Showing posts with label Yazidis. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Yazidis. Show all posts

Wednesday, March 21, 2018

Why is Ghouta so Important to the West?

The Western press has achieved Goebbelsesque levels of distortion in its presentation of  the jihadists' loss of their mortar launch pad of eastern Ghouta. I can think of no better example of this than "‘We Were Dying in There’: Thousands of Syrians Flee Rebel Enclave," by Nada Homsi and Nick Cumming-Bruce. (Cumming-Bruce is The New York Times chief propagandist in Geneva. His job is to filter information that comes out of the United Nations offices there, amplifying the humanitarian crimes of official enemies while air-brushing away any U.S. misdeeds.)

Homsi and Cumming-Bruce ostensibly write about the Syrian government evacuation of civilians  held hostage by the Salafi jihadists in eastern Ghouta. But since this is an unalloyed tale of victory for Syria and its Russian ally, Homsi and Cumming-Bruce execute a switch-up and instead discuss the systematic use of rape by the Syrian Arab Army and its militias. There is no hyperlink to the UN Commission of Inquiry report within the NYT story, but here it is.

Homsi and Cumming-Bruce skew the summary of the report in favor of the Salafi jihadists, making it seem as if they were less criminal than their enemies. Judge for yourself:
United Nations investigators said Thursday that Syrian government troops and affiliated militias had raped and sexually assaulted women and men in a systematic campaign to terrorize, humiliate and punish civilians seen as linked to the opposition — actions that amounted to crimes against humanity.
Opposition armed groups had also committed rapes and sexual violence. Although such acts by rebels were “considerably less common,” the investigators said, extremists had carried out executions and harsh punishments to enforce their rigid social order.
The United Nations Commission of Inquiry monitoring Syria’s conflict said it had documented the rape of women and girls in 20 government detention facilities and military intelligence branches between 2011 and 2016, and the same violence against men and boys in 15 branches.
Such attacks were “not isolated incidents but rather part of a pattern observed countrywide,” the investigators said in a 29-page report, which the panel’s chairman, Paolo Pinheiro, said was “based on 454 powerful, devastating interviews” with victims and witnesses.
The panel’s hope, he added, was that the report would serve as “an equally powerful trigger for accountability,” he told a meeting at the United Nations in Geneva. It was “particularly repulsive” that such violence continued to go unpunished, he said.
During house raids searching for opposition supporters in the early years of the conflict, troops and militias raped women and forced family members to watch the assault, the panel said.
In detention centers, guards subjected women to humiliating invasive searches, gang rapes and torture to force confessions and extract information. Low-ranking officers were often the perpetrators, the panel found, but “numerous cases of rapes by high-level officers have also been documented.”
Male detainees, some as young as 11, also suffered a wide range of sexual abuse, including rape, torture and genital mutilation. Investigators said they had documented such abuse in the political security and military intelligence branches in Aleppo, Hama, Idlib, Tartus and Damascus, including the infamous Sednaya Prison, sometimes “seemingly for amusement.”
Rape and sexual violence by armed opposition groups was not systematic, the panel said, but throughout the conflict it had received regular reports of extremist groups attacking people suspected of being gay, including throwing them off rooftops.
Militant groups such as the Nusra Front and the Islamic State had sentenced women accused of adultery to death by stoning, and subjected women who violated their dress codes to lashings. In areas controlled by Islamic State, women and girls as young as 14 were forced to marry fighters.
When I read this over the weekend two things raked up a stench right away. New York Times readers know that to ISIS "marriage" is a euphemism for rape. If  Homsi and Cumming-Bruce would have scrolled to page 19 of the report they would find: "Many women were passed between multiple ISIL fighters, some as many as six or seven times within two years." Rukmini Callimachi has written about "marriages" that last for 45 minutes.

