Sunday, June 7, 2020

When Does the George Floyd Rebellion Get Co-Opted?

After reading JEFFREY ST. CLAIR's "Roaming Charges: Mad Bull, Lost Its Way" I believe we're at a tipping point. If fence-sitting city councilmembers are joining the barricades and demanding the mayor pull back her troops, something has shifted.

What comes next is an attempt to co-opt and muffle the rebellion. The New York Times, for instance, has been very supportive of the uprising. Read the editorial by Jamelle Bouie, "The Police Are Rioting. We Need to Talk About It." It's excellent. But let's not forget what happened to the Women's March, splintered by turf wars and the obligatory charges of anti-Semitism, or the #Resistance, smothered in years of mainstream Russiagating. 

For the time being the mainstream mind managers are unwilling to take their foot off the accelerator. They've got Trump right where they want him. He's looking increasingly vulnerable, as vulnerable as he looked in the torchlight of Charlottesville the summer of 2017.

But a reaction will come, probably at the same time that legislation starts coursing through city councils to defund the police and replace them with social workers. Shaky Nancy Pelosi, who has gone to ground during the rebellion, will reappear to declare systemic change impossible during an economic crisis.

People must stay mobilized and continue to take to the streets. Don't be fooled by those who try to brake this movement by saying it's all a Putin plot or tainted by anti-Semitic bias. So far criticisms of violent outside agitators and Antifa anarchy have fallen flat, and so too has the Russia bogeyman. But that doesn't mean that the "Mighty Wurlitzer" won't be switched back on.

Thin Blue Line Flag: U.S. Police State's "Old Glory"

The “thin blue line” flag is the known symbol of a social, cultural, and political movement that is inextricably linked to the country’s current unrest. The flag is the centerpiece in a world of merchandise and policing philosophy, all built around the idea that the police are an embattled tribe of warriors, maligned and reviled by a nation that fails to appreciate their unique importance. The blue line is a reminder that much of the policing community sees itself as separate from the rest of society — and as the nation has witnessed in recent days, in video after shocking video, this well-armed population, imbued with the power to deprive citizens of life and liberty, does not take kindly to those who challenge its authority.
“What we’re talking about here is a worldview that says that police are the only force capable of holding society together,” Alex Vitale, a professor of sociology at Brooklyn College and author of “The End of Policing,” told me. The view turns on the notion that “without the constant threat of violent coercive intervention, society will unravel into a war of all against all,” he explained. Seen through this lens, “authoritarian solutions are not just necessary, they’re almost preferable.”
In the wake of Floyd’s killing, with protests in every state in the union and U.S. security forces at every level called to respond, the country is now witnessing what years of militarized conditioning, training, and culture have wrought: a nationwide protest movement running up against a nationwide police riot. 
Ryan Devereaux, "POLICE ATTACKS ON PROTESTERS ARE ROOTED IN A VIOLENT IDEOLOGY OF REACTIONARY GRIEVANCE"

Friday, June 5, 2020

Master-Slave Dialectic

Scrolling through the morning news what jumps out at a reader are all the smartphone videos of police brutality, an issue that Caitlin Johnstone addresses in "Smartphone Cameras Are The Windows Into Society’s Soul."

If you have had a conflict on the street with an officer of the peace, you know that this is how things usually go. The police are trained to use overwhelming force if their authority is challenged.

Recalling my university days and Hegel's Phenomenology of Spirit, this is the dynamic that guides lordship and bondage, a.k.a., the master-slave dialectic. And, FYI, it doesn't work out for the master. Overwhelming force as a solution freezes the master's consciousness, while the overwhelmed slave has to use her noggin to figure a way out of her dominated state. Off she goes to a higher stage in the dialectic.

That's where we are at now. The neoliberal state -- absent all its bells and whistles -- is reduced to gross displays of brute force to maintain fealty.

It's hard to see how it survives, even if somehow jobs were added in May.

UPDATE: The latest from Caitlin Johnstone:

A police force which cannot respond to protests about police brutality without the internet being flooded with a steady stream of police brutality footage is a police force in sore need of drastic overhaul. It has already been proven that that is in fact the case. There’s no taking it back. There’s no fixing it. It’s done. The debate is officially over. Huge, sweeping changes must immediately be made, and there’s no valid reason for the protests to stop until that has occurred.

Thursday, June 4, 2020

U.S. Military Reticent to Wage War on Domestic Population

According to The New York Times in "Esper Breaks With Trump on Using Troops Against Protesters":
Senior Pentagon leaders are now so concerned about losing public support — and that of their active-duty and reserve personnel, 40 percent of whom are people of color — that Gen. Mark A. Milley, the chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, released a message to top military commanders on Wednesday affirming that every member of the armed forces swears an oath to defend the Constitution, which he said “gives Americans the right to freedom of speech and peaceful assembly.”
American exceptionalism anyone? Or, as Peter Schwarz reports in "European media outlets fear bitter class struggles in the US":
“The image of the United States as the centre of Western civilisation is collapsing before our eyes. Will it be possible to rebuild the old image again?,” commented the Polish daily newspaper Rzeczpospolita on Tuesday with reference to the recent events in the US.
The only way to rescue U.S.-led global neoliberalism is at the point of a bayonet. Trump sees this. It won't work. But at this stage, it is the only thing that can keep the zombie ambulatory. I'm surprised it took us this long -- and a lethal global pandemic -- to arrive here.

