Monday, February 10, 2020

Iowa Caucus: "Fraud for 100 Years"

The New York Times comes to the rescue of the Democratic National Committee with "How the Iowa Caucuses Became an Epic Fiasco for Democrats," a story which places the blame on last week's Iowa meltdown squarely on the Iowa Democratic Party and its chairman Troy Price:
Tom Perez, the chairman of the national committee, placed blame directly on the Iowa Democratic Party and Mr. Price.
“Troy Price was doing his best, but it wasn’t enough,” Mr. Perez said in an interview with The Times on Sunday, noting that while the national and state parties work in partnership, the Iowa Democratic Party is ultimately responsible for administering its own nominating contest.
The D.N.C. approved Iowa’s delegate selection plan, but left the state party to determine on its own how to collect and tabulate caucus results, Mr. Perez said, adding that the national party did not test the state’s app or set standards for training or preparation.
Mr. Perez said he was not responsible for what state parties and their leaders do.
“I do not conduct a performance evaluation of every party chair,” he said.
Asked whether the D.N.C. would increase its scrutiny of other caucuses run by state parties, including Nevada’s in less than two weeks, Mr. Perez said he would “implement all of the lessons learned,” but did not specify how.
This contradicts reporting from last week which said that the DNC played a critical role in the IDP's decision to go with the mobile app when it advised the state party not to report results by telephone.

Shadow Inc., the app developer, is portrayed as a well-meaning victim of IDP incompetence, having been been awarded its contract for the Iowa caucuses as late as the fall of 2019. The Times acknowledges that the company is the creation of former Clinton staffers, but it manages to airbrush Tara McGowan and ACRONYM from the narrative. By airbrushing ACRONYM, which has been the focal point for Lee Fang's reporting, as well as Max Blumenthal's, the bigger picture of the guiding influence of wealthy Democratic donors like Reid Hoffman and Seth Klarman is obscured.

Don't get me wrong. The IDP is much to blame too. At this point it seems likely that the true caucus winner will never be known:
In the Times review of the data, at least 10 percent of precincts appeared to have improperly allocated their delegates, based on reported vote totals. In some cases, precincts awarded more delegates than they had to give; in others, they awarded fewer. More than two dozen precincts appeared to give delegates to candidates who did not qualify as viable under the caucus rules.
The big takeaway from last Monday's caucus is contained in a quote from Jeff Weaver of the Sanders campaign:
“You always had to calculate these numbers, all we’re asking is that you report them for the first time,” Jeff Weaver, Mr. Sanders’s closest adviser, said he told Mr. Price on the call. “If you haven’t been calculating these numbers all along, it’s been a fraud for 100 years.”
The Sanders people suspected that they won the vote in Iowa in 2016 but there was no way they could prove it because there was no reporting requirement for the raw vote and then the vote totals after realignment, only the allocation of delegates. One of the post-2016 reforms that Bernie people pushed for was more transparency in Iowa, and in this they were successful.

Now come to find out, Iowa, the first vote of the presidential primary, is nothing but a Potemkin village. This is something that has been intuitively obvious and plain to see for my enter life.

I guess one positive outcome of the election year already is that the fraudulence of the Iowa caucuses has been undeniably exposed.

Friday, February 7, 2020

The DNC in Free Fall

You can tell from the reporting in The New York Times that an organized "Block Bernie" effort does indeed exist. Why list total state delegate equivalents (S.D.E.s) and percentage of S.D.E.s as the sole metric of victory? Why? Because that is the only measure by which Pete Buttigieg can be declared the victor. Sanders leads in the popular vote by a significant margin, and the two are tied in the number of delegates each will send to the national convention

As Bernie explained in yesterday's press conference, S.D.E.s are elected participants to a state convention that will vote on rules and officers to govern the Iowa Democratic Party (IDP). They have nothing to do with the Democratic National Convention.

So to frame the election in Iowa as a quest for S.D.E.s, as the "newspaper of record" has done day after day, is bogus.


