Showing posts with label immigration reform. Show all posts
Showing posts with label immigration reform. Show all posts

Thursday, June 21, 2018

Trump's Border Flip-Flop

Trump's about-face on separating children from parents caught illegally entering the United States is proof that he knew he was backing a loser. It might have been good for his base -- there is a seething mass of opinion that wants to kill, crush, destroy -- but as senior Capitol Hill scribe Carl Hulse relates below in "G.O.P. Lawmakers Hope Trump’s Border Action Heads Off Political Threat" the battleground this November will be in districts held by the GOP but won by Hillary:
But the president’s quick reversal after multiple definitive declarations that his hands were tied — combined with the palpable Republican relief at the policy change — made it very clear that the party knew it was on the wrong side of the debate. Now the question is whether the president’s action will be enough to quiet the public clamor over the decision to tear children from their families.
[snip]
The politics were clearly bad for Republicans, particularly those most at risk in November. Mr. Trump’s tough talk on immigration might rally his most devoted followers and be a good platform for 2020, but this is 2018.
The Republicans most in danger of losing in November are in swing and suburban districts — many carried by Hillary Clinton in 2016 — and those photographs from the border were not playing well. Republicans were already struggling with female voters, and the separation policy was definitely not going to build support with that core voting group.
The DNC, in all its ineptitude, is repeating its 2006 blue dog strategy to take back the House -- white, centrist, pro-gun, anti-single-payer. Bob Moser sketches the contours in "Will Democrats Fumble the 2018 Midterm Elections?":
Democrats have everything going for them in 2018. Here is a party that gets to run against an historically unpopular and palpably dangerous Republican president – Donald F-ing Trump, everybody! – with an equally historic explosion of progressive energy and organizing behind it. At the very least, the Democrats should be able to secure a House majority in November that would give the party a small purchase on power – and a serious way to throw tacks in Trump's road to tyranny. On an average mid-term year since the Civil War, the party out of power has won 32 new seats—and the Democrats, with every conceivable political wind at their back, need only 24. Still, no matter what new daily atrocities belch up from the White House, the party's chances grow more remote all the time – since almost every day also seems to bring a fresh new insult to grassroots Democrats and left-leaning independents.
It started with electing Perez, the choice of the Clintonites, as party chair in the wake of 2016. The former labor secretary began with talk of unity, then immediately axed senior party officials who'd backed Sanders in what progressives called a "purge." Then the DCCC began "shaping" its field of candidates for 2018, following a centrist "Blue Dog" model that Rahm Emanuel, then DNC chair, used to great controversy in 2006—the midterm election that sent a bunch of gun-toting, budget-slashing, Jesus-talking conservative Democrats to Washington. Twelve years later, and a political world removed, the party's idea of a "winning" candidate would be the same: Someone who's well-off enough to "self-fund" in the millions, or well-connected enough to raise big money from others, and who's also willing to follow the Washington consultants' advice about strategy and "messaging."
But a story in Vox -- Dylan Scott, "Charts: Trump is the target of historic voter backlash ahead of the 2018 midterms" -- casts doubt on the Dems ability to repeat a 2006 blue dog wave in 2018. Why? Because in 2006 W. didn't have his base firmly beneath him as Trump does now:
The most recent midterm election to be defined to this degree by opposition to the president, according to Pew, is 2006. That year, during the height of the backlash to the Iraq War and after a failed GOP run at privatizing Social Security, 65 percent of Democratic voters said their vote would be against George W. Bush. The result was that Democrats won 31 seats in the House and retook control of the chamber.
If there is any hope for Republicans, it’s that their voters are still mostly united behind Trump, even as the president galvanizes his opposition. A majority of Republicans say they will be voting for Trump in 2018, a much higher share than said they were voting for Bush in 2006 and even outpacing the share of Democrats who said they would be voting for Obama in 2010 and 2014.
And while Democrats are celebrating Trump's flip-flop, Caitlin Johnstone reminds us, "Democrats Finally Deviate From 'Let’s Start World War 3' Midterm Platform," that the policy of  separation was bipartisan:
Last night Rachel Maddow finally took a break from her relentless warmongering toward Russia, Syria and North Korea to have a pretend cry about the plight of immigrant children on her hit MSNBC show. It was arguably the climax of a loud nationwide outcry against a federal policy of separating parents from their children when they are arrested for illegally crossing the border from Mexico into the United States, and the following day President Trump signed an executive order suspending that policy while congress comes up with some less draconian legislation.
And of course the entire thing was phony from top to bottom. The policy Trump’s political opponents have been blaming on the current administration was actually bipartisan and several administrations in the making, and as with many US policies simply grew progressively more depraved with each new president. The executive order leaves the debate over many, many immigration issues still unresolved, including the fact that it just means families will now be imprisoned together under Attorney General Jeff Sessions’ new “zero tolerance policy”, and the fact that thousands of families will still remain separated. And of course the entire furor only became a mainstream issue because midterm elections are coming up and the “Russia, Russia, Russia” platform of the last year and a half hasn’t exactly energized the Democratic party’s base. And of course that soulless bitch Maddow, who will cheerfully help inflame tensions between nuclear powers in order to give her ratings a bump, was 100 percent acting throughout the entire scene.
But you know what? I’ll take it.
Billionaire centrist Mike Bloomberg plans to plunk down $80 million towards blue dog victory. But he will demand a litmus test on gun control, I would imagine, and most blue dogs, like Conor Lamb, are blue dogs because they are pro-life and pro-gun.

