading the sports pages of the Seattle Times. Lately he has been breakfasting on
muffins and danish. Earlier in the summer he was making due with the thin gruel of
Mariners box scores. Now, I can tell, he's feeling good; he's riding high in bus
seat.
Why? People are excited here about the Seahawks.
Though it is still very early in
the season, it looks like the team is equal if not superior to last year's wild card
squad. During Sunday night's demolition (the second in a row) of Super Bowl
runners-up and division rival San Francisco 49ers, the off season acquisitions for
the defensive line, Michael Bennett and Cliff Avril, played well and made critical
contributions. It was the lack of a pass rush in the fourth quarter on the road that
was the undoing of the Seahawks last year.
So things are looking good and people are beginning to chomp down on the hype. A
trip to the Super Bowl might be a legitimate possibility. I am wary though. The pain
and suffering I experienced was immense with the playoff loss last January in
Atlanta . I don't want to relive that.
I was detached for the nail-biting opener in Charlotte against the
snake-bitten Panthers. But that all changed at some point in the first half of
Sunday night's game. My detachment disappeared. Maybe it was the game delay for the
lightning storm. By the time play resumed I was completely enmeshed. And it was an
extremely satisfying enmeshment. The Seahawks defense shut down the potent
Kaepernick-led San Francsico offense, an offense that had steamrollered Green Bay
the previous week. And the Seahawks offense got its running game going.
This is
what I want to tell you: To be a Seattle fan and to see Marshawn Lynch snap off a
crisp touchdown run complete with sharp cutbacks, to sit enraptured at home in front
the television as The Beast swaggers slowly into the end zone, really, truly, this
is as good as it gets in terms of a communal, cathartic experience. I know the
National Football League is a money-grubbing soul-devouring multi-billion dollar
behemoth. But underneath it all, the greatness of heroic athletes manages to shine through.
We're not asked to create anything. We're asked to maintain a preexisting order that is based on hierarchy and exploitation. It's a miserable system, an infernal machine. To know that she is free, the worker is allowed to purchase with script objects she has produced by the sweat of her own brow. Freedom also includes viewing commercially televised images. For the most part, this is what we're left with. When it's good we're transported from our horrible lives to something bigger and better, something shared.
Tuesday, September 17, 2013
Be Wary, Warmongers Aren't Done with Syria
With the release of the United Nations report on chemical weapons in Syria yesterday a bum's rush is underway to assign blame to the Syrian government for the August 21 chemical attack in the Damascus suburb of Ghouta. I see this as a way to rejuvenate the the unilateral force option that was taken off the table temporarily last week thanks to a combination of overwhelming public opposition and skilled Russian diplomacy. The Western powers will use the Sellstrom report to generate support in the Security Council for the use of force if the Syrian government is decided to be not in compliance with the Kerry-Lavrov agreement ridding the country of its chemical munitions. Then we will be right back to the situation preceding the invasion of Iraq: The United States will insist that the Syrian government is not cooperating; Russia and China will disagree; and the United States will jump the rails and launch a unilateral attack.
That's the idea at least. First work has to be done to make it universally accepted that the Syrian government launched the Ghouta attack. The UN report -- I haven't had a chance to read it yet, just skim sections online -- is said to point to the Syrian government for two reasons: 1) the rockets used require large launchers "not previously documented or reported to be in the possession of the insurgency"; and 2) the azimuth data gleaned from the rocket impact craters are said to point back to a Syrian military facility. This is from a Rick Gladstone and C.J. Chivers story, "Forensic Details in U.N. Report Point to Assad’s Use of Gas," that appears in the New York Times today:
The weapons inspectors, who visited Ghouta and left the country with large amounts of evidence on Aug. 31, said, “In particular, the environmental, chemical and medical samples we have collected provide clear and convincing evidence that surface-to-surface rockets containing the nerve agent sarin were used.”
But the report’s annexes, detailing what the authors found, were what caught the attention of nonproliferation experts.
In two chilling pieces of information, the inspectors said that the remnants of a warhead they had found showed its capacity of sarin to be about 56 liters — far higher than initially thought. They also said that falling temperatures at the time of the attack ensured that the poison gas, heavier than air, would hug the ground, penetrating lower levels of buildings “where many people were seeking shelter.”
The investigators were unable to examine all of the munitions used, but they were able to find and measure several rockets or their components. Using standard field techniques for ordnance identification and crater analysis, they established that at least two types of rockets had been used, including an M14 artillery rocket bearing Cyrillic markings and a 330-millimeter rocket of unidentified provenance.