Wednesday, June 3, 2020

Militarizing a Response to the George Floyd Rebellion Won't Work

Protests continue in Seattle. I can hear the helicopters from my apartment. 

In the nation's capital there is what appears to be a complete military occupation:
Less than two hours before Washington’s 7 p.m. curfew went into effect on Tuesday, military vehicles assumed positions across the city.
A crowd of protesters in Lafayette Square near the White House appeared to be at least twice that of a day earlier, and swelling.
With the imminent arrival of military units and the use of helicopters to suppress protesters on Monday night — a tactic used for battles with insurgents abroad, now applied on U.S. soil — some in the crowd whispered that more soldiers were on the way.
Alec, a 32-year-old protester who spent two deployments in Afghanistan, said he had seen things over the past two days that he never expected to see in his own country.
“There are real problems here,” he said, declining to give his last name because he works for the government, “and no amount of uniforms or soldiers are going to fix them.”
While the evening ended with only flashes of confrontations, the city’s downtown is being flooded with agents from the F.B.I., the Bureau of Prisons, the U.S. Marshals, Customs and Border Protection, and several other agencies, along with the military. Transportation Security Administration officers have also been called out of airports to help protect federal property.
The militarization of the response to the protest has stirred deep concerns and drawn widespread criticism, including from retired Adm. Mike Mullen, a former chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, who said that “our fellow citizens are not the enemy, and must never become so.”
“I am deeply worried that as they execute their orders, the members of our military will be co-opted for political purposes,” he wrote in an opinion piece in The Atlantic published on Tuesday, adding that America’s cities and towns “are not ‘battle spaces’ to be dominated, and must never become so.”
Trump's Wallacite/Nixonian "law & order" response is not going to solve the problem. There are not enough troops to extinguish a nationwide rebellion. Remember Eric Shinseki? He was the Army Chief of Staff during the run-up to the Bush/Cheney/Rumsfeld invasion of Iraq who rocked the boat by saying that the occupation would require several hundred thousand ground troops. The United States has a population ten times greater than the size of Iraq's 2003 population; its entire active-duty and reserve force adds up to about 2.1 million troops. Is Trump going to abandon overseas bases to occupy the homeland?

In "The George Floyd Election," Thomas Edsall susses out the ongoing rebellion's impact on the presidential election, whether it will break for the right or for the left. Edsall starts off by looking at 2020 through the prism of 1968 and the riots in wake of the Martin Luther King, Jr. assassination. It is argued that Humphrey lost because of the protest and riots of 1968 and Nixon and Wallace won.

Edsall goes on to reject parallels between '68 and 2020. For starters, the percentage of the electorate that is white has shrunk by 23% since 1968. More importantly, Trump is completely boxed by an economic collapse that will only grow worse in the near term:
What makes the moment unique is that the combination of widespread racial discontent, the pandemic and the economic implosion is taking place at a time when the scope of deprivation and need is extraordinary.
The number of people who are out of work without income now tops 40 million. There is the prospect of an “avalanche of evictions” forcing millions of renters into homelessness as legal protections and government assistance come to an end. The University of Chicago’s Becker Friedman Institute estimates that “42 percent of recent layoffs will result in permanent job loss.”

Families will increasingly begin to experience the incalculable depth of loss as the election approaches, and traditional political maneuvering will be subordinated to the less familiar and highly volatile politics of scarcity.

Scarcity can being out the best and the worst in us, but with Trump in the White House for the next seven months the likelihood of a beneficial outcome is slim to none.
This is a presidential election that pits George Wallace (Trump) against George H.W. Bush (Biden) during a Great Depression.

Tuesday, June 2, 2020

It's Not All Looting


Credit...Victor J. Blue for The New York Times

Monday, June 1, 2020

Silver Lining to George Floyd Rebellion

As COVID-19 spikes and the White House goes dark, consider this: This is just the beginning.

Civil unrest is our new normal. What happens when enhanced unemployment expires in July? What happens is a wave of evictions.

There is no indication that the federal government is able to provide leadership. States and municipalities will soon have to cut services and layoff workers. As we saw in post-Katrina New Orleans, police will simple vanish from their posts.

One silver lining to the George Floyd rebellion is that it has chased China-bashing from the front-pages of U.S. newspapers. It's hard to act as if you are a bulwark of civil liberties when the national guard is mustered and firing upon reporters:
In China, the state-run news media heavily featured reports about Mr. Floyd’s death and portrayed the protests as another sign of America’s decline. When a U.S. official on Saturday attacked the ruling Communist Party on Twitter for moving to impose national security legislation to quash dissent in Hong Kong, a spokeswoman for the Chinese government fired back with a popular refrain among protesters in the United States.
“‘I can’t breathe,’ ” the spokeswoman, Hua Chunying, wrote on Twitter.