Showing posts with label 2017 British Parliamentary Elections. Show all posts
Showing posts with label 2017 British Parliamentary Elections. Show all posts

Sunday, June 11, 2017

Can Macron's En Marche! Change the Channel from Corbyn's Labour

There has been some mainstream media confusion about messaging in the wake of Labour's surprisingly virile showing on Thursday. The "Corbyn Confounds Critics" highlight is rapidly being rubbed out in favor of "The Tories Fucked It All Up Again."

A few other talking points are emerging: 1) "May Still Won," the flip-side of which is "Corbyn Can't Govern"; 2) Labour's pick-up of 29 seats is being interpreted as a win for "Soft Brexit" over "Hard Brexit," to the exclusion of what it really was -- a crystal clear signal that voters want a return to social democracy -- more money for the National Health Service, free university tuition, higher taxes on corporations and the rich, and a less bellicose foreign policy.

Of course this kind of social democracy is exactly what the neoliberal center exits to deny, and that is why Labour's performance is going to be downplayed and derided. The messaging might not be as consistent as, say, "We Must Bomb Syria." But don't doubt that a consistent, relentless anti-Corbyn/anti-Labour set of talking points effectively dismissing Thursday's results as a one-off, a fart in a gale, is forthcoming.

Another talking point that bubbled up immediately after Thursday was the refulgent expression of a recent Francophilia in the U.S. prestige press. Brett Stephens' absurd Saturday column, "The Year of Voting Recklessly," is a good example:
The news isn’t all bad. Corbyn still fell 64 seats short of a parliamentary majority. Trump’s approval ratings are at 39 percent. Regrets? The Brexiters have a few. And Emmanuel Macron may yet provide evidence that, at least in France, there is gravity, energy, excitement and even sexiness at the political center. 
The West hasn’t walked over the ledge, yet. We’re only dancing at the cliff’s edge.
It appears that the neoliberals are placing all their eggs in the recently woven En Marche! basket. I don't think it's going to end well for them. French polls close in a couple of hours, and, as Alissa Rubin reports, turnout is already running far below recent legislative elections:
On Sunday, the French began voting in the first of two rounds for representatives to the National Assembly, the powerful lower house of the French Parliament and, in essence, decide whether to back the man, his cabinet and his plan.
The participation rate at 5 p.m. local time, nearly 41 percent, was considerably lower than the turnout at the same time in the first round in 2012, when it was 48.3 percent, according to the Interior Ministry. It was even higher in 2007: 49.3 percent.
Who does this benefit? The media has been heralding an-all-but-certain majority for the neophyte En Marche! Macron has selected novices to run. If victorious, they will be tasked with implementing cuts to pensions and worker rights -- the austerity agenda.

I have some experience with idealistic newcomers to politics. That's who the Green Party attracted back in the Nader days. Most didn't last very long because they had no stomach for conflict. That's what politics primarily is -- both internally and externally -- managing conflict. And the basic way that conflict is managed is through reciprocity, a.k.a., the grubby art of quid pro quo. Idealistic newcomers are usually shocked that this is what politics boils down to.

My sense is that is why the Five Star Movement didn't parlay its excellent showing in 2013 Italian general election into a broader, more effective base of power. M5S ran novices.

So regardless of whether the polls are correct and En Marche! sweeps the first round, assuring a strong majority in the National Assembly, legislating more draconian neoliberal austerity is going to be easier said than done.

Thursday, June 8, 2017

Labour Appears to be on a Roll

Labour is picking up seats in Wales and Scotland. Gerry Adams is batting down questions as to whether Sinn Féin will take its seats in Westminster. Boris Johnson is sharpening his shiv for Theresa May. Jeremy Corbyn appears set to exorcise the ghost of Tony Blair. 

Can the D.C. Democrats be next? They should be. The Clintons should have been exorcised after the Trumpocalypse. Team Obama is going to have to go, which is going to be a hard push. Organizing for Action is doing far more organizing now than it ever did while Obama was in office.

Let's take a moment to doff our caps to the British voter -- for pushing Parliament to block Cameron from bombing Damascus back in the summer of 2013, which made it next to impossible for Obama to bomb Syria; for Brexit; and now for supporting a true social democrat in Jeremy Corbyn.

