Sunday, February 4, 2018

Super Bowl LII Prediction

It is Super Bowl Sunday. High Holy Days in the United States. One can imagine in the not-too-distant future our Gregorian calendar being replaced by a Kraftian calendar (named after Patriots owner Bob Kraft), with New Year's Day falling on the first Sunday in February. Because, after all, can we really consider the old year to be concluded until the Vince Lombardi Trophy has been hoisted by the triumphant Super Bowl MVP?

Two decent pieces this weekend are Joe's Drape's "‘The American Dilemma’: Why Do We Still Watch Football?" and Steve Almond's "Trump’s Blood Sport Politics." Drape wonders why so many people continue to watch professional football when it is common knowledge that the game causes brain disease:
C.T.E. has been found in the brain of one dead N.F.L. player after another. Published studies have found a correlation between the total number of years one plays tackle football and the likelihood of one’s developing brain disease later in life.
Still, we shrug. Last year, 111.3 million people tuned in to CBS’s Super Bowl broadcast, according to Nielsen. Even with N.F.L. regular-season ratings down 12 percent this season, Eagles-Patriots on Sunday will almost certainly be the most-watched television event of the year — as the previous year’s Super Bowl was.
“I’m embarrassed how much I love football,” a friend texted me recently during an afternoon of football watching. “The American Dilemma.”
Stories of concussions do not affect viewership of the game for 77 percent of fans, according to the annual Burson-Marsteller Super Bowl survey. Alan Schwarz, the former New York Times reporter who exposed football’s concussion crisis, said that the issue does not discourage him from watching the N.F.L.
“I have no problem watching the N.F.L. — these are grown men making grown men’s decisions,” said Schwarz, whose investigative articles from 2007 to 2011 compelled new safety rules for players of all ages. “After being kept in the dark for so many years by their employers, they now know they could wind up brain-damaged. Fine. They’re professional daredevils. It wasn’t immoral to watch Evel Knievel. We watch stuntmen in movies.”
Drape failed to mention that ratings have continued to slide during this year's playoffs. CNNMoney's story, "NFL Championship ratings dip, but games still bring in huge audience," by Frank Pallota, registers a discernible shift in the recent panic coverage of the multi-year NFL TV ratings drop. The NFL, though slipping, is still -- by far -- the only "game in town" when it comes to television:
Let's start with the bad news. The overall viewership for Sunday's two games dipped compared to last year.
CBS' early game on Sunday, when the New England Patriots held off the Jacksonville Jaguars in the AFC Championship to head to the Super Bowl for the second consecutive year, was down 5% compared to the early game last year between the Green Bay Packers and the Atlanta Falcons on Fox.
Sunday's night game on Fox, which saw the Philadelphia Eagles decimate the Minnesota Vikings in the NFC Championship, was down 12% compared to the Pittsburgh Steelers and New England Patriots night game on CBS last season. The Vikings and Eagles game had the makings of a blow out by halftime, so that could have hurt viewership.
The NFL's numbers have been sluggish all season, so last weekend's ratings aren't exactly surprising. The blame for the declining viewership this season has been pinned on everything from a surplus of TV and streaming content to a roster of injured players.
Now for the good news: Despite a loss in viewership, the NFL still brings in the biggest ratings on TV by a big margin.
Both championship games had more than 40 million viewers tuning in, which makes the match-ups some of the most-watched programming on TV in the last year.
Fox noted that the roughly 42.3 million viewers that watched Eagles-Vikings on Sunday night "registered as Fox's highest-rated and most-watched broadcast on the network since Super Bowl LI."
The 44.1 million who watched Sunday's AFC Championship made the game the most-watched and highest-rated TV program since last year's Super Bowl programming.
When it comes to national identity, the NFL, though beginning to loosen its grip, is all that binds the people of the United States.