And let's not forget Democrats scandalously backtracked on threats to halt the government early in the year in support of the Dreamers. So immigration isn't necessarily a golden ticket.

Saturday, November 22, 2014

Captain America #24 + Captain America #25

Wednesday evening is a big night out for me. I go to a taqueria off Pine Street and get a takeout bean burrito. I visit for a bit with the young Mexican guy who runs the taco shop; he is friendly without being obsequious and extremely efficient; a solid citizen who enriches the community where I live. Another warm acquaintance of mine is also an immigrant from Mexico. My Latina friend with whom I ride the bus in SeaTac and who cleans rooms at the airport motel next to the building where I work is a paragon of decency; she works six days a week and never fails to be warm and polite.

I consider these two people -- immigrants, I'm not sure of their legal status -- the finest individuals I come in contact with in public. To make political hay by stirring up hard-shell nativism and bigotry is not only suicidal, given the obvious demographic trends, but it is morally wrong as well. Mexicans are just as American as Captain America if you ask me.

From the taqueria I walk north on Broadway past the community college. A few blocks after the college I arrive at the neighborhood comic shop where I pick up the week's new releases.

As I enter, the proprietor greets me by name. This week he suggests that I read the latest Daredevil issue.

A big, bearded, barrel-chested guy with a earring and a puka-shell necklace wearing a yellow t-shirt (I'm wrapped in several layers; it's cold) standing in front of the wall where the new releases are displayed chirps, "I can't stand Mark Waid."

Mark Waid writes Daredevil.

"It's always the same precious, 'Oh, look at me! Aren't I witty?' crap," says Big Yellow.

Big Yellow then proceeds to recapitulate the history of the Daredevil title the last five years. I engage in dialogue with him; tell him I wasn't a big fan of Shadowland. Then I shift gears, pointing to the cover of the comic book he holds in his hands. "There's the guy I like."

The name on the cover I was pointing to was Remender. The comic Big Yellow was holding? All-New Captain America #1.

"I'm excited that Sam Wilson is finally getting his due," says Big Yellow.

"What I could never figure out is how Sam Wilson could go from being an island kid to a Harlem badass," I say, proceeding to confuse Big Yellow by imparting to him my own confusion.