Besides the Sanders press conference, the big campaign news yesterday was that corrupt DNC chairman Tom Perez announced on Twitter that enough was enough -- the IDP should recanvass the state. Perez walked this back later in the day, saying that only problem precincts should be recanvassed, presumably the satellite caucus sites won overwhelming by Bernie.

There is a debate tonight on ABC. There is little doubt that Buttigieg has received a bounce in New Hampshire. If former Mayor Pete can parlay his fictitious first-place finish in a melted down Iowa to a close second or, improbably, a win in New Hampshire, then the corporate media buzz saw will cut the Democratic Primary field down to a Sanders-Buttigieg contest, pending the arrival of Bloomberg on Super Tuesday.

One potential scenario is that Buttigieg and Bloomberg will join forces. Even assuming that Buttigieg can vacuum up most of the supporters of Biden and Warren -- a big assumption -- he has very little campaign structure outside the first few primary contests. Former Mayor Pete will need to somehow tag-team with Daddy Warbucks Bloomberg if he hopes to remain in the race. FiveThirtyEight has Buttigieg's chances of victory at no more than 1 in 20.

Meanwhile the party is fracturing as expected. As NYT reports,
It’s not just Sanders supporters who are uneasy with Mr. Perez. 
James Carville, who has said the chairman should resign, pointed to another controversy this week that has been overshadowed by the Iowa chaos: the ouster of the top aides who had been planning the party’s nominating convention in Milwaukee. He cited it as another sign of the party’s disarray.
“We can’t count votes, put on a convention or deliver a winning message,” said Mr. Carville, the longtime Clinton strategist.
If James Carville is calling for DNC heads on pikes, you know we're approaching free fall.

Thursday, February 6, 2020

Joe Biden for President, R.I.P.

Almost overnight Joe Biden has gone from being the favorite to win the Democratic Party nomination in Nate Silver's political forecast to a candidate with merely a one-in-six chance; Nate Silver considers a brokered convention more likely. Amazingly, the faux-hipster Disney-owned FiveThirtyEight now declares Bernie Sanders the odds-on favorite with a 50-50 shot at winning the primaries. (The New York Times gets into the act, joining Silver in trumpeting the political death of Joe Biden.)

Biden's weakness was obvious from the get-go. But national polls almost unanimously showed, and probably still do, Biden as the front-runner. Maybe he can turn it around with a strong showing in New Hampshire. But at this point anything worse than a close second will likely mean the end of his candidacy.

With 97% of the precincts reported in Iowa, the results show a dead heat between Sanders and Buttigieg. My guess is that Granite State voters aren't going to look kindly on the pipsqueak former mayor repeatedly claiming victory for himself. Caitlin Johnstone argues this morning that the slow release of the Iowa results is a DNC, not state party, initiative to favor Mayor Pete over Bernie. It's hard to conclude otherwise. Since the Monday meltdown Buttigieg has been shown day after day as the front-runner. That's a lot of free media.

Wednesday, February 5, 2020

After Iowa the Dynamic of the Democratic Primary Remains Unchanged

Thomas Edsall's column this morning, "If Bernie Wins, Where Will He Take the Democratic Party?," is for the most part a compendium of conventional wisdom regarding the likely disastrous outcome for the Democrats in a Sanders vs. Trump general election. David Frum expressed the same sentiment the other day in a debate on Democracy Now! against Jacobin's Bhaskar Sunkara.

The idea is that Bernie is far too left of the electorate; that he would drag down the senate and house. I think that's true in 1992 America but not true today. The other thing to keep in mind, something that both Frum and Edsall refuse to explore, is that every potential Democratic contender for the presidency is going to face significant challenges beating Trump. Why split the party by blocking Bernie's nomination a second time in a row?

The answer from the DNC perspective is that a split party is better than a party controlled by Sanders.

The muddled outcome in Iowa -- Buttigieg and Sanders neck and neck with approximately 30% of the precincts left to count -- doesn't change anything in the primary race. I still think Bernie is the candidate to beat. Biden and Warren are in trouble. Buttigieg will be a flash in the pan. And the DNC is going to bank on Mike Bloomberg to save the day.