Then, also on page 19, a direct refutation of the "not systematic" claim:
Until mid-2016, ISIL did not allow their members who “owned” Yazidis to sell the Yazidi children separately. This rule was changed in mid-2016 and resulted in the separation of children from their mothers and subsequent sale of young boys as house servants, and girls as young as nine years as sexual slaves. Such children are often then given Muslim names. Identifying their ancestry remains problematic.
Once again, readers of the "newspaper of record" know that ISIS strictly codified a system of sexual slavery. So why is it undercutting all that reporting now with disingenuous stories out of Geneva, stories that make the jihadists sound better than the Syrian government?

Keeping a foothold in eastern Ghouta must really be important to the United States Government. Elijah Magnier explains why in "Will Syria be the Battleground for All-Out War Between Russia and America?":
The US’s anger at the Syrian-Russian attack on al-Ghouta needs to be made clearer here: the US occupation of al-Tanf Syrian-Iraqi borders aimed to create a launching platform for its military operations towards Deir al-Zour in the north and al-Ghouta in the east. The US plan was to occupy the city of Deir al-Zour and al-Qaim north-east and the capital Damascus. But Iran went around the area where the US forces were positioned, isolating these in the al-Tanf pocket, and made a qualitative leap to liberate Deir al-Zour and al-Qaim by defeating ISIS forces, who withdrew towards the US area of influence east of the Euphrates.
Moreover, Al-Ghouta is a clear demonstration of the US’s failed plan to attack Damascus. The strategic military planning and link between al-Tanf and al-Ghouta was possible had the Syrian Army and Russia not intervened on time to surround it and attack jihadists to force these to surrenderer and pull out to Idlib. The US thought to create a real menace against Damascus and at least prevent the parliamentary and presidential elections due next year. By controlling Ghouta, jihadists were supposed to keep up the pace of bombing to render the Syrian capital “unsafe”.
The US and the International community tried to stop the battles of al-Ghouta to no avail. This prompted Washington to exercise its favourite hobby of imposing sanctions on Russia, without succeeding in stopping the Syrian army (fighting without its allies – except Russia) from recovering its control over Ghouta. The answer came immediately from Moscow by bombing Daraa and hitting al-Qaeda’s area of influence in an indication as to where the future theatre of military operations is expected to be.
Again, events are moving very fast: the US response came quickly through its UK ally when Britain took advantage of the poisoning of the former Russian spy Sergey Skripal in London to accuse Moscow of being behind his assassination. The message here is clear: all means are legitimate for the control of the Middle East, specifically Syria.
Israel followed by demanding the return of the UNDOF troops, withdrawn in August 2014 following the abduction of 47 UN peacekeepers by al-Qaeda (the ransom for their liberation was paid by Qatar). The Israeli demand coincided – I have learned from well informed sources – with the gathering of forces of Syria’s allies, including Hezbollah, in Daraa, in preparation for future wide scale military operations. The US considers that the battle of Daraa is directly against itself and its Israeli ally, especially as it is party, along with Russia and Jordan, to the agreement to reduce the escalation there, to serve Israel and secure its security in southern Syria.
In this tense political climate it requires no imagination to link the issue of the Russian former spy to the aggressive statement of President Vladimir Putin and other Russian officials who threatened to use military force against the US and any other country in Syria if necessary.
The Syrian war is far from being a normal one. It is THE war between two superpowers and their allies, where US and Russian soldiers are directly involved on the ground in a war of domination and power. The lack of victory in the US eyes is worse than losing a battle. Even more, the victory of Russia and its allies on Syrian soil in any battle is therefore a direct blow to the heart of Washington and its allies.
Russia understood the US, UK and NATO’s message, including that of the mainstream media, and had no other choice but to escalate the pace of war in Syria as harshly as possible.
The superpowers are on the verge of the abyss, so the danger of falling into a war of cosmic proposition is no longer confined to the imagination or merely a sensational part of unrealistic calculations.
Will Damascus be the door of a major war that destroys everything? Asking the question is very important : but it is a very difficult question to answer.

Tuesday, March 20, 2018

The Crime of the Century

I read Patrick Cockburn's The Rise of Islamic State (2015) over the weekend. I've had a copy of the book for several months, but what motivated me to pick it up on Saturday and dig in -- it's a quick read -- was a story in The New York Times by Catherine Porter, "Canada Struggles as It Opens Its Arms to Victims of ISIS," about how refugee agencies in Canada have been overwhelmed by 1,200 Yazidis who were victims of ISIS.