The French shit the bed, but the Brits are poised to renew hope in electoral democracy.

British Vote Today Not Looking Good for Labour

UPDATE IV: From the The Guardian's "election results live":

Labour says 'Tories are being punished for taking British people for granted'

****

UPDATE III: The first announced exit poll has the Tories falling short of a majority. "The survey predicts the Conservatives will get 314 seats and the Labour Party 266." This is a far cry from the 345-375 spread predicted by a majority of the final polls. If the exit poll is accurate, there will be plenty of upheaval -- anarchy? -- in the UK.

****

UPDATE II: With exit polls soon to arrive, I just finished reading yesterday's FiveThirtyEight post, "The Three Scenarios For The U.K. Election," Both Nate Silver and Harry Enten still appear to be snake-bitten by the Trumpocalypse of last November; hence, the excessive hedging they indulge in prior to revealing their three scenarios: 1) modest Tory triumph, 2) Tory landslide; 3) Tories lose their majority:
We don’t have a model of this election — but in our view, there’s no way around the fact that uncertainty is high and that nobody should be surprised about the outcome unless perhaps Labour wins an outright majority of seats. U.K. polls have not historically been very accurate. And pundit attempts to outguess the polls have often been even worse. (In 2016, pundits and betting markets were notoriously confident that Britain would vote to remain within the European Union even when polls showed a nearly even race.) However, if one takes the polling average but assumes that the error is as high as it has been historically, then it turns out that each of these three outcomes are roughly as likely as one another. 
**** 

UPDATE: If the Tories gain 45 seats, a forecast that Yves Smith featured in her post, this would be considered an enormous victory for Theresa May. According to a helpful scorecard provided by The Independent, any gain of 34 seats or more for the Tories will be considered a landslide, a triumph for May and "[T]he 'terrible campaign' story will be rewritten as a brilliant reading of the essence of the British people."

**** 

Naked Capitalism's Yves Smith has a strong track record of pessimism when it comes to the left's ability to transform the neoliberal center. She is at it again with "Final UK Election Polls: YouGov Still the Outlier, Predicts Tories Get Only 302 Seats." Smith, with slight a hedge in the form of an acknowledgement that polls were wrong about Brexit, seems to favor the point of view that the Tories are looking to pick up something like 45 seats, which would give them a 100-seat majority over all other parties in Parliament. This scenario imagines Tories racking up wins in the midlands, the north, even Scotland.

I understand that Labour's vote is concentrated in metropolitan areas and is heavily dependent on fickle youth turning up at the polls, but the idea that the Scottish National Party could lose as many as 12 seats because of its pro-independence stance seems far-fetched to me.

The fact remains that Yves Smith's pessimism is mostly on the mark. The neoliberal center, entrenched in the West for decades, is remarkably resilient. Look at how it was able to stymie the Obama 2008 landslide or how it was able to Jiffy Pop a new electoral majority seemingly overnight with Emmanuel Macron's En Marche!

Sadly, neoliberalism will likely have to collapse internally -- we're seeing that now with Trump -- before it is deconstructed by social-democratic majorities at the polls. The problem with internal collapse -- remember Thucydides! -- is that it is bloody, horrific, painful, basically the worst.

Wednesday, June 7, 2017

ISIS and Saudi Arabia: "They are One and the Same"