Tuesday, February 4, 2020

The Democratic National Committee Needs a Thorough Purging

Yesterday, contemplating the ham-handed attempts by DNC leadership to rig the Democratic Primary for the second presidential election in a row, I came to the realization that an occupation of party headquarters is going to be necessary before all is said and done.

Blame for last night's Iowa caucus meltdown appears to lie with the Democratic National Committee forcing the state party to report results via a smartphone app. According to The New York Times,
Cybersecurity experts also said that the app had not been properly tested at scale, and that it was hastily put together over the past two months. Iowa Democratic Party officials only decided to use the app to report results after a previous party proposal — which entailed having caucus participants call in their votes over the phone — was scrapped, on the advice of Democratic National Committee officials.
Sydney Ember and Reid Epstein explain that many if not most of the precinct captains decided not to use the mobile app and those who did had difficulty. When people tried to call in their results to headquarters they couldn't get through.

Max Blumenthal is reporting that
The delay in reporting is the result of a failed app developed by a company appropriately named Shadow Inc.
This firm was staffed by Hillary Clinton and Barack Obama campaign veterans and created by a Democratic dark money nonprofit backed by hedge fund billionaires including Seth Klarman. A prolific funder of pro-settler Israel lobby organizations, Klarman has also contributed directly to Pete Buttigieg’s campaign.
The delay in the vote reporting denied a victory speech to Sen. Bernie Sanders, the presumptive winner of the opening contest in the Democratic presidential primary. Though not one exit poll indicated that Buttigieg would have won, the South Bend, Indiana mayor took to Twitter to confidently proclaim himself the victor.
This is banana republic stuff. Yves Smith's post this morning is scathing:
On one level, this is an illustration of America’s descent into banana republic status. Pundits and the media keep reinforcing American exceptionalist fantasies, our brand fumes of vaunted democracy, yet we can’t even run elections competently. Is is just the grifting, that introducing more tech creates more opportunities for vendor enrichment? Or is it yet more proof that a lot of people in charge really hate democracy and are at best indifferent to doing things right?
It’s not hard to see the Iowa fiasco as an illustration of an even more deeply-seated pathology: elite incompetence. Too many people with the right resumes get to fail upwards or at worst sideways. And remember, unlike our older WASP-y leaders who were a combination of people from the right clubs and self-made men, our current crop of people in charge pride themselves on being the end products of a meritocratic system, as in their claim to legitimacy stems from the claim that they are more talented (gah) than mere mortals and therefore obviously should be in the top slots because they’ll do oh so much better than everyone else.
Buttigieg appears to be the beneficiary of the two recent snafus: 1) the decision not to publish the Des Moines Register poll showing Sanders ahead, and 2) the caucus night reporting meltdown. Fortunately Buttigieg is going nowhere in the polls. He's fading in New Hampshire. He is polling below Tom Steyer in Nevada. He's dust. Kaput. He won't even get a free-media bounce if he is declared winner later in the day because tonight is Trump's state of the union address. Tomorrow is Trump's impeachment acquittal. Already the caucus meltdown is providing Trump a platform to remind voters about Obama's cataclysmic HealthCare.gov roll-out.

But back to my original point. This is what democracy looks like to the DNC. The DNC needs to be cleaned out thoroughly and ruthlessly.

