Sunday, April 21, 2019

The Mueller Report: When Things Fall Apart

The problem presented by the release of the redacted Mueller report for the massive disinformation campaign which is Russiagate, a.k.a., "Putin Stole my Election!" -- well, there are several problems -- is that Mueller clearly places the burden on Congress to act: No proof of criminal conspiracy between the Trump campaign and the Russian government (see Glenn Greenwald's "Robert Mueller Did Not Merely Reject the Trump-Russia Conspiracy Theories. He Obliterated Them.," as well as his debate with David Cay Johnston). Obstruction of justice charges, if they are to be pursued, should be taken up by a co-equal branch of government.

But the Democratic-controlled House of Representatives will not begin impeachment proceedings because then there would have to be hearings, testimony given, witnesses cross-examined. All the fluff and gossip contained in the Steele dossier would go up in smoke.

So what are the Democrats to do? Their precious status as victims of Putin's evil machinations is fast disappearing.

The New York Times is busy re-conjuring the genie from his bottle. Yesterday's unsigned editorial -- "The Mueller Report and the Danger Facing American Democracy: A perceived victory for Russian interference poses a serious risk for the United States." -- restates that case against Russia:
The report of the special counsel Robert Mueller leaves considerable space for partisan warfare over the role of President Trump and his political campaign in Russia’s interference in the 2016 election. But one conclusion is categorical: “The Russian government interfered in the 2016 presidential election in sweeping and systematic fashion.”
What are we really talking about here? The Times itself acknowledges that "there is no way to gauge with any certainty how much impact the Russian activities actually had on voters."

We appear to be talking about a modest effort by the reputedly Kremlin controlled Internet Research Agency (IRA) to influence voters. We are supposed to believe that digital ads "purchased in rubles using 470 fake accounts and pages" could have had any impact at all in an election campaign where $6.5 billion was spent.

(My reply to cries of "Putin is dividing us!" is "That's the whole point of the two-party system," which usually generates a stunned silence.)

We are also talking about the DNC hack and Podesta hack, both of which, absent proof, are ascribed to Russian military intelligence. That's just baldly accepted; to question it, to request the evidence for the assertion, is to invite ridicule.

The reality is that all nations fiddle about with influence campaigns on the internet. For instance, close U.S. ally Saudi Arabia was caught red-handed running a botnet in the wake of Jamal Khashoggi's disappearance; Israel has waged cyber-warfare against the BDS movement; and let's not forget the fake Russian botnet created by Jonathon Morgan, a Russiagate conspiracy theorist and author of a Senate Intelligence Committee report on Russia's use of social media during the 2016 election.

The Times editorial seems to acknowledge this by saying that it is the influence campaigns of "hostile" nations that are a threat to U.S. democracy:
A perceived victory for Russian interference poses a serious danger to the United States. Already, several American agencies are working, in partnership with the tech industry, to prevent election interference going forward. But the Kremlin is not the only hostile government mucking around in America’s cyberspace — China and North Korea are two others honing their cyber-arsenals, and they, too, could be tempted to manipulate partisan strife for their ends.
I'm surprised Iran wasn't mentioned, or Venezuela.

And that is what we're really talking about here: The establishment of a censorship regime for the new media environment.

In 2016 things got out of hand because voters no longer get their information from a trusted daily newspaper or the nightly television news. They get their information from the internet. The internet is too wild and woolly an environment to keep a nation of hundreds of millions pacified. Thus, the internet must be regulated.

And that's been happening under the cover of the Russian bogeyman. The tech companies are being brought to heel, to hunt and fetch for the master.

The problem is that the elite political consensus being protected is indefensible. People are miserable. The planet is undergoing a massive die-off. And all the rich want to do is get richer.

In the end, this counterintelligence campaign, this Russiagate, which is really a massive domestic pacification program like COINTELPRO, is going to have to resort to violence, and that's when things fall apart.

Wednesday, April 17, 2019

Democratic Panic

From "‘Stop Sanders’ Democrats Are Agonizing Over His Momentum" by Jonathan Martin:
WASHINGTON — When Leah Daughtry, a former Democratic Party official, addressed a closed-door gathering of about 100 wealthy liberal donors in San Francisco last month, all it took was a review of the 2020 primary rules to throw a scare in them.
Democrats are likely to go into their convention next summer without having settled on a presidential nominee, said Ms. Daughtry, who ran her party’s conventions in 2008 and 2016, the last two times the nomination was contested. And Senator Bernie Sanders of Vermont is well positioned to be one of the last candidates standing, she noted.
“I think I freaked them out,” Ms. Daughtry recalled with a chuckle, an assessment that was confirmed by three other attendees. They are hardly alone.
From canapé-filled fund-raisers on the coasts to the cloakrooms of Washington, mainstream Democrats are increasingly worried that their effort to defeat President Trump in 2020 could be complicated by Mr. Sanders, in a political scenario all too reminiscent of how Mr. Trump himself seized the Republican nomination in 2016.
It’s truly remarkable. Elite Democratic donors and apparatchiks are shitting in their pants over the possibility of Bernie’s nomination.