Steve Almond -- wrongly, I believe -- argues that this has had a malign effect on our politics:
As Americans have become geographically uprooted and spiritually unmoored, they have turned to sports as a source of tribal identity, a primarily masculine refuge from the anxieties of adulthood, the lingua franca in a fragmented culture. The hours we spend consuming sports dwarfs the amount devoted to political activism, volunteer work, even religious worship.
From the moment he began his campaign, Mr. Trump understood that most Americans have exchanged the burdens of citizenship for the pleasures of fandom. And he intuited that politics, for all its precious norms and pretensions, was at its root a blood sport.
While his primary opponents droned on about policy, Mr. Trump dominated debates simply by trash talking. At rallies, he bragged about his poll numbers and urged partisans to pummel protesters. He mocked elitist losers and vowed to usher in an era of winning.
Establishment Republicans yelped that he needed to pivot to a gentler, more inclusive tone. But in the end nearly all of them voted for Mr. Trump. They did so because of what political scientists call “negative partisanship,” an ingrained hatred for the other party that is often entirely divorced from ethics or policy.
Orwell would have seen in this pattern the infiltration of the sporting spirit into our political culture. The result is voters whose prevailing ethos boils down to the motto of Al Davis, the former owner of the Oakland Raiders: “Just win, baby.” Even if you need to suppress votes, or gerrymander districts, or get help from Russian agents to do it.
But Americans across the political spectrum got caught up in the same spirit. Think about how much time liberals spent hate-watching Mr. Trump’s rallies, or hitting refresh on predictive models such as The Times’s Upshot meter. They, too, gobbled up stories that focused on strategy and poll numbers. Is it any wonder that the news media spent so much time focused on the scoreboard, and not the stakes?
We should all be alarmed by a postelection study, conducted by Harvard’s Shorenstein Center, which revealed that just 10 percent of the 2016 election coverage focused on policy. But we should also understand that this dismal statistic redounds to us.
I would say Almond has it backwards. People identify with sports because politics have become completely debased and unauthentic. W. promised that he wasn't going to nation-build, and then he invades Afghanistan and Iraq. Nader won a sliver of the presidential vote in 2000, yet he was widely blamed by liberals, indulging in self-deluding sophistry, for electing Bush, and hence the invasion of Iraq. Obama won the primary in 2008 and later the general election because he proclaimed himself the peace candidate; he was opposed to the war in Iraq. In office Obama presided over the huge covert war against Syria.

People are forced to vote for candidates from one of the two main parties, and the two main parties are united in their devotion to perpetual war. True, there is no escape from militarism when you tune into an NFL game. But at least there is a display of honest effort.

Lying has become so pervasive that now it is common -- this is the Trump administration's contribution to the continued debasement of politics -- for the president to say one thing and his secretary of state to say another (on NAFTA), or, what's worse, the Pentagon (the Kurds of Rojava) to fight a war against the CIA (the Free Syrian Army).

In this environment a rational thing to do is watch a contest on the gridiron. I started watching the NFL again in 2004 after a ten-year layoff probably because the Green Party was splitting and obviously was not going to be the vehicle for political change that seemed apparent in 2000.

The 2004 season also featured a Patriots-Eagles Super Bowl. This iteration of the Patriots-Eagles has the Patriots favored by four, a line that has narrowed by two points as money began flowing to Philadelphia this past week.

The New York Times is going with the favorite. The analysis of the writer Benjamin Hoffman boils down to a distrust of Nick Foles and a faith in Tom Brady. Hoffman points out the dominant nature of the Eagles defense and the so-so quality of the Patriots defense. Clearly, based on this basic but essential match-up, the respective defenses, one would be justified in taking Philadelphia.

Hoffman talks himself out of going with the Eagles because of Foles' poor first half in the divisional round against Atlanta. Hoffman fails to mention that since then Foles has been flawless. The weather conditions -- bitter cold, high winds --in the first half of the Atlanta game didn't favor passing. Foles got himself back on track in the second half by sticking with the run-pass option (RPO).

I don't think the Patriots have an answer for the Eagles RPO or the Eagles running game.

For me the question is whether Philadelphia can maintain pressure on Tom Brady into and through the fourth quarter. You will notice if you watched the AFC Championship Game that Jacksonville had New England beat until the fourth quarter when the Sacksonville pass rush disappeared, leaving Brady with a clean pocket. Give Brady a clean pocket in the fourth quarter and he will score at will. Ask the Atlanta Falcons.

The other question I have about Philadelphia's defense is its ability to cover the running back catching passes out of the backfield. Jerick McKinnon had a dynamite game for the Vikings in the NFC Championship Game. The Patriots have two Jerick McKinnons in Dion Lewis and James White. So New England will be able to move the ball on offense.

