Showing posts with label Wenjian Liu. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Wenjian Liu. Show all posts

Friday, January 2, 2015

Poor, Poor POPO: NYPD Casts Black Lives Matter Protesters as Terrorists

Saturday, December 20 was the day that Ismaaiyl Brinsley gunned down two NYPD officers, Wenjian Liu and Rafael Ramos, while they sat in their patrol car in Bed-Stuy. As a result, for the last two weeks the Black Lives Matter protest movement has been crowded out of the newspapers, replaced by the ceremonial charade of Patrolmen's Benevolent Association president Patrick Lynch taking shots at NYC Mayor Bill de Blasio and de Blasio meekly, apologetically replying.

The mainstream media prefers this type of reporting -- tit-for-tat squabbles between camps of officials -- to actually covering popular movements because it requires less work. The reporter gets a quote from one camp, a reply from the other camp, rehashes the main markers of the conflict followed by next steps, and Shazam! Story finished. That is what you have in "Police Unions’ Leaders Air Grievances in 2-Hour Meeting With de Blasio," by Matt Flegenheimer and J. David Goodman.

One interesting quote by a police union official in the Flegenheimer and Goodman piece conflates the Black Lives Matter protests with the Al Qaeda terrorist attacks of 9/11:
Officials with the administration seemed to bet that some of the union leaders might act as peacekeepers, or at least supply more measured voices, in the conflict with the patrolmen’s union. 
However, in an email to members on Tuesday, Roy T. Richter, president of the Captains’ Endowment Association, said that he would allow the Patrolmen’s Benevolent Association to “lead any conversation.” He added that he stood “in solidarity with them as they express raw outrage against the forces that caused the coldblooded assassination of our two brother police officers.” 
Mr. Richter compared the emotional climate of the day to that immediately following the attacks of Sept. 11, 2001. He wrote that he had met privately with Mr. de Blasio — “at his request” — just before Christmas “to give him a blunt critique of the hostile antipolice environment” in the city.
There you have it. Police union leadership blaming protesters for the death of Liu and Ramos, comparing the Black Lives Matter protests and the 9/11 terror attacks. This is the direction we are headed: lawful protest conflated with terrorism.

To highlight the imbalanced, aggrieved state of mind dominant now in the NYPD is yesterday's report by Al Baker and J. David Goodman, "Arrest Statistics Decline Sharply; Police Unions Deny an Organized Slowdown." The NYPD is engaged in a form of wildcat sit-down strike, refusing to make arrests:
. . . [T]he latest official statistics came in. 
Arrests for crimes large and small, as well as tickets for minor infractions, are down drastically across the city. The department has not said whether it believes that officers are acting in concert — as a result of a specific job action — or whether the officers’ deaths produced a spontaneous response.

The two precincts most directly affected by the deaths — the 79th, where Officers Rafael Ramos and Wenjian Liu were gunned down as they sat in their patrol car on a Brooklyn street; and the 84th, where they were usually assigned — saw a single criminal summons in the week that ended Sunday, according to Police Department statistics. Officers in those precincts wrote no parking or traffic tickets. By contrast, the combined tally of criminal summonses alone during the same week last year reached 130, the department statistics showed. 
Mr. Bratton said on Monday that a “weeklong period of mourning” and demonstrations that were straining resources were contributing to the drop-off in arrests and summonses. But he said the slowdown should not concern New Yorkers. “I would point out it has not had an impact on the city’s safety at all,” Mr. Bratton said. 
A top union official flatly denied that there was a job action and pointed to the orders to double up and the need to police demonstrations as the main reasons. 
“No one has sanctioned a slowdown or stoppage,” said Edward Mullins, the president of the Sergeants Benevolent Association. “That is not something that anybody came out and said to do.” 
He added: “We have demonstrations every night of the week, to which cops are being pulled into every night. We have had two officers killed that has changed the everyday duties of what we are doing, and one of those changes is the consistency of patrol cars backing each other up on radio assignments.” 
He said summonses were simply not a priority at moments like this. 
Still, one senior police official who reviewed precinct-level data across the city said the decline had the signs of an organized effort and was continuing this week. 
It is not uncommon for a grieving station house to ease up on enforcement for a brief period. Enforcement numbers can fluctuate from station house to station house, and from week to week, for a number of other reasons, too, including shifts in personnel or directives from commanders. The holidays can also be a factor. 
But the drop-off in activity in Bedford-Stuyvesant and in Downtown Brooklyn could not explain the sharp slowdown in routine enforcement in each of the city’s 77 police precincts, from the 120th in Staten Island to the 47th in the Bronx.