The truth of Saudi support for jihadist terror is front and center in the British parliamentary election campaign. George Monbiot had a superb piece in The Guardian yesterday:
[May] is even more sycophantic towards this revolting man [Trump] than Tony Blair was to George W Bush. She won’t confront Saudi Arabia over terrorism or Yemen or anything else. Far from it: both as home secretary and as prime minister she appears to have suppressed a report into the foreign funding of jihadi groups in the UK that is said to focus on the role of the Saudi kingdom. When there is a conflict between our security and selling weapons to a despotic regime, brutality wins.
The hyperlink is to another Guardian story, "Theresa May urged not to suppress report into funding of jihadi groups," which says that
Jeremy Corbyn and Tim Farron have challenged Theresa May over a long-delayed inquiry into foreign funding and support of jihadi groups in the UK, after the Home Office suggested the investigation may not be published.
The inquiry into revenue streams for extremist groups was commissioned by David Cameron when he was prime minister and is thought to focus on Saudi Arabia.
[snip]
The Conservatives were criticised last year for selling billions of pounds of arms to the Saudis. 
Cameron ordered the investigation as part of a deal with the Lib Dems in exchange for the party supporting the extension of British airstrikes against Islamic State into Syria in December 2015.
The Home Office’s extremism analysis unit was directed by Downing Street in January 2016 to investigate overseas funding of extremist groups in the UK, with findings to be shown to the then home secretary May and Cameron.
Eighteen months on, the Home Office said the report, originally due to be published in spring 2016, had not yet been completed and publication was not guaranteed, given the sensitive nature of the content.
A decision about the future of the investigation would be taken “after the election by the next government”, a Home Office spokesman said. 
Another reason to vote Labour tomorrow.

The feeling inside Iran is that ISIS terror definitely is Saudi directed. This from Thomas Erdbrink's story, "Islamic State Claims Deadly Iran Attacks on Parliament and Khomeini Tomb":
At least 12 people were killed and 42 others wounded Wednesday morning in a pair of devastating attacks on two of Iran’s most potent symbols: the national Parliament and the mausoleum of the Islamic Republic’s founder, Ayatollah Ruhollah Khomeini.
The Islamic State immediately claimed responsibility; if that is found to be true, the attacks would be the terrorist group’s first major assault within Iran’s borders. Suspicions in Tehran were also directed at Saudi Arabia, Iran’s nemesis in the region, which has been newly emboldened by a supportive visit from President Trump last month.
In the view of many in Iran, the Islamic State, also known as ISIS or ISIL, is inextricably linked to Saudi Arabia. Hamidreza Taraghi, a hard-line analyst with ties to Iran’s supreme leader, Ayatollah Ali Khamenei, said, “ISIS ideologically, financially and logistically is fully supported and sponsored by Saudi Arabia.”
“They are one and the same,” he added.
At this point I think this is a pretty safe bet, and no doubt the reason the Tories are keeping their report hidden.

Given this then we have to accept what follows: Western governments in their fulsome support of the Saudis are complicit, even if only tacitly, in attacks on their own citizens.

The political equation is that terrorizing one's own population keeps the status quo -- the deep national security state, the rancid mainstream political parties, the inequality -- safe and secure.

Trump, thoroughly and unimaginatively corrupt, has "poured gasoline on the fire." As The Independent reported yesterday, "Trump's Washington DC hotel received $270,000 from Saudi Arabia":
Donald Trump’s flagship hotel in the nation’s capital has received more than $270,000 in payments from a lobbying firm tried to Saudi Arabia, as the country seeks to overturn a US anti-terrorism law.
The anti-sharia protesters this Saturday should park themselves on Pennsylvania Avenue.

Monday, June 5, 2017

Islamic State Intervenes in the British Parliamentary Elections

Prime Minister Theresa May has received what amounts to a non-stop, global campaign ad the last 24 hours thanks to terror attacks in London Saturday night that left at least seven dead and nearly 50 taken to local hospitals. Three jihadist attackers were killed by militarized police in a hail of bullets.

The headline repeated constantly Sunday was a variant of this morning's in The New York Times, "After London Attack, Prime Minister Says, ‘Enough Is Enough’." SitRep led its daily bulletin with the synopsis:
London. In the wake of Saturday’s terrorist attacks in London that killed seven people, British Prime Minister Theresa May declared, “enough is enough,” vowing to launch a sweeping review of Britain’s counterterrorism strategy after the third major terrorist attack in the country in three months. The Islamic State claimed responsibility for the attack, saying it had been carried out by “a detachment of Islamic State fighters.” The attack comes after the U.K. had already raised its terrorism alert level following a suicide bombing at a concert in Manchester. The Islamic State has claimed responsibility for the Manchester attack, as well.
Campaigning for Thursday's election was temporarily suspended. So Theresa May largely had the airwaves to herself. (Corbyn did issue a statement.) I saw May's "enough is enough" statement after I turned on the television to see Novak Djokovic's round-of-16 match  at the French Open. I was not impressed. But then again I'm biased.