This seems to me to be the crime of the century, the whole Timber Sycamore fiasco of the Obama administration -- the covert war against Syria which uses Al-Qaeda-type groups, as Cockburn prefers to call them, of which ISIS was one, which is to say, Salafi jihadists financed by the Gulf monarchies, as proxies.

As Glen Ford noted last week in "Going Down With the Bad Ship U.S.A.":
“Do you realize now what you’ve done?” Vladimir Putin demanded of the Americans, at the United Nations, in 2015. “It is hypocritical and irresponsible to make loud declarations about the threat of international terrorism while turning a blind eye to the channels of financing and supporting terrorists, including the process of trafficking and illicit trade in oil and arms. It would be equally irresponsible to try to manipulate extremist groups and place them at one's service in order to achieve one's own political goals in the hope of later dealing with them or, in other words, liquidating them.”
“The U.S. and its junior partners could only project power in the region through an alliance with Islamic jihadist terror.”
Washington’s jihadist strategy has rapidly unraveled ever since. The empire was unmasked in the world’s most public forum, revealing the utter depravity of U.S. policy and, more importantly, the weakness of Washington’s position in the region. The mighty fortress of global capital, the self-appointed defender of the world economic “order,” was revealed as, not just in collusion with head-chopping, women-enslaving, sectarian mass-murdering terrorists, but militarily dependent on the very forces it claims to wage a twilight, “generational” battle to destroy. The U.S. has been spouting The Mother of All Lies, and most of humanity knows it. Deep down, most Americans suspect as much, too.
I read Cockburn's book on ISIS hoping that he would document the links between foreign intelligence agencies and the Salafists. He does, but not in an exhaustive or explicit fashion. He simply asserts that foreign intelligence agencies play an outsize role in Al-Qaeda-type organizations. He mentions the "moderate rebels" canard, which is where pro-Western opposition militias were dummied up to act as pass-throughs for sophisticated weapons, like anti-tank missiles, to the jihadists.

It is all appalling, and the devastated, traumatized Yazidis that Canada is dealing with are just one example. How about the European refugee crisis? The devastated cities of Iraq and Syria? The hundreds of thousands of dead?

What is the appropriate punishment for this covert war? With the Vietnam War at least there was the spectacular humiliation of a super power defeated militarily by a people's army; that acted as a check on U.S. hubris for a decade. So far there has been nothing of the sort in Syria.

The U.S. cannot risk another such defeat in a global environment where the Washington Consensus is shattering and the Dragon and the Bear are on the rise.

So jihadist proxies are what it is going to have to be for the foreseeable future: contrived chemical weapons attacks, punitive U.S. cruise missile strikes, and Salafi foot soldiers.

The defeat of the YPG/YPJ Kurdish militia at the hands of the Turkish Army and its FSA re-branded remnants of ISIS and Jabhat al-Nusra is both a blessing and a curse for the United States. A blessing because the Syrian Kurds have been exposed as critically dependent on U.S. air power. The battle for Kobani that  the YPG/YPJ won against ISIS, handing the caliphate its first significant battlefield defeat the fall of 2014, and which marks the end of Cockburn's book, appears in retrospect to have been singularly dependent on the U.S. Air Force. And a curse because the retreat from Afrin deflates the myth of the Syrian PKK's martial prowess, much as ISIS's attack on Iraqi Kurdistan dealt a blow to the peshmerga, a blow which I don't think it ever recovered.

The U.S. is stymied. It is in this environment that a major blunder could be made. (See Bill van Auken's "Threat of US attack on Syria grows amid fall of 'rebel' stronghold." The best thing I've read on the war in Syria in a while.)

The one hope I harbor is that though U.S. elites are out of touch, they are not so out of touch to think they can embark on another major military escalation in the Middle East without there being a punishing political correction.

The problem here though is that the Democrats are just as hawkish as the GOP now.