It appears they are taking a brokered convention for granted because of the massive frontloading of the primary season. Then, after the first ballot, the superdelegates can vote. So it looks to be a mess in the making.

But not nearly as much of a mess if Bernie wins the primary in a rout. Then I think it’s a pretty safe bet some of these billionaire Dem donors will back a third-party run by Bloomberg or someone else.

Whatever the cost they will block a socialist from winning the presidency.

Trump Vetoes Yemen War Powers Resolution; Sledgehammers his Base

Take a look at the reader comments accompanying the Breitbart story on Trump's veto of the War Powers Resolution ending U.S. involvement in the Yemen civil war. They are almost 100% opposed to the veto.

Much is made about Trump's canniness in keeping his base tightly bound to him. And it's true. Trump has been good at shoveling red meat to his supporters. But working class white reactionaries do not approve of the Saudi royal family; they loathe them.

Attacking little Ilhan Omar comes off as all the more unseemly and perverse when Trump time and again is pictured in flagrante licking Saudi boots.

Trump's veto takes a sledgehammer to his conservative base. As Mark Landler and Peter Baker remind us in "Trump Vetoes Measure to Force End to U.S. Involvement in Yemen War," the Yemen War Powers resolution was co-sponsored by arch-Trump Republicans:
“This is deeply disappointing,” said Representative Ro Khanna, Democrat of California, who was one of the original sponsors of the measure in the House and had sought a meeting with Mr. Trump to try to persuade him to sign it.
“The president had the opportunity to sign a historic War Powers Resolution and stand with a bipartisan coalition, including his allies Rand Paul, Mark Meadows and Matt Gaetz, to stop endless wars,” Mr. Khanna said. “He failed to uphold the principles of the Constitution that give Congress power over matters of war and peace.”
Mr. Khanna was referring to the Republican senator from Kentucky, Mr. Paul, and two Republican representatives, from North Carolina and Florida, Mr. Meadows and Mr. Gaetz, who are closely aligned with Mr. Trump, but split with fellow Republicans to vote with Democrats in favor of the resolution. Members of the group had asked to meet with Mr. Trump to make their case against a veto, but the White House brushed them off.
Trump is gambling that Yemen disappears as a campaign issue a year from now. His veto guarantees that it won't, particularly if the Sanders runaway train continues to gain speed.

Tuesday, April 16, 2019

The American Independent Party is Still Around After Half a Century

There was this interesting blurb from yesterday's Water Cooler by Lambert Strether:
CA: “California Voters Keep Accidentally Joining George Wallace’s Zombie Political Party” [New York Magazine]. “An April 2016 Los Angeles Times report showing that a vast number of indies who should have been registering as ‘No Party Preference’ voters were instead signing up for the [American Independent Party, a hold-over from the Wallace campaign in 1968]…. it certainly did not help the Sanders campaign, which was counting on indie votes…. If there’s a 20-candidate presidential field and Sanders or somebody else is counting on indies to get them across the line in California, they’d better start getting the word on about the AIP pretty soon.”
Who would have imagined that the American Independent Party exists more than 50 years after the 1968 presidential election. It seems to be limited to California; headquartered in Vacaville.

Last night, thinking about the 2020 presidential campaign, I wondered, If Wallace had somehow managed to get elected in 1968, could he have won a second term in 1972?

Because in many ways Trump's presidency is as if George Wallace had been elected, the main difference being that, as Michael Moore does a good job reminding us in his film Fahrenheit 11/9, Trump won in 2016 by running to Hillary's left on a host of issues, particularly war and peace. George Wallace, with General Curtis LeMay on his ticket in '68, ran as an unrepentant war-pig.

But all of Trump's left-progressive packaging has been ripped off after two-plus years in the White House.

As I drifted off to sleep I thought the only chance that Trump has is if the Democratic Party comes to the rescue. This is not out of the realm of possibility. If Sanders win's the primary, Democratic Party leaders might see their best hope of survival the sabotage of his candidacy.