I think the benefit for May is not necessarily the quality of her statement, which was just boilerplate, but the fact that her name was invoked incessantly to the exclusion of anything else -- the victims, the Islamic State attackers -- other than maybe Ariana Grande and her return-to-Manchester concert.

But this morning there seems to be a counter-narrative developing to "enough is enough," and that is that May as home secretary backed cuts to the police force.

According to the NYT's Steven Erlanger, it is unclear how Saturday's attack will affect the election:
With the general election days away, several polls have shown Mrs. May’s lead over Jeremy Corbyn, the Labour leader, to be narrowing.
Mr. Corbyn issued his own strong condemnation of the attacks. “We are all shocked and horrified by the brutal attacks in London,” he said in a statement. “My thoughts are with the families and friends of those who have died and the many who have been injured. Today, we will all grieve for their loss.”
Using different methods, pollsters are divided about the extent of the Conservative lead, but they all show the gap with Labour shrinking, making the landslide Mrs. May hoped for unlikely and even, for at least one polling company, raising the possibility of a hung Parliament.
It is too early to say how the attack will affect the vote, if at all. In general, crises tend to help the incumbent. However, Mrs. May did not seem to receive much of a polling bounce after the Manchester attack, partly because of some campaign mistakes. And as the former home secretary, she might receive some blame for perceived security failings.
Campaigning had already been suspended once, after the Manchester attack. That happened while Mrs. May was on the defensive, having had to change the position on home care policy announced just days earlier in her party’s manifesto.
One thing cannot be denied. The attack changed the direction of the campaign. All talk had been about the Tory collapse underway. Now the discussion shifts to different terrain, and it is not an easy read. Are voters sophisticated enough to know that May as home secretary and the Tories as the governing party are responsible for the status quo, and the status quo needs to change?

Friday, June 2, 2017

Corbyn Has His Mojo Working

UPDATE: A Politico story, "8 ways Jeremy Corbyn is winning," from this morning enumerates Corbyn's charge up the polls. Point eight is particularly sweet:
8. Standing room only 
While packed rallies are not an indicator of voting intentions, Corbyn has managed to attract people to his campaign events in their thousands, giving him a sense of momentum when the images are beamed into people’s living rooms on the evening news. “I know the rallies are driving them mad at CCHQ [Tory headquarters],” one former Tory campaign strategist said. “They know they can’t match it and it’s a problem for them. The images are really good for Labour.”
**** 


It’s funny to track the huge swing in the Tory tabloid press as Corbyn surges towards next week’s election. At first Corbyn was dismissed as an out-of-touch Mr. Magoo riding his bicycle to nuclear-free extinction as Labour disappeared forever. Now he is the Second Coming of Stalin thumping his red playbook for re-nationalization of British industry while he conspires with the reviled Nicola Sturgeon to carve up poor old John Bull.