All that being said, Philadelphia has only given up 17 points in the playoffs so far. The defense looked a little confused on Minnesota's opening drive before settling down, creating turnovers and taking care of business, while New England's defense is the weakest of any of the recent Patriots Super Bowl teams.

Finally, I have to mention that I have talked to a lot of people about the Super Bowl. No one I have spoken with is rooting for the Patriots. Everyone wants an Eagles win. But the overriding sentiment is one of fear. Fear of Brady. Brady the corporate magician, the machine logician.

I say it is different this year. Yes, Brady has been spectacular. He is the best quarterback in the history of the game over a two-decade stretch. But Gronkowski is playing shell-shocked, and there is no Julian Edelman this go-round. Brady is going to have to do it with Brandin Cooks, Dion Lewis and Danny Amendola. I say that's not enough against the Eagles defense. Plus, I like Philadelphia's running game controlling the clock.

The Philadelphia Eagles will win their first Super Bowl.

Friday, February 2, 2018

Lazy, Infantile U.S. Propaganda on Chemical Weapons in Syria

Both Reuters -- "U.S. says Syria may be developing new types of chemical weapons" -- and the Associated Press -- "US Says Syria Making New Chemical Weapons Despite 2013 Deal" -- ran stories yesterday about Trump administration claims that the Syrian government continues to manufacture chemical weapons and use them on the battlefield.

The lede in the Reuters story by Matt Spetalnick reads "The Syrian government may be developing new types of chemical weapons, and U.S. President Donald Trump is prepared to consider further military action if necessary to deter chemical attacks, senior U.S. officials said on Thursday." The lede in the A.P. story by Josh Lederman is less bellicose, "The Trump administration on Thursday accused Syrian President Bashar Assad's government of producing and using 'new kinds of weapons' to deliver deadly chemicals despite committing to abolish its program in 2013, and said the world must find a way to stop it."

The government officials quoted on background provide no proof for any of their allegations. The intention here is to make sure that it is part of the public record that Syria persists in the use of chemical weapons and the Trump administration has signaled the use of military force.

Spetalnick continues:
A deadly sarin attack on a rebel-held area in April prompted Trump to order a missile strike last year on the Shayrat air base, from which the Syrian operation is said to have been launched.

“We reserve the right to use military force to prevent or deter the use of chemical weapons,” one official said, while declining to specify how serious a chemical attack would have to be to draw a fresh U.S. military response. 
A second official said, however, that the Trump administration hopes that stepped-up international sanctions and diplomatic pressure will help rein in Assad’s chemical weapons program. 
If the international community does not act quickly to tighten the screws on Assad, Syria’s chemical weapons could spread beyond its borders and possibly even “to U.S. shores,” the second official said. 
“It will spread if we don’t do something,” the official warned. 
The officials echoed U.S. Secretary of State Rex Tillerson’s recent accusation that Russia, Assad’s ally in Syria’s multi-sided civil war, bears some responsibility for failing to enforce the chemical weapons ban. 
Russia has denied any complicity, and the Syrian government has said it has not carried out any of the attacks. 
The U.S. officials suggested that if left unchecked there would be more smaller chemical attacks as an “instrument of terror” to compensate for Assad’s lack of adequate manpower to retake some opposition-held areas.
“They think they can get away with it if they keep it under a certain level,” an official said.
It is truly pathetic almost infantile propaganda. Notice the continued use of the "low manpower" rational. Assad apparently must resort to the use of chemical weapons when they offer no tactical advantage because the Syrian Arab Army is woefully understaffed. There is no evidence that this is case.

At least Lederman of the A.P. broaches the topic of why a government would resort to an almost useless weapon only to expose itself to an attack by the global hegemon:
Use of such widely deplored weapons comes with great risk for Assad, raising questions about why he would take the chance. But the officials said the U.S. believes Assad's government sees chemical attacks as an effective way to terrorize rebels and sympathetic populations into fleeing, therefore altering the demographic balance in the Alawite heartland where Assad is trying to consolidate control. Assad is a member of the Alawite sect, an offshoot of Shiite Islam that forms a minority of Syria's population.
This is the same shopworn fantasy recycled: Assad can't stop using chemical weapons because he loves to terrorize his own people.