In the week after Officers Ramos and Liu were killed on Dec. 20, the number of summonses for minor criminal offenses, as well as those for parking and traffic violations, decreased by more than 90 percent versus the same week a year earlier. And arrests over seven major categories of felony offenses were nearly 40 percent lower, the numbers show.
My neighborhood was protester ground zero for the historic "Battle in Seattle." For several weeks following the WTO my perception was that policing of the Capitol Hill neighborhood effectively ceased. This was the police's way of saying, "You rise up against us, we will find a way to get back at you." New York City is experiencing something similar.

And all of this in an environment where crime continues to drop (J. David Goodman and Al Baker, "Murders in New York Drop to a Record Low, but Officers Aren’t Celebrating"). So clearly we are dealing here with a sense of police entitlement under siege.

And while for the last two weeks the Gray Lady has dropped her focus on the Black Lives Matter protests, which continue across the country, choosing instead to follow the NYPD tantrum, she published a terrific unsigned editorial the other day, "When New York City Police Walk Off the Job":
The list of [police] grievances adds up to very little, unless you look at it through the magnifying lens of resentment fomented by union bosses and right-wing commentators. The falling murder rate, the increased resources for the department, the end of quota-based policing, which the police union despised, the mayor’s commitment to “broken-windows” policing — none of that matters, because many cops have latched on to the narrative that they are hated, with the mayor orchestrating the hate. 
It’s a false narrative. Mr. de Blasio was elected by a wide margin on a promise to reform the policing excesses that were found unconstitutional by a federal court. He hired a proven reformer, Mr. Bratton, who had achieved with the Los Angeles Police Department what needs doing in New York. The furor that has gripped the city since the Garner killing has been a complicated mess. But what New Yorkers expect of the Police Department is simple: 
1. Don’t violate the Constitution. 
2. Don’t kill unarmed people. 
To that we can add: 
3. Do your jobs. The police are sworn public servants, and refusing to work violates their oath to serve and protect. Mr. Bratton should hold his commanders and supervisors responsible, and turn this insubordination around.
I think the NYPD must be sensing now that business as usual is not going to fly here. But rather than moderate its messaging, it appears to be doubling down. The story by Al Baker this morning, "Man Threatened to Kill Officers, Authorities Say," plays up the poor, poor POPO motif:
The Police Department has now investigated in the past dozen days more than 90 threats it deemed serious among the hundreds that have streamed in from 311, 911, online postings and tips, including eight made on Wednesday through social media sites. 
The first step in analyzing them is to separate angry speech, hate speech and a threat “where someone is indicating they intend to act,” said John J. Miller, the deputy commissioner of intelligence and counterterrorism. 
“What we’ve found in a number of these are, you’ve got dangerous people with serious criminal records, some of whom possessed weapons, who are making these threats,” he said. “And in other cases we’ve found guys who are big and bad over the computer but when the cops knock at their door, they are reduced to tears, saying they were drunk and never really meant anything by it.”
The way that the NYPD has responded to the Black Lives Matter protests after the Liu and Ramos shooting has been fascinating. Petulant, scared, vulnerable yet tough, in command and demanding obeisance from the citizens and elected leaders of the metropolis, it is a portrait of a balling infant coming to understand that mother's body is separate. Baby is on his own.