Monday, February 3, 2020

Force-Feeding Democrats Mike Bloomberg

On the day of the first vote for president, Patrick Martin of World Socialist Web Site has an excellent overview (see "Corporate media and Democratic establishment target Sanders") of the mounting panic within the wealthy donor class that controls the Democratic Party:
There was even a report by NBC News that former Secretary of State John Kerry, the defeated Democratic presidential candidate in 2004 against George W. Bush, was overheard Sunday on the phone at a Des Moines hotel discussing entering the presidential race himself because of “the possibility of Bernie Sanders taking down the Democratic Party—down whole.”
Kerry reportedly expressed regret that he would have to resign from the board of Bank of America and give up lucrative paid speeches, but could expect wealthy donors to provide backing because they “now have the reality of Bernie.”
What really alarms the Democratic Party establishment and the corporate media is not the prospect that Sanders might lead the party to defeat, but that his capture of the nomination, would contribute—despite the Vermont senator’s own efforts—to a radicalization of American working people and youth that Sanders would not be able to contain.
[snip] 
Despite Sanders’ claims, however, the Democratic establishment is in no way reconciled to the prospect of a Sanders nomination. The rule change on eligibility for future debates announced Friday by the DNC drops the requirement that candidates have a minimum number of contributors, an action that would allow billionaire Michael Bloomberg, who has only one contributor, himself, to qualify. Sanders’ campaign adviser Jeff Weaver denounced the move, saying, “Now, at this late hour, to change the rules to accommodate a billionaire who wants to buy his way into the party would be unconscionable.”
There was a report in Politico that members of the DNC have begun privately discussing a change in the convention rules to allow so-called super-delegates—elected officials and members of the DNC—to vote on the first ballot of the presidential nomination. Under current rules, they have no vote on the first ballot, which is reserved to delegates chosen in primaries and caucuses, and can vote only if no candidate has an initial majority and the contest goes to a second ballot. Such a change would be transparently aimed at blocking a first-ballot win by Sanders.
If the DNC is willing to change its small-donor rule at the eleventh hour in order to accommodate billionaire media mogul Bloomberg, then there's no question that we can expect more foul play to come. If it is true that the convention super-delegate rule is going to be tossed, then it will basically confirm that 2016 was rigged.

How do the party kingpins expect voters to support such a corrupt organization? Their answer is likely that the voters should do what they are told. And what they are going to be told is that they must vote for billionaire Bloomberg.

Plutocrats would prefer the general election be a contest between two New York City billionaire business moguls than one that would feature a democratic socialist as a contender.

We'll see what happens. But I doubt that the plutocrats will be able to force-feed their preferred scenario to the voting public. There is not enough grassroots support for a Bloomberg force-feed. If Biden were somehow able to muddle through with a narrow victory, the party would be divided, yes, but I believe it could come together in November. Bloomberg? No.

Sunday, February 2, 2020

Super Bowl LIV

Interestingly the betting line out of Las Vegas is Chiefs by a point and a half. I think San Francisco is the better team. Benjamin Hoffman predicts a 49ers win in a nail-biter. In a sampling of player interviews on the NFL Network the predominate belief appears to be that Patrick Mahomes is going to find a way to win. That's the way I choose to see it too.

Given that most think this game will come down to how the Kansas City offense plays against the vaunted San Francisco defense, a fruitful way to approach this game might be to say that it will really come down to how the Chiefs defense stacks up against the 49ers offense.

There's really no telling. If the Chiefs can't stop the run I think they're in trouble. Kansas City was able to shut down Derrick Henry. So that bodes well if you are a Chiefs fan. Is Jimmy Garappolo that much better than Ryan Tannehill? I don't think so. Take the Chiefs. Let's hope it is a high-scoring, close game.

With the Super Bowl, the holiday season comes to an end. Some would argue it's Presidents' Day. I think Presidents' Day is like a water stop in the first mile of a marathon, the marathon being the February-to-end-of-May long march to Memorial Day.

The Iowa caucus is tomorrow. In February and March the Democratic Primary will likely be decided; unless the DNC opts for some heavy hocus pocus, finding a way to transfer the allegiance of Biden voters, as well as the supporters of all the also-rans, to Mike Bloomberg. Shane Goldmacher's story from the other day says it all. Biden's campaign is on life support. If he finishes out of the top two in Iowa I think he's in real trouble.

Bloomberg has already spent a surreal $275 million in advertising. How Bloomberg does in the Democratic Primary will be a sobering assessment of the health of U.S. democratic system. Can a billionaire buy a major-party nomination with enormous ad buys as if he were selling Doritos?