Champions of American exceptionalism are obsessed by Obama's failure to bomb Damascus after the August 2013 false flag sarin attack in East Ghouta, and they are critical of Trump's almost cosmetic cruise missile attack on Khan Sheikoun last year. They want a massive air strike on Syria. The problem is the Russia S-400 missile defense system.

Thursday, February 1, 2018

The German GroKo

Jacobin has a good interview, "Germany’s Groundhog Day," with Die Linke lawmaker Fabio de Masi. De Masi talks about GroKo, the abbreviation for grand coalition. Negotiations between the Christian Democratic Union (CDU) and the Social Democratic Party (SPD) are presently drawing to a close. Reuters is reporting this morning that a deal will be reached by Sunday.

What makes this iteration of the grand coalition interesting is that it is clearly a death march for the SPD. Party leader Martin Schulz proclaimed after the disastrous federal elections in September that the SPD would return to its social-democratic roots and stand in opposition to any Merkel-led government. Then when Merkel's attempt at a coalition with the Greens and the business-friendly Free Democratic Party collapsed, Schulz quickly performed an about-face.

The problem for Schulz and any future GroKo is that there is fulsome rank'n'file opposition within the SPD, led principally by its youth wing, JUSOS, and any final deal that emerges has to be ratified by the party membership. As the Reuters story summarizes,
The party's roughly 440,000 members could yet sink any deal as they have the final say in a ballot.
The JUSOS youth wing of the SPD, along with other leftist members, are deeply opposed to rejoining a coalition under Merkel, fearing it will decimate their support.
But something that de Masi said really struck me as being pertinent to the entire mainstream left in the Western neoliberal world:
When Schulz was first elected leader of the SPD, he hinted at reversing some of the labor market reforms that his party introduced with the Agenda 2010. Even vaguely gesturing in this direction caused the party’s polling to go up by nearly 10 percent. However, the SPD stayed in government instead of using a potential majority with Die Linke and the Greens in the last parliament to correct some of their past mistakes, cause snap elections and set the agenda. Hence, the Schulz hype was only temporary. There is a substantial section of voters that the SPD could tap into, who are disappointed, but who also have unfortunately not become Die Linke voters.
Democrats in the U.S. could mop up at the polls if they replaced their old leaders and then pledged to reverse peak neoliberalism. That they don't is proof that centrist parties of the left will continue to disintegrate. Corbyn's Labour seems to be the only exception.

Wednesday, January 31, 2018

Democratic Panic

The dream machine is spinning furiously as the clock ticks on #ReleaseTheMemo. On Monday the House Intelligence Committee voted along party lines to release a secret memo written by committee staffers. The memo exposes FBI use of information from the dubious "Steele Dossier" to acquire a FISA wiretap warrant against a member of the Trump campaign. Eileen Sullivan explains in "Answers About the Secret Memo on the Trump-Russia Inquiry":
What does the memo say?
The memo, according to people who have seen it, is a short summary of some of the intelligence used to support a government request to secretly surveil Carter Page, the former Trump campaign associate.
In order to obtain the warrant, the F.B.I. and the Justice Department had to show a Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court judge that they had probable cause to show that Mr. Page was acting as a Russian agent.
The memo’s main argument is that the government, in seeking the warrant, did not disclose that information in the application came from research paid for by the Democratic National Committee and Hillary Clinton’s presidential campaign. Mr. Trump has said that the Democrats’ financial ties to the research support his belief that the Democrats are behind the Russia controversy.
The man behind the research is a former British spy, Christopher Steele, who compiled a dossier of explosive, unsubstantiated information about Mr. Trump and Russia. He told the F.B.I. that he was working for interests opposed to Mr. Trump, and the Republicans question whether the intelligence court judge was misled about Mr. Steele’s credibility.
Some Republican lawmakers who have seen the memo have said it reveals that the F.B.I. was biased against Mr. Trump and misused its authorities in its investigation into Russia’s interference in the 2016 presidential election.
But that argument is undercut by another piece of information said to be in the committee memo: that the top official at the Justice Department who is overseeing the Russia investigation, Rod. J. Rosenstein, approved a government application to continue the surveillance of Mr. Page, which was originally approved in mid-October 2016. Mr. Rosenstein is a Republican and was appointed by Mr. Trump.
The highlighted portion is the source of worry for Democrats, #NeverTrump Republicans (who are once again mulling third-party challenge) and the furious spinning at The New York Times. Rosenstein is tainted. Rosenstein is in charge of special counsel Mueller. So if Rosenstein goes, Mueller can't be far behind. This is the long and short of Charlie Savage's "The Real Aim of the Secret Memo Is the Mueller Investigation."