Monday, April 15, 2019

The Conflict at the Core of Mainstream Assange Coverage

The jubilation found last week in the mainstream media upon Julian Assange's arrest has given way to a more ominous assessment. A good example is Michelle Goldberg's opinion piece "Is Assange’s Arrest a Threat to the Free Press?" While Goldberg relishes the jailing of a principal Russiagate conspirator, most of her column is spent arguing that the U.S. indictment of the Assange is very bad news for press freedom:
“It was part of the conspiracy that Assange and Manning took measures to conceal Manning as the source of the disclosure of classified records to WikiLeaks,” says the indictment. Most if not all investigative journalists take such measures to protect their sources. The indictment says, “It was part of the conspiracy that Assange encouraged Manning to provide information and records from departments and agencies of the United States.” Journalists often do this when they urge whistle-blowers to come forward. “It was part of the conspiracy that Assange and Manning used a special folder on a cloud drop box of WikiLeaks” to transmit classified information, the indictment continues. Like many news organizations, The New York Times does something similar, soliciting tips through an encrypted submission system called SecureDrop.
There is a conflict at the core of how the mainstream media is covering Assange's arrest. On the one hand, there is a recognition that the U.S. indictment of the WikiLeaks co-founder paves the way for arrests of reporters who work for legacy media outlets; on the other, Assange continues to be demonized, a good example of which is "As Ecuador Harbored Assange, It Was Subjected to Threats and Leaks," by Nicholas Casey and Jo Becker. The reader is supposed to feel pity for poor Lenin Moreno who had photos leaked of his eating lobster in bed. All I came away feeling was that it was likely the CIA or an allied intelligence service hacked Moreno so that WikiLeaks would take the blame and Assange would be ousted from his refuge in the Ecuadorean embassy.

It will be interesting to see how this conflict plays out. The mainstream media exists primarily to paint villains for the government; but in the case of Assange, to continue to do so will further destabilize an already shaky newspaper industry.

Friday, April 12, 2019

Nicholas Kristof should be in Prison, Not Julian Assange

For a good example of the absolutely decrepit state of mainstream opinion writing read Nicholas Kristof's embarrassing "Hungry and Desperate, but Away From a Country in Chaos."

The template remains unchanged: A nation's people are being brutalized by its leadership. So the enlightened, benign United States must intervene in that country to replace its leaders with ones of its own choosing.

What always goes unmentioned is that a majority of the citizens of the targeted country doesn't want its leaders evicted by the United States. What also goes unmentioned is that the leaders selected by the U.S. favor privatizing their country's assets.

As Kristof proudly proclaimed in the aftermath of Muammar Gaddafi's ouster in 2011:
I’m a believer in humanitarian intervention to avert genocide or mass atrocities — when the stars align, as I believe they did in Libya — so maybe I’m deluding myself to justify our bombing campaign. Yet it seems to me that the NATO military intervention prevented a massacre in Benghazi, saved countless Libyan lives and has put the country on a track of hope.
Countries like the United States, France, Britain and Qatar did something historic in supporting a military operation that was largely about preserving lives, not national interests. While plenty can still go wrong, my sense is that Libya is muddling along toward a future far better than its oppressive past.
In the years that followed, when Libya descended into civil war and chaos, Kristof changed his tune and became critical of the "humanitarian intervention," not only there but in Syria as well.

The important thing to note here is that Kristof's change of tune on Libya and Syria never translates into an aversion to making another call for a new regimen change operation.

This is also the case with Kristof's fellow columnist Thomas Friedman, who supported the invasion of Iraq, only to acknowledge later that he was wrong, but then ended up arguing for the removal of Assad in Syria.

People like Kristof and Friedman are not really independent thinkers. They are Borgs. They will always advocate for whatever war is being boosted at the moment, to fall back later, in order to maintain any credibility at all, and criticize the intervention, as Kristof does persuasively now with the war in Yemen.

Thursday, April 11, 2019

New York Times Attempts to Link Assange to Russiagate

What's odd about the main dispatch on Julian Assange's arrest published by The New York Times  (see "Julian Assange Arrested on U.S. Extradition Warrant, London Police Say" by Richard Pérez-Peña) is that the center of the story is all about Russiagate, capped by this paragraph:
“The big questions that it seems like he should be able to answer are about the relationships between WikiLeaks and the Russian government and between Roger Stone and the Trump campaign,” said Scott R. Anderson, a fellow at the Brookings Institution and an editor of the online publication Lawfare, who has tracked the investigation. “There are certainly a lot of factual gaps that it seems like Assange could help fill.”
Then you have to read 14 more paragraphs until arriving at the final two paragraphs:
During the 2016 campaign, WikiLeaks released thousands of emailsstolen from the computer systems of the Democratic National Committee, leading to a series of revelations that embarrassed the party and Hillary Clinton’s campaign. United States investigators have said that the systems were hacked by Russian agents.
Mr. Assange made no secret of his intent to damage Mrs. Clinton, but he has insisted that he did not get the emails from Russia.
The whole "Stone worked with Assange, and therefore the Russians, to sabotage the Clinton campaign" line is a complete canard. Mueller could have interviewed Assange and elected not to. What does that tell you?

It tells you that the excessive focus on Russiagate and the allegations of Ecuadorian president Lenin Moreno are meant to disparage the character of Assange and bias readers against him.

There is no mention of the UN's finding that Assange was being arbitrarily detained and that the UK must allow him to leave the Ecuadorian embassy freely.

There is no mention of the absurd Luke Harding story published by The Guardian alleging a meeting between Assange and Paul Manafort at the Ecuadorian embassy.

There is precious little mention -- a couple paragraphs -- of the trove of U.S. Government filth Assange published in 2010.