I remember reading the Stan Lee-Gene Colan Falcon origin, Captain America #117, as a kid. Falcon is Sam Wilson's superhero alter ego. Sam Wilson is a fresh-faced youth with a trained hawk, Red Wing, on a tropical island (I thought it was Trinidad and Tobago; turns out it was an island off Haiti) who comes to the assistance of Red Skull. The Red Skull is getting shit-kicked by a bunch of Nazis. Turns out the Red Skull is actually Steve Rogers, a.k.a., Captain America. The real Red Skull, using the Cosmic Cube, has traded identities with Captain America. So while the Red Skull is parading around Manhattan sucking up adulation as the star-spangled Avenger, Captain America is fighting for his life against a group of war criminals that the Red Skull double-crossed one time too many.

Confusing.

Anyway, it turns out I was confused. Sam Wilson is not an islander but a Harlem native who answered a newspaper ad soliciting workers to come to the tropics. Steve Rogers/Red Skull trains Sam up to superhero status, gets him a costume and an alter ego, the Falcon -- and away they go.

In Captain American and the Falcon #144, Sam Wilson loses his pretty green outfit and gets the red-and-white costume (not unlike the Atlanta Falcons white jersey) and the gold nose-guard that we have come to associate with the character. A year or two later, during the Watergate era, is when I became a regular reader of Captain America and the Falcon. By this time Sal Buscema had taken over the penciling duties and Steve Englehart was the writer. Sam Wilson was no longer the ingenue sidekick; he was one tough brother, pure Black Power muscle. These comic books are a treasure trove of early '70s Americana.

Anyway, Big Yellow just stared back at me as if I were unhinged, babbling as I was about Sam Wilson's origins.

The scans you will find below are from the final two issues of the Captain America devoted to the Dimension Z storyline. The Iron Nail, the loser in a fight to the death with Captain America, managed to strip the Super-Soldier serum from Cap's DNA, leaving Steve Rogers a frail old man.

As the Avengers battle Arnim Zola's Dimension Z hoards in downtown Manhattan, the Falcon flies a ticking super-bomb to the stratosphere, sacrificing his life so the inhabitants of the megalopolis might live.

Remender is not afraid to embrace the hoariest, clunkiest conventions of the genre.

Fear not though, Sam Wilson is not dead. In the end, his Stark-designed vibranium wings shield him from the lethal blast. Only the Falcon character shuffles off, while Sam Wilson is reborn as the "All-New" Captain America.

Remender, whose writing is always to be read with an eye to the present political age, is making a statement here, I believe, about the failure of our first black president. Sam Wilson, the son of community organizers, Marvel's first African-American superhero, is taking his shot as leader of the Free World. Will he fail like Obama? Or will Remender, a true radical, render this black Captain America, albeit if only as a counterfactual, a triumph?







Friday, November 14, 2014

Why This Pervasive Sense of Doom?

On the train home from work last night, reading an article on the collapse of honeybee colonies (Dady Chery, The Bee’s Vanishing Act), I realized why it is there is this pervasive sense of doom that shrouds everything these days. No longer as a society do we structure in -- acknowledge the merit of -- repose.

Formerly in the United States there was a widely shared cultural vision of the importance -- the justice and fairness -- of a secure retirement. One would toil his or her heart and soul away, kissing youth goodbye, at a job(s), usually dehumanizing, with the promise that eventually one would get to relax for maybe a decade or two of dotage.

At the beginning of this year when the Boeing Machinists approved, following threats by the employer (backed by politicians elected by means of union support), an end to their defined-benefit pension, a line was crossed. The palm at the end of the American mind -- retirement with a good defined-benefit pension -- has been chopped down.

The Great Recession knocked my union's pension plan into the red. One of the moves the plan trustees made to get back into the black was to abolish "the rule of 80." The rule of 80 states that once a plan participant hits age 55, any years of credited service in the plan plus the participant's age that add up to 80 or more allows the participant to retire early with full benefits. In other words, the "gold standard."