Democrats have reason to be worried. No one, not even mainlining Rachel Maddowites, can coherently explain the Mueller investigation. It has something to do with Russian interference. When you ask, "Does that mean that Russia stole the election from Hillary?" They get defensive and respond, "Hillary won the election!," before accepting that, well, okay, Russia might not have been solely responsible for electing Trump.

So even partisan Democrats are confused, in denial. As for the general public, it has stopped paying attention to the Mueller investigation months ago.

Trump is about to rack up a big win in the info wars. The general public can understand a dirty-tricks campaign (Whitewater and Monica Lewinsky). People will comprehend, as many already do, that all this Russophobia is just politics as usual, standard partisan dirty tricks, and not high crimes and misdemeanors.

Tuesday, January 30, 2018

At War with Pakistan

In office Trump reversed course from the campaign trail and proclaimed a renewed U.S. commitment to the war in Afghanistan. At the beginning of the month, Trump tweeted his disdain for Pakistan's role in that war, and his administration suspended aid to its ally. The response -- crippling Taliban and Islamic State attacks on Kabul -- was predictable.

What's interesting about recent coverage in "the newspaper of record," a sampling of which you will find below, is how explicitly this increase in attacks is connected to Pakistan. The U.S. is at war with our NATO ally Turkey, and it has been at war with Pakistan for quite some time, 17-plus years.