Monday, August 17, 2015

Europe's Refugee Crisis: Best Hope for Peace in Syria, but Don't Count on It

The best hope for peace in Syria might very well be the mounting refugee crisis Europe is now confronted with. A good story by Ceylan Yeginsu and Anemona Hartocollis, "Amid Perilous Mediterranean Crossings, Migrants Find a Relatively Easy Path to Greece," detailing how Syrians get from the southern coast of Turkey to the nearby Greek island of Kos, appears in this morning's paper:
The International Organization for Migration, based in Geneva, said Friday that nearly 250,000 migrants had crossed the Mediterranean to Europe this year, already more than for all of 2014. Greece alone, it said, had reported 134,988 arrivals from Turkey this year. 
Singling out the strain on Greece, the United Nations has called for urgent action to address the crisis in Europe. 
For many of the refugees, Greece is seen as a steppingstone to Western Europe. Although Turkey is hosting nearly two million Syrian refugees, more than any other country, many Syrians say that they do not see a future there. 
To get to Europe, they depend on a vast illegal migrant smuggling operation that has grown over the past year as the Syrian civil war grinds on.
The problem for Europe is that it is wedded to the U.S.-Turkey-GCC regime-change policy dictating that Assad must go in order for there to be any peace. This policy of course has led to the efflorescence of jihadi groups using Turkey as an entry point to Syria and Iraq. Now we have a caliphate where slavery is practiced.

A particularly disturbing story by Rukmini Callimachi appeared last Friday, "ISIS Enshrines a Theology of Rape," which explains how the caliphate uses captured Yazidi girls and women as sex chattel. Here is how Callimachi ends her piece:
One 34-year-old Yazidi woman, who was bought and repeatedly raped by a Saudi fighter in the Syrian city of Shadadi, described how she fared better than the second slave in the household — a 12-year-old girl who was raped for days on end despite heavy bleeding. 
“He destroyed her body. She was badly infected. The fighter kept coming and asking me, ‘Why does she smell so bad?’ And I said, she has an infection on the inside, you need to take care of her,” the woman said. 
Unmoved, he ignored the girl’s agony, continuing the ritual of praying before and after raping the child. 
“I said to him, ‘She’s just a little girl,’ ” the older woman recalled. “And he answered: ‘No. She’s not a little girl. She’s a slave. And she knows exactly how to have sex.’’’ 
“And having sex with her pleases God,” he said.
No wonder there is a refugee crisis. What Turkey facilitated on the front end by funneling jihadis across the border, it is now promoting on the back end by acting as a transit center for not only Syrians, Afghans, Iraqis, but Pakistanis and Bangladeshis as well.

Expect the number of refugees to mount. Increased fighting appears to have returned to the suburbs surrounding Damascus. The UNHCR is calling for a plan of action. The problem is that right-wing nativism is on the upswing in Europe. Governments will not want to risk popular reaction by implementing a system that will lead to the introduction of more refugees.

The obvious thing to do would be to end the fighting in Syria and Iraq and roll up the Islamic State. But Europe cannot exercise its sovereignty when it comes to war and peace. The U.S. calls the shots. We saw this clearly in Ukraine.

So the U.S. double game -- aiding the jihadis while fighting the jihadis -- will continue and the European Union will likely continue to fracture.

Monday, September 1, 2014

U.S. and Asaib Ahl al-Haq Allies Against ISIS: Great Satan Shows Multiple Personalities

Something shifted in U.S. policy vis-a-vis Islamic State at the beginning of August. That is when ISIS took Mosul Dam from the pesh merga and it looked like the capital of Kurdistan, Erbil, was in danger of being overrun. ISIS was also targeting the Yazidis, scattering their communities and creating a humanitarian crisis on Mount Sinjar.