My idea was to be done with the rat race by 59. That is what it would take me under the rule of 80. I would retire to California and spend the remainder of my days reading books I want to read -- on ancient Egypt, Big Foot, Robert Caro's LBJ opus -- and jogging beneath an orange sun.

But shortly after the Lehman meltdown, the rule of 80 was rescinded and so was the daydream of freeing myself at 59.

It is war all the time. That is what it is. And that is what I realized sitting on the train last night. The Hobbesian state of nature, the war of all against all, which supposedly motivates us to come together and form a society, is actually the basis of our culture now. And no better representative of this is the Grand Old Party, an absolutely contrived diabolical corporate machination designed solely to expand the prerogatives of the super-rich. That the Democrats have been beaten repeatedly by these soulless ghouls proves that they are no better.

Bear this in mind next week or next month when Obama announces his immigration plan. That plan was rolled out by the Gray Lady yesterday, "Obama Plan May Allow Millions of Immigrants to Stay and Work in U.S.," as part of the post-midterm debacle counterattack that the administration has skillfully put forth -- along with net neutrality and the China carbon-reduction accord -- to mobilize its broader base of support.

Republican leadership is talking tough, even going so far as to mention the possibility of a government shutdown if Obama extends protections to millions of undocumented immigrants. The Tea Party will be stirred up. No doubt there will be angry rallies of white people with rifles held aloft.

The optics favor the Democrats. It's a good political move by Obama. It empowers the knuckle-draggers in the GOP and accentuates the fissure with the Chamber of Commerce Rovian brain trust, who favor an immigration deal.

In the end, if past iterations of Potomac Armaggedon are a guide, a deal will be cut, and that deal will likely be one which sells the undocumented down the river.

But maybe the GOP's pandering to Dixiecrat nativism will finally bust the seams of the party. We can only hope. It is doubtful though.

Which leaves us only the repose offered by the mind. For me, now, it is the idea that this weekend I will watch football on television while eating an entire bag of clementine oranges.

Friday, April 19, 2013

Stasis

Columns this morning by David Brooks and Paul Krugman each highlight stasis. Krugman argues in "The Excel Depression" that despite the discrediting of the main pro-austerity study by Carmen Reinhart and Kenneth Rogoff, "Growth in a Time of Debt," the anti-deficit mania of ruling elites will continue as before:
So the Reinhart-Rogoff fiasco needs to be seen in the broader context of austerity mania: the obviously intense desire of policy makers, politicians and pundits across the Western world to turn their backs on the unemployed and instead use the economic crisis as an excuse to slash social programs. 
What the Reinhart-Rogoff affair shows is the extent to which austerity has been sold on false pretenses. For three years, the turn to austerity has been presented not as a choice but as a necessity. Economic research, austerity advocates insisted, showed that terrible things happen once debt exceeds 90 percent of G.D.P. But “economic research” showed no such thing; a couple of economists made that assertion, while many others disagreed. Policy makers abandoned the unemployed and turned to austerity because they wanted to, not because they had to. 
So will toppling Reinhart-Rogoff from its pedestal change anything? I’d like to think so. But I predict that the usual suspects will just find another dubious piece of economic analysis to canonize, and the depression will go on and on.
David Brooks in "The Second Wave" limns the current state of the GOP. He discounts any long-term impact to Republicans for blocking gun control legislation. Brooks sees a rift in the party that, based on recent history, will likely scuttle any immigration reform legislation:
The main reason the gun issue won’t significantly harm Republicans is that it doesn’t play into the core debate that will shape the future of the party. The issue that does that is immigration. The near-term future of American politics will be determined by who wins the immigration debate. 
In the months since the election, a rift has opened between the Republicans you might call first-wave revolutionaries and those you might call second-wave revolutionaries. The first-wave revolutionaries (the party’s Congressional leaders) think of themselves as very conservative. They ejected the remaining moderates from their ranks. They sympathize with the Tea Party. They are loyal to Fox News and support a radical restructuring of the government.
The second wavers are much more tactically aggressive, favoring filibusters and such when possible. What the party needs now, they argue, is an ultra-Goldwaterite insurgency that topples the “establishment,” ditches immigration reform and wins Hispanic votes by appealing to the evangelicals among them and offering them economic liberty. 
The first and second wavers are just beginning their immigration clash. A few weeks ago, I would have thought the pro-immigration forces had gigantic advantages, but now it is hard to be sure. 
The immigration fight will be pitting a cohesive insurgent opposition force against a fragile coalition of bipartisan proponents who have to ambivalently defend a sprawling piece of compromise legislation. We’ve seen this kind of fight before. Things usually don’t end up well for the proponents. 
Whether it’s guns or immigration, it is easy to imagine that the underlying political landscape, which prevented progress in the past, has changed. But when you actually try to pass something, you often discover the underlying landscape has not changed. The immigration fight of 2013 might bear an eerie similarity to the fight of 2007.
High unemployment, an unresponsive political system, a perverse concentration of wealth, a distracted and harried populace -- the classical understating of stasis, that it results in civil war and/or tyranny, merits attention in our current situation.