From "As Afghan Attacks Intensify, So Does Anger at Country’s Leaders" by Mujib Mashal and Fahim Abed:
Afghan officials said they had expected the urban attacks to escalate after President Trump this month ratcheted up pressure on Pakistan, long seen as supporting Taliban insurgents as proxies in Afghanistan, and intensified the air campaign against the Taliban in the countryside.
But critics say the political disarray in Kabul has exacerbated the security situation. The government is facing a growing and vocal opposition and has long been strained by a constitutional crisis. Mr. Ghani has struggled to manage, picking what critics call untimely political battles. His recent firing of a powerful provincial governor, who is refusing to leave a post he has held for 13 years, has led to a protracted showdown that is consuming the government’s energy.
In the latest wave of violence, Taliban militants laid siege to a hilltop hotel, fighting for 15 hours and killing at least 22. Then, on Saturday, the Taliban drove an ambulance packed with explosives into the heart of the city, within a earshot of the country’s intelligence agency and other government offices, and slaughtered more than 100 people.
Although the Monday attack at the military university was claimed by the Islamic State, Afghan officials saw it as connected to the Taliban violence. Afghan and Western officials have long spoken of an overlap between the networks that carry out urban attacks for the Taliban and the Islamic State.
The Trump administration announced last month that it would suspend security aid to Pakistan for harboring such terrorist groups. Mr. Ghani, his aides say, has repeatedly warned that Pakistan would push the Taliban to intensify its violence in order to weaken the government here before American pressure could change Pakistan’s long-held calculations.
The war will not end, said Mohammad Masoom Stanekzai, the Afghan intelligence chief, who is facing calls to resign, “without Pakistan stopping the support for terrorists.”
“The mentality there that ‘fighting in Afghanistan is a holy war’ should be eliminated,” he added. “Without that, it is not possible to end the war here.”
Mr. Stanekzai said the international pressure on Pakistan had “translated into revenge on the Afghan people.”
Taliban commanders say they are intensifying the urban attacks as a retaliation for increased airstrikes on their areas. The United States military alone dropped more than 4,000 bombs across Afghanistan in 2017, and the Afghan air force, as it expands with aircraft provided by the United States, increasingly carries out regular bombings. New American military units are expected to arrive, adding to the approximately 14,000 troops already here, to advise and assist the Afghans.
Much of the blame for the security lapse has focused on the leadership of Mr. Ghani, whose voice has been lacking from the public conversation in the face of the bloodletting. He rarely speaks to local news media, and critics accuse him of not understanding the gravity of the situation as he remains mired in trying to fix a broken bureaucracy.
On Monday, Mr. Ghani appeared at a brief news conference along with the visiting president of Indonesia. The day had been declared a national holiday “to free resources” for victims of the earlier attacks, though many suggested that the main motive was to shut down the city for security reasons to make the Indonesian’s visit possible.
Mr. Ghani said the Taliban, who in the past had hesitated to claim responsibility for attacks with high civilian casualties, were now happy to do so because “their masters” — a reference to Pakistan — had been cornered by international pressure. “They did it at the behest of their masters, so their masters can get out of political isolation,” Mr. Ghani said.
He added: “Our blood will not go unanswered.”
From "Attacks Reveal What U.S. Won’t: Victory Remains Elusive in Afghanistan" by Helene Cooper:
In coming months, the total number of American troops in Afghanistan will grow to an estimated 15,000. Nearly a third of them — 4,000 — will have been sent under President Trump’s new war strategy, which he is expected to promote during his State of the Union address on Tuesday night.
“We’re going to finish what we have to finish,” Mr. Trump told reporters Monday at the start of a lunch at the White House with United Nations ambassadors on the Security Council. “What nobody else has been able to finish, we’re going to be able to do it.”
But in a war that began with airstrikes and a few hundred Special Operations forces in 2001, and which later saw as many as 100,000 troops deployed, such promises have been heard before.
[snip] 
On May 27, 2014, Mr. Obama announced that the bulk of American forces would head home. An estimated 100,000 United States troops were in Afghanistan at the peak of war operations; that number would dwindle to 10,000 under Mr. Obama’s strategy.
“It’s time to turn the page on more than a decade in which so much of our foreign policy was focused on the wars in Afghanistan and Iraq,” he said.
That was before the Islamic State arrived on the scene. In 2015, the extremist group rooted in Iraq and Syria marked its arrival in Afghanistan with a suicide bomb attack in Jalalabad, killing more than 30 people and injuring more than 100.
Not to be outdone, the Taliban soon after overran Kunduz — the first time the group had managed to take over a major city since 2001. Afghan government troops, backed by the United States, eventually wrested back control.
By the end of 2016, General Nicholson, the current war commander, said the United States’ support “sends a clear message to the enemies of peace and stability in Afghanistan, and the world, frankly, that they will not win.” Four months later, he ordered the dropping of the “mother of all bombs” — the most powerful conventional bomb in the American arsenal — on an Islamic State cave complex in the Achin district of eastern Afghanistan.
In November, General Nicholson delivered another bright update from Kabul. “The Taliban cannot win in the face of the pressures that I outlined,” he said on Nov. 28. “Again, their choices are to reconcile, live in irrelevance or die.”
From Max Fisher's "Why Attack Afghan Civilians? Creating Chaos Rewards Taliban":
As American-led forces have escalated in response to Taliban gains, they have unintentionally pushed the Taliban toward grislier violence. Airstrikes have forced the Taliban to lie low in rural areas, where they prefer to operate, seizing territory and extorting from locals.
Instead, they have shifted toward terrifying if brief guerrilla-style attacks in Kabul and other urban districts, where American air power is of little use. Though this gains them no territory, it allows them to humiliate the government where it is most visible.
“The city is infiltrated, the city is contaminated,” said Amrullah Saleh, a former intelligence chief.
The government, Mr. Saleh said, often cannot even know whether a suicide bomber entered from outside the city “or whether he is brainwashed here; whether they build the vests here or whether they import.”
The group’s internal dynamics have aligned with its shifting incentives, elevating officers who favor large-scale attacks on civilians.
Sirajuddin Haqqani, who leads the once-semi-autonomous Haqqani Network, a terrorist group closely associated with Al Qaeda, now serves at the Taliban’s No. 2 leader and de facto military planner.
“The Taliban and the Haqqani are the same,” said Sayed Akbar Agha, a former Taliban commander. “Only the government is differentiating between them.”
[snip]
For as long as Afghanistan’s war has raged, Pakistan, which plays a double-game with the Taliban, has been at the center of its seeming intractability.
President Trump, following two presidents who tried and failed to rein in Pakistan’s meddling, publicly chastised Pakistani leaders this month, freezing security aid to Pakistan.
But Ms. Brown said that the United States seemed unready for the all-but-inevitable response to its confrontation with Pakistan. “If you start on the path of escalating pressure, you have to be ready for the other side to escalate,” she said.

