Showing posts with label 2019 Afghan Presidential Election. Show all posts
Showing posts with label 2019 Afghan Presidential Election. Show all posts

Thursday, May 2, 2019

The Jig is Up for the Ghani Government in Afghanistan

There was once a time when the puppet government in Afghanistan convened a loya jirga it was front-page news. No longer. You have to wade seven-paragraphs deep into David Zucchino's "Taliban and U.S. Start New Round of Talks in Qatar" to learn that
Mr. Ghani on Monday convened a traditional grand council assembly, known as a loya jirga, to discuss peace for Afghanistan. About 3,000 delegates from around the country, selected in a process dominated by Mr. Ghani’s supporters, are meeting this week to reach a consensus on peace and a postwar Afghanistan. Their decisions are not legally binding.
Zucchino reported on a bombshell the day prior (see "U.S. Military Stops Counting How Much of Afghanistan Is Controlled by Taliban"). The U.S. military will no longer report how much territory it controls in the country. These assessments, sanguine to begin with, were really the only way for the casual observer to gauge how the war was going. Forums like The Long War Journal would use the same data and come up with a different picture, one more favorable to the Taliban.

The best statement concerning this turn events is provided by John Sopko:
The decision to end the assessments, which have been produced in various forms since at least 2010, was published in the latest quarterly report by the American special inspector general for Afghanistan reconstruction.
“We’re troubled by it,” the inspector general, John F. Sopko, said in an interview. “It’s like turning off the scoreboard at a football game and saying scoring a touchdown or field goal isn’t important.”
I'd say that when the scoreboard goes dark the game is over.

Combine this with Zalmay Khalilzad statement that "he hopes to reach a final peace agreement before the elections" in September and it's a pretty safe bet that the jig is up for the Ghani government in Kabul.

Tuesday, April 9, 2019

Peace Agreement with Taliban Needs to be Concluded by End of Summer

With the blessing of proconsul Zalmay Khalilzad, Afghan president Ashraf Ghani has created a "big tent" council to oversee negotiations with the Taliban. As Mujib Mashal and Fahim Abed point out in "Afghans Name Council to Ease Logjam on Talks With Taliban" heretofore the Taliban have refused to speak with official from Ghani's government:
The Taliban have refused to meet directly with representatives of the Afghan government, calling it a puppet of the United States. The Afghan government has insisted on nothing less than direct negotiations, criticizing any move by political groups to engage with the Taliban as giving the insurgents unwarranted legitimacy.
[snip] 
Mohammed Umer Daudzai, a member of the council, said an informal meeting with the Taliban in Qatar, seen as an icebreaker, would go ahead. That meeting, set for mid-April and expected to be attended by more than a hundred Afghans from various parts of society, is intended as a trust-building measure.
“It was decided in today’s meeting that we will participate in the meeting in Qatar as a joint delegation,” Mr. Daudzai said. “A big delegation will go to Qatar to exchange views with the other side, which are the Taliban, but they will not negotiate. Negotiation is the next step.”
Easing Mr. Ghani’s concerns is the fact that since he leads the council overseeing the talks, his officials will be on the negotiating team when direct talks with the Taliban do begin. Government representatives are also likely to attend the large Qatar meeting.
The Taliban will get around their prohibition of negotiating with the puppet government by saying that they are dealing not with official representatives but people acting in an individual capacity.

The criticism of this "icebreaker" in Qatar is that it is merely a repeat of the February meeting in Moscow between "Afghan political elites" and the Taliban that was repudiated by Ghani. The only difference now is that Ghani is a major participant in the charade.

It is hard to see how Ghani survives. The presidential election has already been delayed twice this year; it is now set for September 28.

I am of the opinion that whatever ruse is hatched between the Taliban and the U.S. to hand over power it has to be completed before the end of summer because there is a very limited capacity to stage a viable presidential election.