It was then that the United States shifted from basically ignoring Islamic State to suddenly sounding the alarm. The extent of this shift is on full display today in the frontpage article by Tim Arango and Azam Ahmed, "U.S. and Iran Unlikely Allies in Iraq Battle." U.S. air power operating in concert with Kurdish pesh merga, Iraqi Army and, most importantly, Iraqi Shiite jihadi militia broke the siege of Shiite Turkmen villages clustered around Amerli. The Shiite militias included Sadrists, Badr Ogranization and Asaib Ahl al-Haq:
The Obama administration has tried to avoid being seen as taking sides in a sectarian war, because the Shiite militias are especially feared by Iraq’s Sunnis.
But for the weekend at least, the realities on the ground appeared to override any concerns of effectively supporting the militias.
ISIS has been rampaging through Iraq, beheading prisoners, carrying out massacres of Shiites and expelling hundreds of thousands of residents. The Shiite militias have been accused of some recent abuses against Sunnis, but so far have avoided large-scale revenge killings.

Among the militias fighting for Amerli are Asaib Ahl al-Haq, considered the most fearsome of Iraq’s Shiite militias, and a group linked to the Shiite cleric Moktada al-Sadr, one of the Americans’ most unyielding enemies during the occupation. Those groups are supported by Iran. 
Asaib, a militia that was a particularly fierce opponent of the United States as it was winding down its military role in Iraq, was said to have taken on the most prominent role in the fighting for Amerli, in Salahuddin Province.
“I would like to thank the jihadists from Asaib Ahl al-Haq, as they are sacrificing their lives to save Amerli,” said Mahdi Taqi, a member of the provincial council in Salahuddin. 
Naeem al-Aboudi, the spokesman for Asaib, said, “today is a great happiness and victory for all Iraqis. Iraqi security forces, volunteers and resistance brigades have proved their ability to defeat ISIS.”
And what makes this ironic and signals a sea change in U.S. policy in Iraq, Syria and Iran is Asaib Ahl al-Haq is sponsored by Iran's Quds Force, an American bête noire akin to Vladimir Putin, Bashar al-Assad or Hezbollah.

The U.S. is denying coordination with the Iraqi Shiite militias, but, make no mistake, coordination is occurring. How it works is that the U.S. communicates through the pesh merga and the Iraqi Army who then communicate to the Asaib Ahl al-Haq, the Sadrists and Badr Organization:
As night fell Sunday, the fighting was still raging in Qaryat Salam, a village to the north of Amerli. At a makeshift forward base, set up amid half-constructed homes and the hulk of a new soccer stadium, Kurdish pesh merga forces fired a barrage of artillery, mortars and rockets. A line of trucks roared into the area, their headlights smeared with mud to dull the brightness. An assortment of Kurdish fighters, Iraqi Army soldiers and Shiite militia members, who seemed to be working together in a highly coordinated way, passed by. 
Several Iranian military advisers were also seen, according to a pesh merga fighter. 
“We are cooperating with the pesh merga and other military forces,” said Abd Kadum al-Mousaw, a militia fighter. “From each force there is a commander who is a member of a higher committee that makes decisions.” 
Pesh merga commanders said they had cleared about half of the village, but were facing stiff resistance from the militants, “who were fighting like madmen.”
Of course this has set off some hand-wringing in the Deep State, which, hitched as it is to Israel and Saudi Arabia, is addicted to Iran hatred. What better way to note this than have the disgraced former DCIA David Petraeus bleat the conventional wisdom?
David Petraeus, a former top American military commander in Iraq who led the United States troop surge in 2007, months ago warned against such possibilities as the Obama administration, reeling from the fall of Iraq’s second largest city, Mosul, weighed military action against ISIS. 
“This cannot be the United States being the air force for Shia militias or a Shia-on-Sunni Arab fight,” he said at a security conference in London in June. “It has to be a fight of all of Iraq against extremists, who do happen to be Sunni Arabs.”
There is a tendency on the anti-imperialist left to see a grand intelligence at the Deep State control board. What the U.S. turnabout on Islamic State shows is that there is not a monolithic master plan at work here.

In Iraq USG is working with a Quds Force proxy, while in Libya it is working with Sunni salafis backed by Qatar and Turkey in a proxy war against Saudi Arabia, UAE and Egypt. Then in Syria USG is working with the Saudis -- the Syrian National Coalition is a joint Saudi-U.S. front group.

It is not multi-dimensional chess being played by Great Satan; it is chaos.