Thursday, December 25, 2014

"The Kids of Today Should Defend Themselves Against the 70's"


At certain airports, one will come across sections of the concourse and find himself/herself suddenly transported back to the the early 1970s. It is an architectural vision of the future that is blank, invisible, non-partisan. No expectations. I must say I love this feeling when it happens. Because, now, today the future is all filled in, and it is dystopian.

Benjamin Mueller and Nina Bernstein had an article, "Targeted Attack on New York Police Officers Reopens Wounds From the Militant 1970s," in Tuesday's paper, not the first one by the Gray Lady, stoking fear of a Big Apple returned to the violence and upheaval of the bad-ass Black Power early 1970s. Fear of the 1970s. This is a preoccupation of the power elite. When change is in the air and it looks like people aren't going to take it anymore, the '70s are dangled in effigy as a time of chaos and death and failure.
For some members of the New York Police Department, the ambush killing of two officers over the weekend roused memories of a far darker chapter in the department’s past, the 1970s, when violence on the streets and anger at the police erupted into the deliberate murder of some officers. 
There were other similarities — public protests roiling the city and the nation; the police blaming politicians for fomenting antipolice sentiment; and city leaders scrambling to defuse a dangerous divide between law enforcers and the communities they serve.
The drug dealing and rampant crime that characterized that era have faded, but the shooting of Officers Wenjian Liu and Rafael Ramos on Saturday shifted the Police Department into the kind of defensive pose more reminiscent of decades past.
Then, as now, officers were being told to take precautions against the risk of targeted attacks, even though the threat from the Brooklyn gunman, Ismaaiyl Brinsley, appeared to stem at least in part from a history of mental illness and recent expressions of despair.
Forty-six police officers were killed in the line of duty in the 1970s, and 41 more in the 1980s. Before Saturday, the last time an officer was killed in the line of duty was in 2011. 
Some of the assassinations of police officers in the early 1970s were stoked by a militant strain of the black liberation movement, including the explosive killing of Officers Rocco Laurie and Gregory Foster in 1972. 
Officer Foster, 22, of the Bronx, and Officer Laurie, 23, of Staten Island, who had fought together as Marines in Vietnam, were shot dead after walking out of a diner in the East Village just before 11 p.m. on Jan. 27, 1972. They had asked to be placed on patrol in the East Village because it was riddled with crime. 
Killings of police officers have dwindled, and the city has sought to rub out the stain of drugs and violent crime, but people in the law enforcement community say the fatal shootings on Saturday ripped open old wounds. 
“The drive to Bellevue Hospital, the chaos, and the sea of uniforms in and out,” Officer Laurie’s wife, Adelaide Laurie, recalled.
“Please don’t let it be that we are retrogressing to that horrible time in the ’70s,” Ms. Laurie said in an interview on Sunday. She added: “It’s the same idea. No one trusted the police; they were called pigs. I’m just kind of reliving that tragedy all over again.”
The text of story refutes the headline, a sure sign that we are dealing with propaganda here. There is very little that is similar between now and then. Drug use and crime is not the issue it was in the 1970s. I can't remember the last time I walked the streets of a big city and was either hassled or felt menaced. Police are not nearly as at risk. But the theme of the piece nonetheless is "Poor, poor police," and its underlying message is, "The police are feeling afraid and maligned. So don't protest."

Pitiful and woeful as this reasoning is, it will definitely have an impact on the ongoing Black Lives Matter protests. The question becomes, Will the murders of NYPD's Liu and Ramos mark the beginning of the end for the Black Lives Matter upheaval much the same way that Bloomberg's razing of Occupy Wall Street's Zuccotti Park encampment spelled doom for the global Occupy movement?

I don't think so. Why? The political system is non-functioning; it is not providing society a way to release steam through legislation. The U.S. political system is completely captured by money. Money is brittle, inflexible; it wants to maintain or increase dollarocracy even if it is the costliest of all options.

Obama was able to capture, to a large extent, Occupy. Hillary will not be able to yoke Black Lives Matter.