Friday, May 12, 2017

The Sisi Trend Again

It was only last Friday that things were looking up for Trump. Now things appear quite differently. The first place to start this morning is Yves Smith's re-post of Gaius Publius' "Trump – A Nation in Crisis, Again":
Yves here. The media’s fixation on the scary Putin monster takes energy away from opposing Trump on real issues: health care, climate, dropping life expectancy, the surveillance state, to name a few. It also validates the effort of the CIA and certain elements of the military to meddle in domestic politics in a shockingly open manner, which is a terrible precedent.
As Lambert wrote, “If we can’t win on the facts, we do not deserve to win.” As Ilargi said yesterday:
It’s not about whether Trump is or has ever been guilty of anything he’s accused of, it’s that the insinuating narratives about that have long been written and repeated ad nauseam. It’s about whether the witch hunt exemplified by PropOrNot makes objective news gathering impossible. And the only possible response to that question must be affirmative….
Does Trump deserve being resisted? It certainly looks that way much of the time. But he should be resisted with facts, not innuendo of yellow paper quality. That destroys the media, and the media are needed to maintain a democracy.
Gaius’ post focuses on how the “get Trump on Russia” campaign has gone down a series of rabbit holes and his opponents are now likely to shift to “extra-Constitutional means” to remove him.
Gaius Publius hypothesizes that a constitutional crisis occurs in the U.S. every 70 years:
The Next American Constitution
One last thought. This country has had a constitutional crisis every 70 years, after which the government restructured itself. In effect, we have been ruled by three Constitutions, not just one, each producing, in practice, very different governments and societies. We’re rapidly producing a crisis that will produce a fourth.
In order, our constitutional crises are:
• 1789, the Revolutionary War and transition from colony to slave-holding republic.
• 1865, the Civil War and transition from divided slave-holding nation with two competing economies to united freed-slave state. This change took down the Southern agricultural aristocracy (by depriving it of the nearly free labor it depended on); made the Northern industrial economy nationally ascendant; and put us firmly on the path to first-world industrial powerhouse.
• 1933, the Great Depression and transition from a light-handed pro-business government to a heavy-handed regulatory state.
• And now, this.
What will the next American Constitution look like? Turkey’s and Hungary’s, with their dictators and single-party governments wrapped in the old constitutional forms? A naked kleptocracy, where constitutional forms are simply ignored, like those in many third-world countries? A state in which forms are observed but the hand with real power belongs mainly to the “security” apparatus? In many countries, coups by segments of the elite, blatant or covert, are welcomed as correctives and tacitly approved (another way constitutions are revised without being rewritten).
In the past this is what I have referred to on this page as the "Sisi Trend."

Macron's attempted third-party renewal of neoliberalism is part of this Sisi Trend, a desperate lunge to create an electoral majority to implement all the hugely unpopular policies that have pauperized so many the last 40 years (and created a new definition of the working class, the precariat).

Macron's Republic En Marche! reeks of intelligence agency dial-spinning. But already Macron is running into trouble ahead of the June 11 legislative elections in France. According to the Reuters story, "France's Macron woos conservative moderates as row simmers with ally":
Thursday's publication of Macron's partial candidate list produced the first sign of tension within his camp since he was elected.
Francois Bayrou, a centrist who gave up his presidential bid to join Macron, told L'Obs magazine that the list contained only 35 names from his Modem party, whereas he and Macron had agreed it should have 120.
"We got him elected," Bayrou told L'Obs. "This (candidate list) is a Socialist recycling operation."
Richard Ferrand, secretary general of Macron's REM party, responded to Bayrou's complaint. "There was no set agreement," he said on BFM TV, adding that there was still room for maneuver given there are more constituencies to be assigned.
It is going to be difficult for Macron to govern. The Thomas Friedman fantasy of a legislatively potent third party devoted to the toxic nostrums of neoliberalism will likely disintegrate sooner rather than later in the French parliament, allowing the West to march on to unvarnished Sisiism.

Three days before the French election the Brits vote for a new parliament. The press is savaging Labour leader Jeremy Corbyn per usual. Next to Putin and Kim Jong-un there is not a figure more reviled in the mainstream media.

A Labour campaign platform was leaked this week which sent the Tory press into a howling rage. Labour is returning to its social-democratic roots, calling for the re-nationalization of certain industries and making universities tuition free. What's not to like? Stephen Castle includes the following sidebar in  "U.K. Labour Party Approves Manifesto That May Take Sharp Left Turn":
KEY PROPOSALS IN LABOUR’S DRAFT MANIFESTO
The program includes some eye-catching policies likely to appeal to traditional party supporters and younger voters.
  • Abolish university tuition fees.
  • Provide free meals to more schoolchildren, paid for by removing the VAT exemption on private school fees.
  • Renationalize some energy companies, train operators and Royal Mail.
  • Impose a levy on companies “with high numbers of staff on very high pay.”
  • Prohibit government contracts from companies that pay bosses more than 20 times as much as the lowest earners.
  • Guarantee the rights of European Union nationals living in Britain, and "secure reciprocal rights" for British citizens living elsewhere in the bloc.
  • Ensure no rise in income tax for those earning below 80,000 pounds, or about $105,000.
It is worth taking note of Labour's attempt to exorcise its New Labour Blairite demons. Will voters reward an anti-neoliberal mass political party? We'll find out soon.