Monday, January 29, 2018

The Vietnam War

I am watching The Vietnam War by Ken Burns and Lynn Novick, the ten-episode documentary that PBS broadcast last year. Based on a few things I read online, I was worried that it would champion a revisionist perspective -- that the U.S. Goliath could have triumphed if not for the cowardliness of politicians and students. But so far, I just finished watching episode five, there's been no revisionism of any sort.

A month or two ago, in preparation for the Burns-Novick documentary, I watched Vietnam: A Television History, the 13-episode WGBH-produced documentary which was broadcast in the fall of 1983. No revision there either. The U.S. was beat fair and square by a much more motivated people fed up with colonial domination.

There are differences between the two documentaries. The Burns-Novick film focuses on average soldiers, where the WGBH documentary had lots of wonderful interviews with people at the top of the heap who were still alive in the late-70s/early-80s -- McGeorge Bundy, Madame Nhu.

This morning Yves Smith reposts a Tomgram by Danny Sjursen, "The War That Never Ends (for the U.S. Military High Command): And It’s Not the War on Terror."

Sjursen helpfully summarizes revision when it comes to the Vietnam War and he traces its influence on GWOT:
Historian Gary Hess identifies two main schools of revisionist thinking. There are the “Clausewitzians” (named after the nineteenth century Prussian military theorist) who insist that Washington never sufficiently attacked the enemy’s true center of gravity in North Vietnam. Beneath the academic language, they essentially agree on one key thing: the U.S. military should have bombed the North into a parking lot.
The second school, including Petraeus, Hess labeled the “hearts-and-minders.” As COINdinistas, they felt the war effort never focused clearly enough on isolating the Vietcong, protecting local villages in the South, building schools, and handing out candy — everything, in short, that might have won (in the phrase of that era) Vietnamese hearts and minds.
Both schools, however, agreed on something basic: that the U.S. military should have won in Vietnam.
[snip] 
Petraeus, Mattis, McMaster, and the others entered service when military prestige had reached a nadir or was just rebounding. And those reading lists taught the young officers where to lay the blame for that — on civilians in Washington (or in the nation’s streets) or on a military high command too weak to assert its authority effectively. They would serve in Vietnam’s shadow, the shadow of defeat, and the conclusions they would draw from it would only lead to twenty-first-century disasters.
[snip] 
Today’s leaders don’t even pretend that the post-9/11 wars will ever end. In an interview last June, Petraeus — still considered a sagacious guru of the Defense establishment — disturbingly described the Afghan conflict as “generational.” Eerily enough, to cite a Vietnam-era precedent, General Creighton Abrams predicted something similar. speaking to the White House as the war in Southeast Asia was winding down. Even as President Richard Nixon slowly withdrew U.S. forces, handing over their duties to the South Vietnamese Army (ARVN) — a process known then as “Vietnamization” — the general warned that, despite ARVN improvements, continued U.S. support “would be required indefinitely to maintain an effective force.” Vietnam, too, had its “generational” side (until, of course, it didn’t).
The fundamental thing to understand about the Vietnam War is that South Vietnam was never a real organic entity. Diem managed to kick the French out when he beat the mafia that controlled Saigon. Then when Diem began to lose his grip because of a Buddhist-led popular uprising, the Kennedy administration backed a coup that led to Diem's death. The show was over right there. The U.S. killed the guy who justified the fiction that there was a South Vietnam. Instead, the U.S. decided to pour more and more resources into the country in an attempt to maintain the fiction.

Friday, January 26, 2018

Erdogan Says "Operation Olive Branch" will Proceed Until Turkey Controls Manbij

The Turkish assault on the Kurdish-controlled northwest Syrian region of Afrin continues. The United States foothold in Syria is predicated on a fiction. That fiction is the Syrian Democratic Forces (SDF), a U.S. re-branding of the Kurdish People's Protection Units (YPG). The YPG is a Syrian PKK militia.