These findings, though not presented as evidence of responsibility, were likely to strengthen the argument of those who claim that the Syrian government bears the blame, because the weapons in question had not been previously documented or reported to be in possession of the insurgency.
Moreover, those weapons are fired by large, conspicuous launchers. For rebels to have carried out the attack, they would have had to organize an operation with weapons they are not known to have and of considerable scale, sophistication and secrecy — moving the launchers undetected into position in areas under strong government influence or control, keeping them in place unmolested for a sustained attack that would have generated extensive light and noise, and then successfully withdrawing them — all without being detected in any way.
One annex to the report also identified azimuths, or angular measurements, from where rockets had struck, back to their points of origin. When plotted and marked independently on maps by analysts from Human Rights Watch and by The New York Times, the United Nations data from two widely scattered impact sites pointed directly to a Syrian military complex.
Other nonproliferation experts said the United Nations report was damning in its implicit incrimination of Mr. Assad’s side in the conflict, not only in the weaponry fragments but also in the azimuth data that indicated the attack’s origins. An analysis of the report posted online by the Arms Control Association, a Washington-based advocacy group, said “the additional details and the perceived objectivity of the inspectors buttress the assignment of blame to Bashar al-Assad’s Syrian government.”The first argument -- that insurgents have not been seen using large rocket launchers -- I don't find compelling. Peter Krohn posted a link to a video yesterday showing rebels using 140-mm rockets. Granted this not a 330-mm rocket that Gladstone and Chivers mention. But simply because rebels have not been documented using this particular ordnance is not proof of Syrian Arab Army guilt.
What is more difficult to refute, assuming it is being accurately reported, is the azimuth data. We'll have to see how this plays out. Syria needs to address this argument in particular. There is enough information in the public sphere regarding rebel access to sarin and rockets that this isn't so much of a problem. But what about angles of impact pointing to Syrian military facilities?
The Gladstone and Chivers story ends tendentiously though, making me suspicious of the information that preceded it:
The report’s release punctuated a tumultuous week spawned by the global outrage over the attack, in which an American threat of punitive force on the Syrian government was delayed as Russia proposed a diplomatic alternative and intense negotiations between the United States and Russia led to a sweeping agreement under which Syria’s chemical weapons arsenal could be destroyed.
The United Nations, in danger of becoming irrelevant in helping to end the Syria conflict, was suddenly thrust back into a central role, with the Security Council now engaged in deliberations over an enforceable measure to hold Syria to its commitment on chemical weapons.This is a clear example of an ex post facto sculpting of reality. Horrible as it is, the global outrage was not over the chemical attack. Global outrage was over threats of another illegal, destabilizing U.S. war. It was not the United Nations that was in danger of becoming irrelevant, it was Obama. This is slanted reporting. Be wary, the warmongers aren't done with Syria.
Monday, September 16, 2013
Crisis Averted for the Time Being
This Monday morning it is apparent that the U.S.-Russian deal, brokered over the weekend, to rid Syria of its chemical weapons is a huge defeat for the warhawks. Two stories limn the plaintive cries of the warmongers as they rail at the failure of Obama to launch a strike: Anne Barnard's "Deal Represents Turn for Syria; Rebels Deflated" and Peter Baker's "Brief Respite for President, but No Plan B on Syria." Here are two essential quotes from each. First, Peter Baker:
Most lawmakers on both sides of the aisle just want the issue to go away. Indeed, the White House recommended to lawmakers that they move on to other subjects. The White House itself pivoted its public message back to economic issues on Sunday. Mr. Obama and Congress face critical deadlines in the next few weeks to keep the government open and avert a default.
The prolonged process of finalizing a disarmament plan and putting it into effect over the course of a year would take Syria off the front burner for a while and could give Mr. Obama an opportunity to avoid action altogether. Senior administration officials made the case last week that the process itself serves as a deterrent because Mr. Assad presumably would not use his chemical weapons in the interim.This supports the analysis provided on the Moon of Alabama blog. Western backing for the Syrian opposition will be slowly, gradually unwound. Crisis averted.
The rebels can read the handwriting on the wall. Here is Anne Barnard:
Bashir Hajji, a field commander with Liwaa al-Tawheed, a rebel group affiliated with the loose-knit, Western-backed Free Syrian Army, said the agreement had strengthened the growing suspicion among rebels and “civilians who want salvation” that the United States, which has not substantially delivered on promises to strengthen their forces, actually aims to prolong Mr. Assad’s rule.