Friday, February 8, 2013

Immigration Reform Could Be a Longtime Coming

The word from on high as passed down to us little folk at the political action committee meeting Wednesday night is that immigration reform is coming our way fast and furious and it should happen quickly. The messenger, a woman who is plugged in at the state labor council, then added sardonically, "But that's what they said about the healthcare law."

Apropo of this is Steven Greenhouse's story this morning about the AFL-CIO working with the Chamber of Commerce on an immigration overhaul. A sticking point is the guest-worker program; the same sticking point that scuttled Bush's attempt at an immigration overhaul in 2007.

Labor is pushing for a body of experts to determine, based on certain data, how many provisional visas to issue at any one time. Business is fighting back saying that such a system wouldn't work; it would create another unwieldy government bureaucracy unresponsive to employer needs.
Labor unions have urged business to embrace a plan pushed by Ray Marshall, labor secretary under President Jimmy Carter. He suggests creating a commission of experts who would use economic data to determine, for instance, whether 20,000 or 40,000 immigrants should be granted provisional visas to do seasonal work nationwide at shellfish plants, restaurants or apple orchards.
“Instead of a system that works at the whim of any employer, it will be a data-driven system,” said Richard Trumka, president of the A.F.L.-C.I.O. Under the current system, he noted, employers have applied repeatedly for new batches of guest workers. A data-driven system would ensure an adequate flow of immigrants to help employers meet seasonal needs, he said.

Mr. McBurney of the hotel association disagreed. “It will never work,” he said. “There are no experts who will know exactly what the economy will need — this was proved by command and control economies. The bureaucracy will never be able to respond to the economy. The economy is a very dynamic thing. Bureaucracies aren’t so dynamic.”
Randel K. Johnson, senior vice president for labor policy at the United States Chamber of Commerce, agreed. “We oppose the commission because it would never be able to determine shortages in a timely manner that reflect the always-changing realities of the marketplace.”
One way unions have moved closer to the Chamber is that many have embraced the E-Verify system to screen new hires:
In another important step forward, many labor unions have joined with the Chamber of Commerce and other business groups in embracing E-Verify, a federal electronic system that uses Social Security numbers and other data to verify that newly hired workers are in the country legally. Union leaders have frequently denounced E-Verify as error-prone, a continuing concern. They said it often declared that immigrants with valid papers were not authorized to work.
When I worked at the carpenters local we often went to bat for guys who got tagged by E-Verify; a service representative would walk them through getting a temporary Social Security Card and then fight the employer to accept that as a valid form of identification.

Based on a reading of Greenhouse's story the woman from the state labor council might be right. It could be a new immigration law will be a longtime coming.