There is a good story by Anne Barnard and Ben Hubbard, "Allies or Terrorists: Who Are the Kurdish Fighters in Syria?":
Y.P.G. leaders say theirs is a homegrown movement that sprang up to defend civilians in the early days of Syria’s war and against offensives by the Islamic State.
That role, and the backing of the United States, has transformed the group into the most prominent political and military force in northeastern Syria.
Formerly an impoverished and marginalized minority, Syria’s Kurds now administer substantial territory, where they are teaching Kurdish in schools and setting up local administrations. Critics have accused them of displacing Arabs.
American officials have long sought to minimize the Y.P.G.’s ties to the P.K.K., but Turkey is enraged that the United States is giving military support to a group that idealizes Mr. Ocalan, the sole inmate of an island prison in the Sea of Marmara.
Many Y.P.G. leaders speak openly of their history with the P.K.K., and Kurds from Iraq, Iran and Turkey have joined the movement in Syria.
Mr. Bonsey said there had been hope among the Americans that they could pull the Y.P.G. away from the P.K.K.
But such a prospect appears unlikely — especially with the Kurds now uncertain that they have solid support from the United States, which has sent mixed messages about how strongly it would back them against a Turkish onslaught.
The American ambivalence was clear on Wednesday in comments by Thomas P. Bossert, Mr. Trump’s homeland security and counterterrorism adviser, at the World Economic Forum in Davos, Switzerland.
“I’m not in any way critical of the Turkish decision, but I’m just praying for their longer-term strategic patience,” Mr. Bossert told reporters.
Asked if the Turks should withdraw, Mr. Bossert said, “I would prefer it if for now they would remove themselves from the capital of Afrin.”
The United States effectively gave a green light to the current Turkish offensive against Afrin, urging restraint but emphasizing that it does not work with the Y.P.G. there.
The enclave is in northwest Syria, not connected to a larger territory held by the Syrian Democratic Forces in the country’s northeast, where several small American military bases and several thousand American advisers are.
But Mr. Erdogan has threatened to attack that larger area, beginning with the town of Manbij. The Turks say the Americans promised that the Syrian Democratic Forces would withdraw from such majority-Arab areas after taking them from the Islamic State, but it has not.
The ingredients for this clash have been brewing since Syrians rose up against the authoritarian rule of President Bashar al-Assad in 2011. Within a few years, the northeastern province of Hasaka, with a large Kurdish population as well as Arabs and Assyrians, was effectively ruling itself.
As it became the area’s dominant force, the Y.P.G. tried to implement its vision of a utopian society, inspired by Mr. Ocalan. Influenced by Murray Bookchin, an American anarchist, Mr. Ocalan has called for autonomous rule by local committees unbound by national borders. Proponents say they do not seek to break up Syria but are leading a long-term social revolution that will ensure gender and minority rights.
Reuters is reporting that in a speech today Erdogan reiterated that the goal of Turkish military campaign is to take Manbij. Problem there is that is where the U.S. Special Forces have a base:
ANKARA/BEIRUT (Reuters) - President Tayyip Erdogan said on Friday Turkish forces would sweep Kurdish fighters from the Syrian border and could push all the way east to the frontier with Iraq -- a move which risks a possible confrontation with U.S. forces allied to the Kurds.
The Turkish offensive in northwest Syria's Afrin region against the Kurdish YPG militia has opened a new front in the multi-sided Syrian civil war but has strained ties with NATO ally Washington.
Turkey considers the YPG a terrorist group but the militia has played a prominent role in U.S.-led efforts to combat the hardline Islamic State in Syria.
Since the start of the incursion, dubbed "Operation Olive Branch" by Ankara, Erdogan has said Turkish forces would push east towards the town of Manbij, potentially putting them in confrontation with U.S. troops deployed there.
"Operation Olive Branch will continue until it reaches its goals. We will rid Manbij of terrorists, as it was promised to us, and our battles will continue until no terrorist is left until our border with Iraq," Erdogan said in a speech in Ankara.
Any drive by Turkish forces toward Manbij, part of Kurdish-held territory some 100 km (60 miles) east of Afrin, could threaten U.S. efforts in northern Syria.
The United States has about 2,000 troops in Syria, officially as part of the international, U.S.-led coalition against Islamic State.
U.S. forces were deployed in and around Manbij to deter Turkish and U.S.-backed rebels from attacking each other and have also carried out training missions in the area.
Washington has angered Ankara by providing arms, training and air support to the Syrian Kurdish forces. Turkey sees the YPG as an extension of the outlawed Kurdistan Workers Party (PKK), which has waged a deadly insurgency in Turkey's largely Kurdish southeast for three decades.