“The international community is providing a new chance for Assad’s gangs to continue the criminal play in Syria,” he said.Thanks to Russia's masterly move in providing Obama an avenue of escape from the warmongers in his own administration and the foreign policy establishment, a wider war has been avoided. To deescalate the crisis Russia took advantage of the overwhelming antiwar sentiment of the general populous that was effectively blocking Congress from granting Obama an Authorization for the Use of Military Force. Bush II had invaded Iraq despite huge antiwar rallies across the globe. The Russian diplomatic initiative was a necessary part of the solution. Leaders, for the most part, don't respect the people they govern.
So, for the time being, chalk up a win for democracy and the people.
Sunday, September 15, 2013
Ultimate Comics: The Ultimates #9
Jonathan Hickman outdoes himself and crosses some sort of boundary in conventional superhero comic books with Ultimate Comics: The Ultimates #9, the last issue of the series to be penciled by Esad Ribic. The Obama-like president, addressing Congress in a joint session, is wiped out -- blown to kingdom come -- along with most of Washington D.C. by a ghoulish little boy carrying an anti-matter bomb sent by Reed Richards.
Scans of the beautiful last three pages of Ultimate Comes: The Ultimates # 9 you will find below:
Scans of the beautiful last three pages of Ultimate Comes: The Ultimates # 9 you will find below:
The Colt 45 Chronicle #36
I'm getting off schedule with this letter archive project. "The Colt 45 Chronicle" is a collection of letters that were written my first two years in New York City. I had left the University of California and had moved with my wife to the Big Apple where she attended medical school. We lived in a housing high-rise on the urban campus of the health sciences complex on the western edge of Washington Heights.
I pulled the string-tied folder of letters out of storage during halftime of the Seahawks-Falcons playoff game last January. Bit by bit every Sunday afternoon I've been posting a letter here. It's an archive project that allows me to see who I was 25 years ago, which often times has proven to be an unpleasant experience.
I've been taking the letters off the top with no ordering or editing other than some punctuation changes and the occasional elision of a name. Two missives I've skipped entirely because they were all business -- "I'll be out of town on this date . . . You can meet me here at . . ." -- That type of thing.
The letter below is addressed to a guy I knew at Berkeley. He was an "art for art sake" bohemian who was a hanger-on with my group of friends. He was a participant in the events mentioned in Chronicle #15. Henry was his name. He liked to keep his cock in a tube sock; he boasted about how much he masturbated. Henry's good friend was a guy named Dallas. Dallas was in his 30s (we were all in our early 20s) and had a thick head of prematurely gray hair; he was a dishwasher, a smart guy, who I believe had been a graduate student at another university but who had migrated to Berkeley because Berkeley was Berkeley. He and Henry liked to go to parties -- any party. And this was the primary bond that I shared with them. They would supply information to me and my friends as to where the parties were -- mostly on Thursday, Friday and Saturday nights -- and we would crash them.
Henry and Dallas were after free beer and women and the sound of their own voices. We would go to these parties and argue about books. We would drink; there would be a fist fight now and then; sometimes there would be single women with whom to flirt. One much-discussed evening Henry and Dallas were alleged to have met a woman whom they escorted to a pornographic theater (they still had them in those days) where they had sex during the movie while the audience of forlorn single men hungrily looked on.
The letter below I'm sure was never sent. I would often begin a letter after I had completed one. I liked to create the kernel of an epistle when I was done with my third quart of beer and finished with whatever communique I had been working on and I was sitting contentedly beneath the palm at the end of my mind. Then later on, on another night, I would go back and expand the kernel into a full-blown letter. This one, probably because it was irredeemably negative, was never salvaged.
Autumn 1989
Give up the ghost and try something like swimming off the maverick shore.
Life never gets ironed out if you sit in the same seat all your life; -- that's got to be a foundational truth, huh?
Here, let me tell you something: people who've got big heads, as in strong minds (eggheads) -- like you Henry -- always have a problem with comfort; by problem I mean "need." You have an addiction to comfort in other words. Smart people have this problem because they're the first ones to figure out the pleasure-pain calculus; and, often times, the first ones there are the last ones to leave.
You're a sweet guy and you probably have a heart of gold, and I wish things were all comic books and Berkeley, but the truth is that is the farthest thing from the truth.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)


